Israeli Supreme Court Releases Two Settlers Suspected of Killing Palestinian Maatan

Elisha Yered, 22, (right), handcuffed on his way to the Jerusalem Court, is one of two settlers suspected of involvement in the killing of Qusai Maatan. (AP)
Elisha Yered, 22, (right), handcuffed on his way to the Jerusalem Court, is one of two settlers suspected of involvement in the killing of Qusai Maatan. (AP)
TT

Israeli Supreme Court Releases Two Settlers Suspected of Killing Palestinian Maatan

Elisha Yered, 22, (right), handcuffed on his way to the Jerusalem Court, is one of two settlers suspected of involvement in the killing of Qusai Maatan. (AP)
Elisha Yered, 22, (right), handcuffed on his way to the Jerusalem Court, is one of two settlers suspected of involvement in the killing of Qusai Maatan. (AP)

The Israeli Supreme Court released the two suspects accused of killing 19-year-old Palestinian Qusai Maatan and placed them under house arrest.

The court strongly criticized the police and intelligence services for not providing enough evidence, saying it did not meet the minimum standard required to establish the crime of manslaughter and that evidence submitted by the Shin Bet did not justify extending the detention.

Accordingly, Judge Zion Saharai decided to release the two settlers and transfer them to house arrest.

The police representative announced at the Jerusalem Magistrate's Court hearing that a "pathology report in Arabic" was issued about the autopsy of Maatan's body and that the police received a copy of it, including new information about the victim's shooting.

The new intelligence information changes the situation and justifies the request to extend the detention for a relatively long period.

Initially, the court extended the settlers' detention for five days, and the police charged them with causing death either on purpose or by negligence, a felony equivalent to murder, without aggravated circumstance, and obstruction of justice.

They later added nationalistically motivated arson to this list.

The defense lawyers of the suspected settlers appealed to the High Court, which postponed the release of Elisha Yered to house arrest and kept him in custody.

Judge Tamar Bar-Asher ruled that Yered should be released to house arrest because "no substantial evidence gathered thus far establishes reasonable suspicion."

The police asked to delay the settler's release until the appeal at the Supreme Court.

During the Supreme Court session, the Shin Bet provided confidential material.

However, Judge Rut Ronen refrained from including them in her ruling, saying the evidence presented by the police to prove that Yered obstructed the investigation into Maatan's death did not justify his continued detention.

Yered, who lives in the Ramat Migron settlement, is a former spokesman for Knesset member Limor Son Har-Melech of the Otzma Yehudit party, led by Minister of National Security Itamar Ben Gvir.

Yered is a "central target" for the Shin Bet.

The second suspect, Yehiel Indore, will stay in custody due to injuries sustained during the attack. The court will consider extending his detention later, noting that he is the central suspect in the fatal shooting, and the charge of obstructing the investigation has been added to him.

Israeli forces arrested four Palestinians suspected of attacking the settlers during the incident and will likely be brought to a hearing for an extension in the coming days.

According to local sources in Burqa, settlers stormed last Friday the western and northwestern parts of the village under the protection of the Israeli army forces while the villagers rushed to defend their lands.

The sources stated that the settlers brought livestock during the raid, indicating their intention to seize lands to establish a "pastoral settlement."

They pointed out that the settlers burned at least two cars during the attack.



Lebanon, Gaza Ceasefire Hopes Dim as Netanyahu Puts More Conditions

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks as he attends a ceremony for the 70th cohort of military combat officers, at an army base near Mitzpe Ramon, Israel, October 31, 2024. REUTERS/Amir Cohen
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks as he attends a ceremony for the 70th cohort of military combat officers, at an army base near Mitzpe Ramon, Israel, October 31, 2024. REUTERS/Amir Cohen
TT

Lebanon, Gaza Ceasefire Hopes Dim as Netanyahu Puts More Conditions

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks as he attends a ceremony for the 70th cohort of military combat officers, at an army base near Mitzpe Ramon, Israel, October 31, 2024. REUTERS/Amir Cohen
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks as he attends a ceremony for the 70th cohort of military combat officers, at an army base near Mitzpe Ramon, Israel, October 31, 2024. REUTERS/Amir Cohen

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told visiting US envoy Amos Hochstein and Middle East adviser Brett McGurk Thursday that any ceasefire deal with Hezbollah would have to guarantee Israeli security.

"The prime minister specified that the main issue is not paperwork for this or that deal, but Israel's determination and capacity to ensure the deal's application and to prevent any threat to its security from Lebanon," Netanyahu's office said after the meeting in Jerusalem.

Speaking at a military academy in Israel's Negev desert later Thursday, Netanyahu told reservists he appreciated American support in the ongoing wars against Hamas in Gaza and Hezbollah in Lebanon, but would not accede to any and all US demands.

"My policy is simple. I say yes when it's possible, but I say no when it's needed," he told trainee officers.

"Hamas will no longer control Gaza and Hezbollah will not settle on our northern border," he added.

"We are also blocking weapons supply chains from Iran to Hezbollah via Syria and from there to Lebanon."