Why Are so Many Ligue 1 Clubs Sacking Their Managers?

 Rudi Garcia, Bruno Génésio and Jean-Louis Gasset are all being replaced this summer. Composite: Getty Images
Rudi Garcia, Bruno Génésio and Jean-Louis Gasset are all being replaced this summer. Composite: Getty Images
TT

Why Are so Many Ligue 1 Clubs Sacking Their Managers?

 Rudi Garcia, Bruno Génésio and Jean-Louis Gasset are all being replaced this summer. Composite: Getty Images
Rudi Garcia, Bruno Génésio and Jean-Louis Gasset are all being replaced this summer. Composite: Getty Images

With Dijon having pipped Caen to the relegation play-off spot, the dust has almost but not quite settled on the Ligue 1 season. The football is stopping but the churn of managers will continue. It is no surprise that Fabien Mercadal, who was undermined by a poor transfer market and the arrival of Rolland Courbis, has already left Caen. Nor is there much shock at the departure of Jocelyn Gourvennec from Guingamp; no amount of goodwill could save the club from relegation after a run of poor attacking performances.

The relegated clubs will take a dramatic financial hit and will probably have to sell off their best players; Caen have already lost Frédéric Guilbert to Aston Villa and various clubs around Europe are interested in signing Marcus Thuram from Guingamp. Bearing this in mind, one can hardly blame these clubs for seeking a fresh approach. But the churn is not only at the bottom.

The managers who finished first and second are at least guaranteed their jobs. Thomas Tuchel has been awarded a contract extension at PSG until 2021, which suggests the owners recognise that his shortcomings in Europe are more a product of the club’s ineptitude in the transfer market and intractability in the dressing room rather anything of his own doing.

Lille boss Christophe Galtier, who was solid if unspectacular at Saint-Étienne, has been voted manager of the year for guiding his young side to second place. This was no mean achievement for a manager known for his defensively sound approach with Saint-Étienne. Several key players – including the superb Nicolas Pépé – are likely to leave but Galtier is sticking around to lead the club into the Champions League.

While the top two are staying put, the next three clubs in the table – Lyon, Saint-Étienne and Marseille – have all parted ways with their managers. Bordeaux (twice), Monaco (twice), Dijon, Nantes, Rennes and Guingamp have also changed managers during the season. Each departure is its own story, but the common thread of ambition runs through this series of changes.

Lyon finished third under Bruno Génésio, but Jean-Michel Aulas has decided against renewing his contract this summer. Génésio was popular in the dressing room but he had clearly tested the president’s patience for the final time. They went unbeaten in their Champions League group – including a famous win over Manchester City at the Etihad – but their domestic struggles, particularly in the two cup competitions, had become a matter of frustration.

With PSG failing to win the Coupe de France or Coupe de la Ligue, Lyon were handed an ideal opportunity to secure their first trophy since 2012. However, they stumbled badly in both cups, showing an inconsistency that has plagued them in recent years. Aulas has invested considerably and expects more. Lyon are not going to be the powerhouse they were 15 years ago but Génésio’s results did not match the president’s ambition. Whether the new Brazilian power axis of manager Sylvinho and sporting director Juninho can achieve this consistency is yet to be seen, but it is clear that Aulas saw Génésio – rather than the frustrating play of Nabil Fékir or Memphis Depay – as the culprit.

Ambition would appear to be less of a motivating factor in the departure of Jean-Louis Gasset from Saint-Étienne, with the veteran manager reportedly retiring at 65. Given the success other older managers have enjoyed in recent times, it is difficult to believe that Gasset, a veteran assistant but someone who has been given precious few opportunities to lead a team, is choosing to retire. Saint Étienne’s tilt at the top three did fail at the last, but Gasset impressed in terms of his man-management and his ability to bring through young players (defender William Saliba was arguably the league’s best young player not named Mbappé in 2019), to the point that many of the club’s players have said that, if Gasset goes, they will also seek new opportunities.

With reports emerging of potential American investment at Saint-Étienne, one has to wonder whether Gasset was nudged toward the exit in a way not dissimilar to that of Rudi Garcia. Garcia has had his faults, but his departure from a Marseille project that has shown little appetite for building a cohesive sporting framework is just the latest pratfall for the impatient reign of Frank McCourt. Marseille’s season has had its wobbles but they have the makings of a young, intriguing team at the Vélodrome, and that side showed itself in flashes in winning five of six matches in March.

A heavy loss in Le Classique followed and the wind seemed to have gone out of the club’s sails but, in Garcia’s defence, he has done well to bring along the young centre-back pairing of Boubacar Kamara and Duje Caleta-Car, neither of whom seemed up to standard at the start of the season. His departure is unsurprising but it, and the exits of Génésio and Gasset, look circumspect when compared to the success that other clubs have enjoyed this season by opting for managers who have experience in the division and a healthy approach towards man-management.

Galtier is the obvious example here, but Michel Der Zakarian at Montpellier and Thierry Laurey at Strasbourg are two further examples of managers previously known for their defensive style who can keep those basic tenets in place while still offering attractive attacking football. It would be a massive shock were Galtier to be lured away from Lille by Marseille or Saint-Étienne, but both clubs could do far worse than looking towards Ligue 1 experience, rather than a quick fix in creating a plan for the future – or André Villas-Boas.

The Guardian Sport



Jesús Navas: ‘I’m Stopping because I Have To. I’m Happy with What I’ve Achieved’

Jesús Navas celebrates with the trophy in Berlin after Spain beat England to win Euro 2024. Photograph: Matt McNulty/Uefa/Getty Images via The Guardian Sport
Jesús Navas celebrates with the trophy in Berlin after Spain beat England to win Euro 2024. Photograph: Matt McNulty/Uefa/Getty Images via The Guardian Sport
TT

Jesús Navas: ‘I’m Stopping because I Have To. I’m Happy with What I’ve Achieved’

Jesús Navas celebrates with the trophy in Berlin after Spain beat England to win Euro 2024. Photograph: Matt McNulty/Uefa/Getty Images via The Guardian Sport
Jesús Navas celebrates with the trophy in Berlin after Spain beat England to win Euro 2024. Photograph: Matt McNulty/Uefa/Getty Images via The Guardian Sport

A little after 9am in Montequinto, Seville, and Jesús Navas walks past the Jesús Navas Stadium and up the little slope in the sunshine, gym to the left, training pitch to the right. The first to arrive and he’s moving OK this morning, which isn’t something he can say every day, but still he comes. Soon, too soon, he won’t. “It’s my life,” he says, “what I’ve always done, who I am.” The stand bearing his name wasn’t here when he first turned up, a quarter of a century ago. Most of this wasn’t; the trophies at the Estadio Ramón Sánchez Pizjuán, three miles north, certainly weren’t. Everything changes, except him. “I’m the same as the first day,” he says.

That day, Navas was 15, a small, skinny, shy boy from Los Palacios, 15 minutes south. It was 2000 and he has been coming almost every morning since, apart from four seasons in Manchester which he enjoyed more even than you might imagine. He is still small, slight: 5ft 7in and 67kg. Still quiet, too: warm company, but not a man with any desire for the spotlight, any delusions of grandeur. Only he is the grandest footballer of all here at Sevilla Fútbol Club.

Navas is the Spanish national team’s most-decorated player and there is a reason his name is written large where he used to train and the B team play, however strange it feels to him passing each morning: because it is written all over Sevilla’s history too. The most significant player in their 119 years, symbol of their academy and their success, their entire model. Navas played a record 393 games for Sevilla – my Sevilla, he calls them every time – left because they needed him to, came back and played 311 more. He has just one left.
On Sunday at the Santiago Bernabéu, Navas will play his 982nd professional game; aged 39, it will be his last. There has been something comfortingly familiar about him, always there, but he will depart for the last time and on Monday morning he won’t be back at Montequino. “It’s hard,” he says sitting in the players’ area, which hadn’t been built back then either. “It’s difficult for me. I still can’t imagine it. My whole life has been spent doing what I most love. And now ...” There is a pause, a look. “But in the end, it’s a question of health.”

Over four years, Navas has suffered. He has an arthritic hip which hurts when he plays, when he trains and when he walks, which some days he can’t. He continued in silence, playing longer than anyone imagined and than he should have done, but can resist no more. “I’ve put up with the pain for four years and this season has been even harder, madness,” he says. “These last six months have been very, very hard. After games it’s difficult to walk. It’s purely physical: I’m stopping because I have to. I’m happy with what I’ve achieved.”

What he has achieved is everything, nostalgia and melancholy in the memories, gratitude in the long goodbye, announced last summer and concluding this weekend. Navas says his best battles were with Roberto Carlos and it’s not that the Brazilian has long since departed; it’s that his successor, Marcelo, has been and gone too. He says the footballer he most enjoyed playing with, his best friend, is Fredi Kanouté, and Kanouté retired 11 years ago.

Asked for a moment from the many he has made, he chooses someone else’s goal, which is like him: with the clock showing 100.07 in the semi-final of the 2006 Uefa Cup against Schalke, his cross reached Antonio Puerta, who scored the winner, changing their history and their future. Puerta, whose shirt number Navas wears, collapsed on the Pizjuán pitch in August 2007, dying three days later.

When Navas made his Sevilla debut against Espanyol two days after his 19th birthday in November 2003, they had not won a trophy for 55 years; he has won eight of them. By the time he left for Manchester City in 2013, he had already played more games than anyone in the club’s history, had scored in a Copa del Rey final and lifted two Uefa Cups, the competition around which Sevilla’s entire identity became built. And still he wasn’t finished.

He returned from Manchester with a new position at full-back – “ideal”, he calls it – a Premier League title and two League Cups. He had scored in the 2014 final and in the shootout two years later. He returned with a fondness that’s clear too, continuing when the tape stops. Yet for Navas more than anyone, there was nowhere like home. “The Pizjuán,” he says. Apart from the Pizjuán? “I, er ... I wouldn’t know what to say.”

So he came back and carried on doing what he always had; different position, same Navas. He lifted two more Uefa Cups, his crosses creating goals in the 2020 and 2023 Europa League finals. Captain in Cologne and Budapest, when he lifted the trophy for the last time it was 17 years since the first.

Fourteen passed between his first and last with Spain. He won the Euros in 2012 and 2024, and the World Cup in 2010, the greatest moment in the country’s history beginning at his feet. It is one he admits watching every two or three days but couldn’t imagine even then. “All I was thinking was getting to the other end as fast as I could.” That’s it? “That’s it.” He smiles. “It’s what the manager asked,” he says; it is what he does too. Three opponents trail behind, defenders appear either side like a sequence from Captain Tsubasa, cartoonish and comic, and he just keeps running. “And then ... well, it’s the greatest thing that can happen to a kid who loves football.”

The boy who had anxiety attacks, who literally couldn’t leave home, went round the world and won it all. That he even set off was something; that he went to Manchester seemed impossible, it might as well have been Mars; that he was there in South Africa had taken care and conviction, support and strength. Navas had missed the Under-20 World Cup in 2005, had to abandon his first pre-season with Sevilla, coming and going to Huelva from home while the rest stayed in the hotel, and his full international debut was delayed until November 2009, when he had fought his way through and the conditions had been created for him to feel able to join them.

I’m proud of the trophies but the nicest thing is to take their love with me
“That first big leap came so fast,” he says. “I arrived at Sevilla at 15 and in two years I was playing in primera. For a simple kid from a small town, it was a drastic change. We’re people. On the pitch, everything was OK. But I assimilated it all bit by bit. And I have been able to enjoy football: it has given me life.”

There’s a toughness in the timidity. You’re a hard man. Navas’s response is swift, definitive: “Yes.” “It’s mental. Physical, too,” he says. “To put up with all this pain. After games it is hard to walk but here I am.

“Manchester was wonderful. Going wasn’t such a hard decision [as it seems]. Sevilla were in [financial] difficulty, that appeared, and I didn’t doubt. I wanted the challenge, to be able to say: ‘I can. I’m strong.’ What I suffered back then tested me. I wanted to grow in every way. There was a human side, a tremendous growth. The Premier League is incredible: the speed is unique and I wanted to experience that. Also, the lifestyle didn’t change really: I train, I go home. It was harder for my wife; our son had just been born and she came back every so often. But football was all I was looking for and it was incredible.”
Navas returned from City in 2017 after four seasons, 183 games, and, aged 32, supposedly nearing the end. Pep Guardiola later admitted he had let him go too soon but he understands the decision and so did everyone else. He had a season left, maybe two. It has been eight. Two more Uefa Cups. A return to the Spain squad five years later, the only man from that generation playing with this new one. “That’s the way I live; every day I want more. I never settle for anything.”

There’s that edge again: there is something in Navas’s career, his style, that speaks above all of insistence, relentlessness. Quiet he may be, but he is a competitor. “A [then] 38-year-old who trains like an 18-year-old,” Spain’s captain, Álvaro Morata, said in 2023. Navas says: “When I was in Manchester I went four, five years without being called up. Every Friday the squad was named I would be watching, waiting, hanging on the announcement. That was really, really hard. But I always held on to that hope. You keep going, keep hoping. And in the end, I was there.”
Right to the end, another winner’s medal round his neck, nothing left to give. He deputised for Dani Carvajal against Georgia, playing 85 minutes with his ankle swollen out of shape. “I’m strong in that sense. With my hip, a knock wasn’t going to force me off,” he says. “And what made us win was looking out for each other.” He faced Kylian Mbappé in the semi-final at 38, no pressure. “Well, I’ve been in football a long time and played lots of good players,” he says. And then on the eve of the final he finally revealed what he had been going through, admitting this was the end with Spain. There was no announcement, no noise, it just slipped out.

He hurt, yet held on. Six more months. Why? “Because it’s my life. I wanted to be here with my Sevilla during this transition, help the younger players. And making people happy is the most important thing.”

Last Saturday he played his last game at the Sánchez Pizjuán. “The moment I hope would never arrive has arrived,” he told his teammates before the game. As it ended, he sat on the substitutes’ bench alongside Manu Bueno, a portrait of the passage of time: the 20-year-old academy product who hadn’t been born when Navas made his Sevilla debut and trained and played at the Estadio Jesús Navas with the B team scored the only goal, the pair departing together immediately after. Navas embraced everyone, knelt and kissed the turf, sobbing as the stadium stood as one. When he lifted his shirt, he folded it so the name couldn’t be seen, only the number: Puerta’s 16.
Yet the name chanted was Navas’s, a man who belongs to everyone, universally admired in part because he never tried to be anything other than himself. “It’s hard to understand so much love,” Navas says. “People thank you for everything you’ve done, the way you are: the values my family showed me and I try to show my kids. Am I an unusual footballer? Could be. That might be why there’s affection. Because I’m normal. Because despite the pain I’m here giving everything. Because I haven’t changed. That’s what I hold on to. I’m proud of the trophies but the nicest thing is to take their love with me. Every ground I go to, there’s been applause; that’s incredible.” A teammate tells me: “You will not find a single person in football who has a bad word to say about him, still less anyone that has ever argued with him.”

One more left: the Bernabéu on Sunday. And then what? Coach? “No. People say: ‘You will because what you love is football,’ but I don’t see it. There is something I would like to do, something there in my mind,” Navas says. “I always followed Miguel Indurain. I love watching Pogacar and Vingegaard. It was always about football for me as a kid, but in the summer it would be the Tour de France. I’d like to cycle, and do it properly. It will be something I try, for sure. I can’t go out there just to pass the time, no. I’m not like that. I compete, give everything. Cycling is hard and I like that. I’ve been competing all my life and I have that ‘itch’.”

It’s almost time. Navas’s teammates start arriving, the last of hundreds he has had, all of them marked by him. Outside the sun is shining, once more into the fray. “Football is everything, my life. It’s what I’ve always done, every day,” he says. “I’ll have to look for something else, keep doing sport. And the bike is non-impact, it doesn’t hurt my hip. But today, I train. To the end. That’s what brought me this far.”

 

The Guardian Sport