Syrian Doctor in German Torture Trial Denies Atrocities

Alaa Mousa practised medicine in Germany until his arrest in 2020 Boris Roessler POOL/AFP/File
Alaa Mousa practised medicine in Germany until his arrest in 2020 Boris Roessler POOL/AFP/File
TT

Syrian Doctor in German Torture Trial Denies Atrocities

Alaa Mousa practised medicine in Germany until his arrest in 2020 Boris Roessler POOL/AFP/File
Alaa Mousa practised medicine in Germany until his arrest in 2020 Boris Roessler POOL/AFP/File

A Syrian doctor on trial in Germany for torture and murder while working in military hospitals in his war-torn homeland on Tuesday denied setting fire to a teenage boy's genitals or operating on detainees without anesthesia.

Alaa Mousa, 36, who arrived in Germany in 2015 and practiced medicine in the country until his arrest five years later, is on trial for crimes against humanity.

Taking the stand, he told judges at the higher regional court in Frankfurt that he "felt sorry" for patients who were beaten and blindfolded.

He firmly denied allegations of dousing a teenage boy's genitals in alcohol before setting them alight, saying he "did not do that".

He also said he did not strike detainees, and "would never" have operated on a patient without anesthesia, as prosecutors accuse him of doing, AFP reported.

Instead, Mousa told the court he felt sympathy for detainees.

"I saw the military secret service beating injured detainees. I felt sorry for them, but I couldn't say anything, or it would have been me instead of the patient," Mousa told the court.

Mousa stands accused of 18 counts of torturing detainees in Damascus and the western city of Homs in 2011-12.

He also faces one count of murder for allegedly administering a lethal injection to a prisoner who resisted being beaten, according to federal prosecutors.

His case is the second landmark trial in Germany over atrocities committed by the Syrian regime during the country's civil war.

Earlier this month, another German court sentenced a former Syrian colonel to life in jail for overseeing the murders of 27 people and the torture of 4,000 others at a Damascus detention center a decade ago.

Describing his time at the military hospital in Homs in 2011, after Arab Spring protests against President Bashar al-Assad's regime led to a brutal crackdown, Mousa said so many opposition demonstrators were brought in with injuries that it was "chaos".

Some of the detainees showed signs of having been tortured or beaten, he said.

But Mousa, a civilian doctor, never asked questions, having been told by his supervisor that the military secret service was "in control" of the hospital.

On one occasion, Mousa said he witnessed a blindfolded patient, his hands tied behind his back, being beaten by military secret service and some of the military medical staff working at the hospital.

"I was very scared of the military secret service and also of the medical staff that just joined in," he told the court.

He also said he thought it was "inhumane" to keep patients blindfolded while they were being sutured or otherwise treated.

Asked whether he felt sympathy for the demonstrators, Mousa said neither he nor his family were political activists. "But I also wasn't a super supporter of the regime."

The anti-Assad protests started off peacefully, he recalled, but he said they quickly turned more "radical". "I'm against violence on either side," he added.

Mousa will address the other charges he faces on Thursday.

Prosecutors in Frankfurt say Syria's military hospitals play a key role in Assad's state-sponsored torture system, and that Mousa helped to perpetrate "a systematic attack on the civilian population".

Mousa left Syria for Germany in mid-2015, on a visa for skilled workers.

He worked in several places as an orthopaedic doctor, including in the picturesque spa town of Bad Wildungen. He was arrested in June 2020 after Syrian witnesses came forward.

The proceedings in Germany are enabled by the legal principle of "universal jurisdiction", which allows crimes of exceptional gravity to be prosecuted even if they were committed in a different country.

A German woman who moved to Syria aged 15 to join the ISIS group went on trial in the eastern city of Halle on Tuesday, accused of aiding and abetting crimes against humanity.



Israeli Minister Says Army Applying Lessons from Gaza in West Bank Operation

Israeli soldiers run to take position in Jenin camp during the second day of an Israeli military operation in the West Bank city of Jenin, 22 January 2025. (EPA)
Israeli soldiers run to take position in Jenin camp during the second day of an Israeli military operation in the West Bank city of Jenin, 22 January 2025. (EPA)
TT

Israeli Minister Says Army Applying Lessons from Gaza in West Bank Operation

Israeli soldiers run to take position in Jenin camp during the second day of an Israeli military operation in the West Bank city of Jenin, 22 January 2025. (EPA)
Israeli soldiers run to take position in Jenin camp during the second day of an Israeli military operation in the West Bank city of Jenin, 22 January 2025. (EPA)

Israel's defense minister said on Tuesday forces were applying lessons learned in Gaza as a major operation continued in Jenin which the military said was aimed at countering Iranian-backed armed groups in the volatile West Bank city.

A military spokesperson declined to give details but said the operation was "relatively similar" to but in a smaller area than one last August, in which hundreds of Israeli troops backed by drones and helicopters raided Jenin and other flashpoint cities in the occupied West Bank.

It was the third major incursion by the Israeli army in less than two years into Jenin, a longtime major stronghold of armed groups including Hamas and Islamic Jihad, which said its forces were fighting Israeli troops.

At least four Palestinians were wounded on Tuesday, after 10 were killed a day earlier, Palestinian health services said, and residents reported constant gunfire and explosions.

Israeli military spokesperson Nadav Shoshani said the fighters' increasing use of roadside bombs and other improvised explosive devices were a particular focus of the operation, which included armored bulldozers to tear up roads in the refugee camp adjacent to the city.

As the operation continued, many Palestinians left their homes in the camp, a crowded township for descendants of Palestinians who fled or were driven from their homes in the 1948 war of Israel's creation.

"Thank God, we were at home, we went out and asked an ambulance to take us out," said a woman who gave her name as Um Mohammad.

Before the raid, which came two weeks after a shooting attack blamed by Israel on gunmen from Jenin, roadblocks and checkpoints had been thrown up across the West Bank in an effort to slow down movement across the territory.

As the raid began, Palestinian Authority (PA) security forces pulled out after having conducted a weeks-long operation to try to reassert control over the refugee camp, dominated by Palestinian factions that are hostile to the PA, which exercises limited governance in parts of the West Bank.

The operation came just two days after the launch of a ceasefire deal in Gaza and exchange of hostages for Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli jails, with Israeli troops pulling back from their positions in many areas of the enclave.

LEARNING FROM GAZA

Defense Minister Israel Katz said the Jenin raid marked a shift in the military's security plan in the West Bank and was "the first lesson from the method of repeated raids in Gaza".

"We will not allow the arms of the Iranian regime and radical Sunni Islam to endanger the lives of (Israeli) settlers (in the West Bank) and establish a terrorist front east of the state of Israel," he said in a statement.

Israel's campaign in Gaza, following the Oct. 7, 2023 attack on Israel by bands of Hamas-led gunmen, has left much of the coastal enclave in ruins after 15 months of bombardment. The military has said it has refined its urban warfare tactics in the light of its experience in Gaza, but Shoshani declined to provide details of how such lessons were being applied in Jenin.

Israel considers Palestinian armed groups such as Hamas and Islamic Jihad that are backed by Iran as part of a multifront war waged by an axis that includes Hezbollah in southern Lebanon and the Houthis in Yemen.

Newly installed US President Donald Trump has appointed a string of senior officials with close ties to the settler movement, and his return to the White House has been welcomed by hardline pro-settler ministers who have pledged to expand settlement building in the West Bank.

Around 700,000 Israeli settlers live among 2.7 million Palestinians in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, land Israel seized in the 1967 Middle East war. Most countries deem Israel's settlements on territory taken in war to be illegal. Israel disputes this, citing historical and biblical ties to the land.