Israel Won't Supply Ukraine with Iron Dome System

A missile was launched from the Iron Dome near Ashdod, southern Israel (File photo: AFP)
A missile was launched from the Iron Dome near Ashdod, southern Israel (File photo: AFP)
TT

Israel Won't Supply Ukraine with Iron Dome System

A missile was launched from the Iron Dome near Ashdod, southern Israel (File photo: AFP)
A missile was launched from the Iron Dome near Ashdod, southern Israel (File photo: AFP)

Several Israeli ministers leaked information that the army and other security services in Tel Aviv were against providing Ukraine with the Iron Dome anti-missile system, fearing it could lead to a more significant crisis with Russia, which in turn would supply Syria with similar designs, and the S-300 and S-400 missiles.

A security official said Thursday that relations with Russia are already tense due to Israel's support of Ukraine.

Tensions increased after reports claimed that Israeli intelligence provided information to Ukraine about the secrets of Iranian drones used by Russia.

According to informed sources, for the past four weeks, the Israeli army halted all operations in Syria over the past four weeks, fearing Russian interference, noting that the last Israeli raid in Syria took place on Sept. 16-17.

Recent statements of Defense Minister Benny Gantz created controversy within Israel after he announced that Tel Aviv would not provide Ukraine with advanced defense systems, noting that the government offered to provide Ukraine with expertise that would allow the development of an intelligent approach to counter air threats.

It seems that this public announcement came with an official decision taken after security deliberations on Tuesday, during which it was decided to issue clear statements refusing to provide Ukraine with weapons to avoid escalation with Russia.

The position aroused strong criticism in Tel Aviv, especially among the left-wing and liberal forces that demand a clear stand in support of Ukraine, but Gantz rejected the criticism, saying that friends in the West understand Israel's sensitive position.

A close associate of Gantz pointed out that Israel's refusal to provide Ukraine with the Iron Dome system to intercept short-range missiles and drones also stems from professional reasons.

He indicated that this anti-missile system is unsuitable for Ukraine because of the country's large area, noting that the Russian aircraft that controls the Ukrainian airspace will be able to target the convoys transporting it from one place to another.

An official source in the Israeli Defense Ministry confirmed that Gantz is coordinating his positions, especially with his Ukrainian counterpart, Alexei Reznikov, noting that the Prime Minister and Foreign Minister, Yair Lapid, also discussed with Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba.

The source revealed that Kuleba submitted an official request to Israel three days ago to obtain the Iron Dome and other advanced weapons.

He noted that Iran's involvement in the battle creates a new situation that worries Israel, adding that the Iranians are testing their weapons through the Russian army and practically training for war against Israel and other enemies in the Middle East.



Russia Condemns ‘Irresponsible’ Talk of Nuclear Weapons for Ukraine

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov attends a press conference of Russian President Vladimir Putin speaks at the BRICS summit in Kazan, Russia October 24, 2024. (Reuters)
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov attends a press conference of Russian President Vladimir Putin speaks at the BRICS summit in Kazan, Russia October 24, 2024. (Reuters)
TT

Russia Condemns ‘Irresponsible’ Talk of Nuclear Weapons for Ukraine

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov attends a press conference of Russian President Vladimir Putin speaks at the BRICS summit in Kazan, Russia October 24, 2024. (Reuters)
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov attends a press conference of Russian President Vladimir Putin speaks at the BRICS summit in Kazan, Russia October 24, 2024. (Reuters)

Discussion in the West about arming Ukraine with nuclear weapons is "absolutely irresponsible", Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Tuesday, in response to a report in the New York Times citing unidentified officials who suggested such a possibility.

The New York Times reported last week that some unidentified Western officials had suggested US President Joe Biden could give Ukraine nuclear weapons before he leaves office.

"Several officials even suggested that Mr. Biden could return nuclear weapons to Ukraine that were taken from it after the fall of the Soviet Union. That would be an instant and enormous deterrent. But such a step would be complicated and have serious implications," the newspaper wrote.

Asked about the report, Peskov told reporters: "These are absolutely irresponsible arguments of people who have a poor understanding of reality and who do not feel a shred of responsibility when making such statements. We also note that all of these statements are anonymous."

Earlier, senior Russian security official Dmitry Medvedev said that if the West supplied nuclear weapons to Ukraine then Moscow could consider such a transfer to be tantamount to an attack on Russia, providing grounds for a nuclear response.

Ukraine inherited nuclear weapons from the Soviet Union after its 1991 collapse, but gave them up under a 1994 agreement, the Budapest Memorandum, in return for security assurances from Russia, the United States and Britain.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy said last month that as Ukraine had handed over the nuclear weapons, joining NATO was the only way it could deter Russia.

The 33-month Russia-Ukraine war saw escalations on both sides last week, after Ukraine fired US and British missiles into Russia for the first time, with permission from the West, and Moscow responded by launching a new hypersonic intermediate-range missile into Ukraine.

Asked about the risk of a nuclear escalation, Peskov said the West should "listen carefully" to Putin and read Russia's newly updated nuclear doctrine, which lowered the threshold for using nuclear weapons.

Separately, Russian foreign intelligence chief Sergei Naryshkin said Moscow opposes simply freezing the conflict in Ukraine because it needs a "solid and long-term peace" that resolves the core reasons for the crisis.