German Court Hands ISIS Member Life in Yazidi Genocide Case

30 November 2021, Hessen, Frankfurt_Main: Iraqi defendant Taha Al-J. (L) covers his face with a folder as he enters the courtroom of the Frankfurt's Higher Regional Court before a verdict is pronounced. Photo: Frank Rumpenhorst/dpa-Pool/dpa
30 November 2021, Hessen, Frankfurt_Main: Iraqi defendant Taha Al-J. (L) covers his face with a folder as he enters the courtroom of the Frankfurt's Higher Regional Court before a verdict is pronounced. Photo: Frank Rumpenhorst/dpa-Pool/dpa
TT

German Court Hands ISIS Member Life in Yazidi Genocide Case

30 November 2021, Hessen, Frankfurt_Main: Iraqi defendant Taha Al-J. (L) covers his face with a folder as he enters the courtroom of the Frankfurt's Higher Regional Court before a verdict is pronounced. Photo: Frank Rumpenhorst/dpa-Pool/dpa
30 November 2021, Hessen, Frankfurt_Main: Iraqi defendant Taha Al-J. (L) covers his face with a folder as he enters the courtroom of the Frankfurt's Higher Regional Court before a verdict is pronounced. Photo: Frank Rumpenhorst/dpa-Pool/dpa

A man was sentenced to life in prison by a German court on Tuesday in a landmark trial regarding crimes committed by ISIS against the Yazidi people in Iraq.

The Frankfurt Higher Regional Court found Taha Al-J, an Iraqi native whose full name was not released for legal reasons, guilty of genocide and a war crime resulting in the death of an enslaved Yazidi girl, the German News Agency (dpa) reported.

He must also pay damages of 50,000 euros (56,391 dollars) to the girl's mother.

Presiding judge Christoph Koller said it was the world's first verdict for crimes committed by ISIS against the Yazidi minority.

During the preliminary remarks on the reasons for the verdict, the defendant slumped in the courtroom and the session was interrupted.

Al-J was found guilty of having kept and abused a Yazidi woman and her daughter as slaves between July and September 2015. To punish the 5-year-old, he tied her to a window grate in the courtyard of the property in Fallujah in sweltering heat, where the child died of thirst.

Jennifer W, Al-J's former wife, was sentenced to 10 years in prison by the Munich Higher Regional Court in October. As a witness in the trial against Al-J, she had described her former husband as violent.

Al-J himself has not commented on the accusations against him.

Judge Koller spoke of the special meaning of the term genocide as a violation of international law. "Whoever violates this law violates the law of all states in the world," dpa quoted him as saying.

Therefore, even if neither the victim nor the perpetrator were German citizens and the crime had taken place outside Germany's borders, the Frankfurt court could pronounce justice.

Koller went into detail about the ideology of ISIS and the crimes against the Yazidis, about the enslavement of Yazidi women and girls, about rapes - which had been commonplace - and about the slave trade.

Al-J had shared the ideology, aimed at the destruction of the Yazidis, the court found.

Addressing the mother of the dead girl, Koller thanked the slender, stooped woman for testifying on a total of seven trial days. All those involved in the trial had been "deeply moved" by her account, he said. "We wish that you succeed in bearing your suffering and that you find peace," he said.

There was no exchange of glances between the mother, identified as Nora B, and Al-J during the pronouncement of the verdict.

Nora B, who according to the court still suffers severely from her experiences and requires psychological care, kept her eyes fixed on the ground. Al-J took notes and listened intently to his interpreters.

Al-J had accepted responsibility for the death of the child, but had not intended for her to die, the court stated in its verdict. He had tried to give the unconscious girl water and had taken her to a hospital.

Tuesday's verdict is not final. Immediately after the verdict was announced, the defense announced its intention to appeal.

A lawyer for Al-J spoke of a "very harsh sentence," adding, "We have the impression that our client has been sentenced vicariously for the atrocities of ISIS."

"Today's verdict has a strong signal effect beyond the individual case," the representative of the Office of the Attorney General of Germany stressed. "It is the first judgement in the world to establish that ISIS’ actions against members of the Yazidi religion amounted to genocide."

He said it was a warning to perpetrators of the most serious crimes under international law "that they can be held accountable - no matter where they are."



Uncertainty Looms for Germany after Scholz Coalition Collapses

09 October 2024, Saxony, Leipzig: German Chancellor Olaf Scholz speaks during the 35th anniversary of the peaceful revolution in Leipzig, at the Geandhaus.  Photo: Sebastian Kahnert/dpa-Pool/dpa
09 October 2024, Saxony, Leipzig: German Chancellor Olaf Scholz speaks during the 35th anniversary of the peaceful revolution in Leipzig, at the Geandhaus. Photo: Sebastian Kahnert/dpa-Pool/dpa
TT

Uncertainty Looms for Germany after Scholz Coalition Collapses

09 October 2024, Saxony, Leipzig: German Chancellor Olaf Scholz speaks during the 35th anniversary of the peaceful revolution in Leipzig, at the Geandhaus.  Photo: Sebastian Kahnert/dpa-Pool/dpa
09 October 2024, Saxony, Leipzig: German Chancellor Olaf Scholz speaks during the 35th anniversary of the peaceful revolution in Leipzig, at the Geandhaus. Photo: Sebastian Kahnert/dpa-Pool/dpa

Germany enters a period of political uncertainty Thursday after its fragile three-party ruling coalition collapsed on the same day Donald Trump won the US election.
Chancellor Olaf Scholz -- who announced a January confidence vote, likely followed by snap elections in March -- will seek to reassure his European partners at a summit in Budapest.
Scholz said late Wednesday he would reach out to conservative opposition leader Friedrich Merz, who is leading in opinion polls, for support in passing crucial bills on the economy and defense, said AFP.
The end of his fractious three-way coalition, which deprives him of a governing majority, could not have come at a worse time for Europe's biggest economy, which is set to shrink for a second year in a row.
"The early end of the coalition leaves Germany somewhat rudderless in what could be an exceptionally turbulent time right after Donald Trump won the US election," wrote Berenberg bank analyst Holger Schmieding.
But Schmieding said a snap election and new leadership in early 2025 may ultimately help as "the constant bickering within the now-defunct three-party coalition had turned into a major obstacle to growth".
Scholz heads to an EU summit in Budapest on Thursday to discuss multiple global crises, chiefly Ukraine's war with Russia and the Middle East conflict, all impacted by the looming change in the White House.
EU leaders are gathering for the talks hosted by Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, a Trump supporter and one of the EU's main skeptics of support for Kyiv.
'Petty political tactics'
After months of bitter infighting, the three-way coalition between Scholz's Social Democrats (SPD), the Greens and the business-friendly Free Democrats (FDP) finally broke apart on Wednesday night.
In a shock power move, Scholz sacked his troublesome finance minister Christian Lindner, forcing the FDP out of the coalition and leaving the SPD and the Greens ruling in a precarious minority government.
The German leader said he would seek a vote of confidence by January 15 so lawmakers can decide whether to call early elections which could be held six months earlier than a previously scheduled September vote.
Until then, the minority government will only be able to pass some laws, on a case-by-case basis, if it wins opposition backing.
The usually softly spoken Scholz on Wednesday had strong words for Lindner, declaring there was no longer any "basis of trust" between them.
He bitterly attacked the ousted finance minister for his "petty political tactics" and accused him of a level of egoism that is "completely incomprehensible".
The FDP, the smallest party in the coalition, had long disagreed with the SPD and the Greens on a range of issues, most strikingly how to carve up a tight budget and jumpstart the troubled German economy.
Lindner had repeatedly flirted with bolting the unhappy coalition and warned of "an autumn of decisions" as a deadline loomed for difficult fiscal negotiations next week.
Scholz declared that "we now need clarity on how we can soundly finance our security and defense in the coming years without jeopardizing the cohesion of the country".
"With a view to the election in America, this is perhaps more urgent than ever."
'No tactical delays'
Scholz said he had offered Lindner a plan with steps to bring down energy costs and boost investment for German companies, secure auto industry jobs and keep up support for Ukraine.
But Lindner -- a fiscal hawk and strong opponent of raising new debt -- had shown "no willingness" to accept it, Scholz said, adding that "I no longer want to subject our country to such behavior".
Scholz and his mutinous coalition partners have drawn withering fire from Merz, the leader of the opposition CDU-CSU alliance, which has long demanded early elections.
"We cannot afford to argue for another year," CDU lawmaker Norbert Roettgen said after Trump's victory and before the coalition bust-up. "Germany is important in Europe, and if the government can't live up to that, then it must make way now."
On Wednesday, the head of the CSU in the southern state of Bavaria, Markus Soeder, demanded an immediate vote of confidence, warning that "there must be no tactical delays".
Recent opinion polls give the CDU/CSU alliance around 32 percent support -- more than the combined total of the SPD with 16 percent, the Greens with 11 percent and the FDP with only about four percent.
The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) has recently scored close to 20 percent, but so far all other parties have vowed not to cooperate with it.
On current trends, the conservatives, if they win, would still need a coalition ally for a majority.
This raises the longer-term prospect that they could bring the SPD back on board in a left-right "grand coalition" of the two traditional big-tent parties.