Turkish Opposition Calls New Media Law ‘Censorship’, Will Appeal to Top Court

Lawmakers from Türkiye's main opposition Republican People's Party hold up placards protesting against the passing of a new bill at the parliament, in Ankara, Türkiye, Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP)
Lawmakers from Türkiye's main opposition Republican People's Party hold up placards protesting against the passing of a new bill at the parliament, in Ankara, Türkiye, Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP)
TT

Turkish Opposition Calls New Media Law ‘Censorship’, Will Appeal to Top Court

Lawmakers from Türkiye's main opposition Republican People's Party hold up placards protesting against the passing of a new bill at the parliament, in Ankara, Türkiye, Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP)
Lawmakers from Türkiye's main opposition Republican People's Party hold up placards protesting against the passing of a new bill at the parliament, in Ankara, Türkiye, Tuesday, Oct. 11, 2022. (AP)

Türkiye’s main opposition group said on Friday it would ask the top court to throw out new media legislation that would jail people for spreading "misinformation", calling the measures unprecedented censorship.

Parliament adopted the law late on Thursday after it was proposed by President Tayyip Erdogan's ruling AK Party (AKP), which says it aims to regulate online publications, protect the country and combat disinformation.

The bill had drawn criticism from Türkiye’s Western allies and rights groups who said its vague reference to "false or misleading information" can be interpreted differently by courts to punish those critical of the government.

The law's Article 29 says those who spread false information about Türkiye’s security to "create fear and disturb public order" will face a prison sentence of one to three years. The bill still needs to be approved by the president.

"We are talking about a law that is the most oppressive in our history and the law that contains the most censorship," Burak Erbay, a member of the opposition Republican People's Party (CHP), said.

He said the party would file an application to the Constitutional Court as soon as the "Law on Amending the Press Law" was published in the Official Gazette.

"We believe the biggest censorship law in history will be reversed by the Constitutional Court and this law will be annulled. It is a regulation that takes us down to the level of underdeveloped societies," Erbay told Reuters.

The AKP's nationalist allies MHP joined it in voting to approve the bill, while opposition parties opposed it.

The AKP has dismissed the criticism and says it opposes censorship, adding the law aims to protect everyone from false accusations on social media.

The pro-government Sabah newspaper said a "safe era" in social media had begun. It said the regulations would improve national safety by allowing the immediate removal of content that would endanger public peace.

Tight election

Hundreds of journalists have been jailed in a crackdown following a 2016 coup attempt, mainly on terrorism charges. Ankara has defended the measures as a necessary response to the scale of the security threat facing Türkiye.

People have also been tried over social media posts including ones that criticize Türkiye’s incursions in Syria or are seen as insulting the president, considered a crime in Türkiye.

Ozgur Ogret, Türkiye representative for the Committee to Protect Journalists, said the new law poses a danger not only for journalists but all citizens and could increase self-censorship ahead of elections set for next year.

"This law will hinder the free flow of information in the election atmosphere," he said after a press freedom event organized by the International Press Institute in Istanbul.

"Freedom of expression is always important but in an election atmosphere, it is really crucial for everybody to speak their minds and voters to decide on solid information".

Election polls show Erdogan could lose to an opposition candidate if a presidential election were held today - and that the opposition bloc would win a majority in parliament.

Arda Guzel, a student in Ankara, said the new law aimed to stifle dissenting voices on social media and prevent the opposition from garnering more votes.

"Because people nowadays look at social media more than mainstream media, they can access negative news about the government faster," he said.

"They passed this law to counter these news stories."



Russia Says French Citizen Pleads Guilty to Illegally Collecting Military Details

People walk on the Red Square outside the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia, 02 July 2024. The temperature in Moscow exceeded 32 degrees Celsius. EPA/MAXIM SHIPENKOV
People walk on the Red Square outside the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia, 02 July 2024. The temperature in Moscow exceeded 32 degrees Celsius. EPA/MAXIM SHIPENKOV
TT

Russia Says French Citizen Pleads Guilty to Illegally Collecting Military Details

People walk on the Red Square outside the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia, 02 July 2024. The temperature in Moscow exceeded 32 degrees Celsius. EPA/MAXIM SHIPENKOV
People walk on the Red Square outside the Kremlin in Moscow, Russia, 02 July 2024. The temperature in Moscow exceeded 32 degrees Celsius. EPA/MAXIM SHIPENKOV

Russian investigators said on Wednesday that French researcher Laurent Vinatier, who was detained last month and accused of failing to register as a foreign agent while illegally collecting sensitive military information, had pleaded guilty during questioning.

Vinatier, an expert with long experience of working in Russia, was shown last month being arrested in a central Moscow restaurant by masked officers from the Federal Security Service (FSB), the main successor to the Soviet-era KGB.
He is accused of failing to register as a foreign agent and intentionally collecting military information which could be used by foreign intelligence services to damage the security of Russia, Reuters reported.
French President Emmanuel Macron denied that Vinatier, an employee of the Center for Humanitarian Dialogue (HD), a Swiss-based conflict mediation group, worked for the French state. Macron described his arrest as part of a disinformation campaign by Moscow.
"The French citizen has pleaded guilty in a criminal case on illegal collection of information in the field of Russian military activities," Russia's Investigative Committee said in a statement.
"During the interrogation, he admitted his guilt in full."
A representative of HD had no immediate comment.
Russian investigators said that Vinatier had for several years failed to comply with the Russian law on foreign agents and had collected military information at meetings with Russian citizens.
The Investigative Committee said that seven witnesses who Vinatier had tried to collect military information from had been questioned - and that it had recordings of some of their meetings.
"A linguistic forensic examination has been scheduled based on audio recordings of these meetings," the committee said.
In a statement following Vinatier's arrest, his employer HD said: "In the course of HD’s activities as an impartial and independent mediation organization, our people work around the world and routinely meet with a wide range of officials, experts and other parties with the aim of advancing efforts to prevent, mitigate and resolve armed conflict."
Vinatier, 47, could face up to five years in prison. He was placed in pre-trial custody until Aug. 5, despite a request to free him endorsed by the French embassy.