Exclusive – Lebanese Have More Faith in Private Schools than Public Ones

Syrian refugee children queue as they head towards their classroom at a school in Mount Lebanon, October 7, 2016. (Reuters)
Syrian refugee children queue as they head towards their classroom at a school in Mount Lebanon, October 7, 2016. (Reuters)
TT

Exclusive – Lebanese Have More Faith in Private Schools than Public Ones

Syrian refugee children queue as they head towards their classroom at a school in Mount Lebanon, October 7, 2016. (Reuters)
Syrian refugee children queue as they head towards their classroom at a school in Mount Lebanon, October 7, 2016. (Reuters)

The Lebanese Ministry of Education has been exerting relentless efforts to combat the challenges hindering the education sector in the country. Public schools in Lebanon have seen better days amid a drop in enrollment in the elementary and middle levels.

Lebanon boasts 1,260 public schools that teach 314,726 students and employ 42,686 teachers.

They face stiff competition from private schools, despite their higher tuition fees, which the majority of Lebanese cannot afford.

The standards of public schools dropped during the civil war and their curricula remain outdated. This was not helped by the state’s granting of scholarships to the children of military officials and state employees enrolled in private schools. Instead of improving the level of education at public schools, the state is giving further incentive for parents to turn to private ones.

Scholarships make up some 430 billion Lebanese pounds of the state’s budget, revealed a study by Information International.

Given this reality, Asharq Al-Awsat approached General Director of Education in the Ministry of Education Fadi Yarak about the condition of the education sector in Lebanon.

He disagreed with the assessment that private schools offered a better education than public ones, saying they were on equal footing whether in elementary, middle or secondary school levels.

He added that a plan had been drafted to be implemented over a five year period, between 2010 and 2015, to improve public schools, but political turmoil in Lebanon and the eruption of the Syrian conflict in 2011 hindered it.

“We need stability in order to implement these plans and reap their results from among the various generations that are enrolled in public schools,” Yarak said.

The Syrian crisis, he said, has had an impact on public school enrollment, revealing that 51 percent of the elementary and middle school students were Syrian.

Regardless of the challenges in public schools, he stated that the standard of education between them and private schools was negligible.

“Perhaps 25 percent of private schools offered strong curricula. More than 20 percent of public schools also offer high quality education. Comparing between the public and private is not justified as they are both at the same level,” he explained.

The main challenge in public schools lies in the failure in providing a good education across all schools, he went on to say. Writing, reading and math levels were uneven throughout the country and facilities for special needs students are unavailable.

These are all factors that discourage parents from enrolling their students in public schools, Yarak added.

Another important problem at public schools are the curricula that have not been updated since 1997, he remarked. This issue is the responsibility of the state’s Center for Educational Research and Development, but it has fallen victim to political meddling.

The absence of a history book that it taught at all schools is evidence of this meddling, Yarak explained. Lebanese history lessons taught at schools stop at the country’s independence in 1943 and there is no mention of the 1975-90 civil war given that many of the sectarian tensions that existed then still persist to this day.



Little Hope in Gaza that Arrest Warrants will Cool Israeli Onslaught

Palestinians gather to buy bread from a bakery, amid the Israel-Hamas conflict, in Khan Younis, in the southern Gaza Strip November 22, 2024. REUTERS/Hussam Al-Masri Purchase Licensing Rights
Palestinians gather to buy bread from a bakery, amid the Israel-Hamas conflict, in Khan Younis, in the southern Gaza Strip November 22, 2024. REUTERS/Hussam Al-Masri Purchase Licensing Rights
TT

Little Hope in Gaza that Arrest Warrants will Cool Israeli Onslaught

Palestinians gather to buy bread from a bakery, amid the Israel-Hamas conflict, in Khan Younis, in the southern Gaza Strip November 22, 2024. REUTERS/Hussam Al-Masri Purchase Licensing Rights
Palestinians gather to buy bread from a bakery, amid the Israel-Hamas conflict, in Khan Younis, in the southern Gaza Strip November 22, 2024. REUTERS/Hussam Al-Masri Purchase Licensing Rights

Gazans saw little hope on Friday that International Criminal Court arrest warrants for Israeli leaders would slow down the onslaught on the Palestinian territory, where medics said at least 24 people were killed in fresh Israeli military strikes.

In Gaza City in the north, an Israeli strike on a house in Shejaia killed eight people, medics said. Three others were killed in a strike near a bakery and a fisherman was killed as he set out to sea. In the central and southern areas, 12 people were killed in three separate Israeli airstrikes.

Meanwhile, Israeli forces deepened their incursion and bombardment of the northern edge of the enclave, their main offensive since early last month. The military says it aims to prevent Hamas fighters from waging attacks and regrouping there; residents say they fear the aim is to permanently depopulate a strip of territory as a buffer zone, which Israel denies.

Residents in the three besieged towns on the northern edge - Jabalia, Beit Lahiya and Beit Hanoun - said Israeli forces had blown up dozens of houses.

An Israeli strike hit the Kamal Adwan Hospital in Beit Lahiya, one of three medical facilities barely operational in the area, injuring six medical staff, some critically, the Gaza health ministry said in a statement, Reuters reported.

"The strike also destroyed the hospital's main generator, and punctured the water tanks, leaving the hospital without oxygen or water, which threatens the lives of patients and staff inside the hospital," it added. It said 85 wounded people including children and women were inside, eight in the ICU.

Later on Friday, the Gaza health ministry said all hospital services across the enclave would stop within 48 hours unless fuel shipments are permitted, blaming restrictions which Israel says are designed to stop fuel being used by Hamas.

Gazans saw the ICC's decision to seek the arrest of Israeli leaders for suspected war crimes as international recognition of the enclave's plight. But those queuing for bread at a bakery in the southern city of Khan Younis were doubtful it would have any impact.

"The decision will not be implemented because America protects Israel, and it can veto anything. Israel will not be held accountable," said Saber Abu Ghali, as he waited for his turn in the crowd.

Saeed Abu Youssef, 75, said even if justice were to arrive, it would be decades late: "We have been hearing decisions for more than 76 years that have not been implemented and haven't done anything for us."

Since Hamas's October 7th attack on Israel, nearly 44,000 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza, much of which has been laid to waste.

The court's prosecutors said there were reasonable grounds to believe Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant were criminally responsible for acts including murder, persecution, and starvation as a weapon of war, as part of a "widespread and systematic attack against the civilian population of Gaza".

The Hague-based court also ordered the arrest of the top Hamas commander Ibrahim Al-Masri, also known as Mohammed Deif. Israel says it has already killed him, which Hamas has not confirmed.

Israel says Hamas is to blame for all harm to Gaza's civilians, for operating among them, which Hamas denies.

Israeli politicians from across the political spectrum have denounced the ICC arrest warrants as biased and based on false evidence, and Israel says the court has no jurisdiction over the war. Hamas hailed the arrest warrants as a first step towards justice.

Efforts by Arab mediators Qatar and Egypt backed by the United States to conclude a ceasefire deal have stalled. Hamas wants a deal that ends the war, while Netanyahu has vowed the war can end only once Hamas is eradicated.