Mounting Criticism over Syrian Government Failure to Manage Economic Crises

Protests in Suwayda, southern Syria, last August (file photo: AP)
Protests in Suwayda, southern Syria, last August (file photo: AP)
TT

Mounting Criticism over Syrian Government Failure to Manage Economic Crises

Protests in Suwayda, southern Syria, last August (file photo: AP)
Protests in Suwayda, southern Syria, last August (file photo: AP)

Syria's recent budget approval created a firestorm of criticism, questioning the government's ability to handle the economic crisis.

The government claims it is proceeding with its decisions to reduce the deficit, which reached unprecedented levels this year.

The initial allocations for the 2024 draft general budget amounted to SYP35,500 billion, divided into SYP26,500 billion for current spending and SYP9,000 billion for investments. The total deficit amounted to SYP9,404 billion.

Syrian economic expert Amer Shahda wrote on his Facebook page that the government's monetary policy from September 2018 until 2023 led to a profound imbalance in the distribution of national income.

The policy transferred public treasury funds from the state to a small group of financiers, representing 5% of Syrians.

He described them as a highly affluent group that gained wealth through theft, corruption, and control over economic decisions approved by the government, while 95 percent of Syrians were below the poverty line.

Shahda pointed out that the budget deficit in 2011 amounted to SYP547 billion, while the deficit in 2024 will reach more than SYP9,000 billion, in light of mismanagement and poor planning.

The government seeks to alleviate the deficit through a package of decisions that lead to removing subsidies, with successive decisions to raise fuel prices already 20% higher than those of neighboring countries.

Wage increases of 100% in late 2023 were instantly nullified by a 250% price surge and a plummeting lira, bringing the exchange rate to SYP15,000 per dollar.

Furthermore, economic journalist Ziad Ghosn criticized the government's policy, which operates with the mentality of the past, relying on tactics like "gradually lifting subsidies" instead of finding alternatives and new solutions.

Ghosn wrote an article on the Sham FM website, saying that increasing public treasury revenues requires radical changes rather than easy, traditional ones that the government resorts to, such as dramatically increasing the prices of goods and related services.

He explained that finding alternative solutions is unsuitable for a group operating in an environment that does not belong to the future.

Earlier this year, Damascus hosted several meetings and events with the participation of businessmen, chambers of industry and commerce, and government representatives who engaged in open dialogues about economic policies and the need to find ways out of the growing crises.

The General Federation of Trade Unions (GFTU) in Syria held a symposium with government officials to discuss the economic situation and wages.

Average salaries range between SYP200,000 and SYP300,000, equivalent to $13-$20, and according to local media reports, a family of four needs more than SYP10 million to survive, which is about $700.

Journalist Maad Issa said the national labor market is linked to "crises and government decisions" and that every crisis creates new job opportunities regardless of the legitimacy of these opportunities.

In an article in al-Thawra newspaper, Issa explained that the electricity crisis created entire markets for equipment in which many merchants participated without oversight.

Inflation also contributed to the emergence and maintenance of the money counter trade.

The author pointed out that this transformation caused a distortion in the work environment, and every day, Syria is losing dozens of university graduates, academics, doctors, engineers, and craftsmen who chose to leave the country for better opportunities.



Blinken Seeks to Avert Syria Turmoil with Europeans on Final Trip

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken (L) met French FM Jean-Noel Barrot in Paris. Ludovic MARIN / POOL/AFP
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken (L) met French FM Jean-Noel Barrot in Paris. Ludovic MARIN / POOL/AFP
TT

Blinken Seeks to Avert Syria Turmoil with Europeans on Final Trip

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken (L) met French FM Jean-Noel Barrot in Paris. Ludovic MARIN / POOL/AFP
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken (L) met French FM Jean-Noel Barrot in Paris. Ludovic MARIN / POOL/AFP

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken was heading on Thursday to Rome for talks with European counterparts on bringing stability to Syria in the face of flare-ups with Türkiye, capping what is likely his final trip.
Blinken had been expected to remain in Italy through the weekend to join President Joe Biden but the outgoing US leader scrapped his trip, which was to include an audience with Pope Francis, to address wildfires sweeping Los Angeles.
Blinken, on a trip that has taken him to South Korea, Japan and France, was heading on Thursday from Paris and will meet for dinner in Rome with counterparts from Britain, France, Germany and Italy.
In Paris on Wednesday, Blinken said the United States was united with the Europeans on seeking a peaceful, stable Syria, a month after the opposition factions toppled longtime ruler Bashar al-Assad.
But concerns have mounted over Türkiye’s threats against Syrian Kurdish fighters, who have effectively run their own state during the brutal civil war engulfing Syria.
A war monitor said that battles between Turkish-backed groups, supported by air strikes, and Kurdish-led forces killed 37 people on Thursday.
The Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) have worked with the United States on Washington's main stated priority -- battling the ISIS extremist group -- but Türkiye says the SDF has links with PKK militants at home.
Blinken in Paris said that Türkiye had "legitimate concerns" and that the SDF should gradually be integrated into a revamped national army, with foreign fighters removed.
"That's a process that's going to take some time. And in the meantime, what is profoundly not in the interest of everything positive we see happening in Syria would be a conflict," Blinken told reporters.
"We'll work very hard to make sure that that doesn't happen."
Blinken said he expected no change on goals in Syria from US President-elect Donald Trump, who takes over on January 20.
During his last term, Trump briefly said he would accede to a plea by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan to pull out US troops that have been working in Syria with the Kurdish forces.
But he backed down after counter-appeals led by French President Emmanuel Macron.
When to ease sanctions?
Also on the agenda in Rome will be whether and when to ease sanctions on Syria.
French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot said on Wednesday that some sanctions "could be lifted quickly".
The US Treasury Department said this week it would ease enforcement on restrictions that affect essential services.
But US officials say they will wait to see progress before any wider easing of sanctions -- and the Biden administration is unlikely in its final days to accept the political costs of removing Syria's victorious Hayat Tahrir al-Sham rebels from the US "terrorism" blacklist.
While Western powers are largely in synch on Syria, some differences remain.
Blinken reiterated US calls on European countries to repatriate citizens of theirs detained in Syria for working with the ISIS group and languishing in vast camps run by the Kurdish fighters.
France and Britain, with painful memories of attacks by homegrown extremists, have little desire to bring militants back.
The Rome talks come a week after the French and German foreign ministers, Jean-Noel Barrot and Annalena Baerbock, jointly visited Damascus and met new leader Ahmed al-Sharaa to encourage an inclusive transition.
Sharaa, has promised to protect minorities after the fall of the iron-fisted but largely secular Assad.
A senior US official in turn said last month on meeting Sharaa that Washington was dropping a $10-million bounty on his head.
Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani will pay his own visit to Syria on Friday, during which he plans to announce an initial development aid package.
Italy's hard-right government has pledged to reduce immigration. Millions of Syrians sought asylum in Europe during the civil war, triggering a backlash in some parts of the continent that shook up European politics.
In contrast to other major European powers, Italy had moved to normalize ties with Assad just weeks before he fell, presuming at the time that he had effectively won the war.