UN Experts Say Arrest of Belgian Citizen in Iran Violates Int’l Law

An undated photograph made available by the family of Bernard Phelan on January 18, 2023, shows French-Irish citizen Bernard Phelan in an undisclosed location. (Photo by Handout / FAMILY HANDOUT / AFP)
An undated photograph made available by the family of Bernard Phelan on January 18, 2023, shows French-Irish citizen Bernard Phelan in an undisclosed location. (Photo by Handout / FAMILY HANDOUT / AFP)
TT

UN Experts Say Arrest of Belgian Citizen in Iran Violates Int’l Law

An undated photograph made available by the family of Bernard Phelan on January 18, 2023, shows French-Irish citizen Bernard Phelan in an undisclosed location. (Photo by Handout / FAMILY HANDOUT / AFP)
An undated photograph made available by the family of Bernard Phelan on January 18, 2023, shows French-Irish citizen Bernard Phelan in an undisclosed location. (Photo by Handout / FAMILY HANDOUT / AFP)

UN rights experts have condemned Iran’s “arbitrary” detention of Belgian aid worker Olivier Vandecasteele and demanded his immediate release.

“We believe Mr. Vandecasteele has been arbitrarily deprived of his liberty and is a victim of enforced disappearance for periods of detention,” the independent UN human rights experts said in a statement.

“His right to a fair trial before an independent and impartial tribunal has been violated. These are flagrant violations of Iran’s obligations under international law,” they said.

Vandecasteele, 40, was arrested on February 24, 2022.

In their statement, the UN experts declared that he had suffered ill-treatment in detention and that his health condition was critical.

Vandecasteele had been sentenced to 40 years of imprisonment and 74 lashes on charges of espionage against Iran, cooperating with the US, currency smuggling, and money laundering.

Under Iranian law, Vandecasteele is eligible for appeal after 12 years and six months.

“We are gravely concerned over the mental and physical health of Mr. Vandecasteele,” the experts said. “Mr. Vandecasteele requires special attention and medication.” 

Belgian-Iranian ties have been tense since the arrest of Iranian diplomat Asadollah Asadi who was sentenced to 20 years in prison in Belgium over plots to stage a “terrorist” attack against the Iranian opposition.

The statement urged Iran to release the many foreign and dual national citizens who remain arbitrarily detained in Iran and condemned the execution on January 14 of the British-Iranian, Alireza Akbari.

Moreover, France is extremely worried about the health of Bernard Phelan, a French-Irish citizen held in Iran since October 2022, who relatives say is on hunger strike, the foreign ministry said on Tuesday.

Local media reported that a German national was also arrested.

"He is showing serious signs of physical and psychological exhaustion," said a French diplomatic source, adding he was in a "critical state."

The Iranian authorities have so far refused to release Phelan on medical grounds despite repeated requests from the French and Irish authorities, the source said.

The French Foreign Ministry said Phelan was one of seven French nationals currently held arbitrarily by Iran, and Paris was “extremely worried about his health, which is poor and requires appropriate medical monitoring, which is not ensured in detention”.

Phelan’s sister, Caroline Masse-Phelan, told AFP her brother had started a dry hunger strike on Monday, refusing water, in addition to the food hunger strike he had been on since the start of the year.

“We are stepping up the pressure on Iran, in coordination with the Irish government, to ensure that our compatriot is released without delay,” the French foreign ministry said.

Tehran is accused of using western nationals to put pressure on the West.



Erdogan, Barzani Discuss Critical Files in Ankara

Erdogan and Barzani during their talks in Ankara on Wednesday (Turkish Presidency)
Erdogan and Barzani during their talks in Ankara on Wednesday (Turkish Presidency)
TT

Erdogan, Barzani Discuss Critical Files in Ankara

Erdogan and Barzani during their talks in Ankara on Wednesday (Turkish Presidency)
Erdogan and Barzani during their talks in Ankara on Wednesday (Turkish Presidency)

The President of Iraq’s Kurdistan Region, Nechirvan Barzani, visited Türkiye at a critical time for both Ankara and Erbil, amid regional tensions, particularly with Israel expanding the scope of war in the region.
Before meeting with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Barzani held discussions with Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan and intelligence chief Ibrahim Kalin.
According to a statement from the Turkish Presidency’s Directorate of Communications, the meeting between Erdogan and Barzani at the presidential palace on Wednesday covered relations between Ankara and Erbil, regional security issues, and energy concerns.
Discussions also touched on Türkiye’s relations with Baghdad and Erbil, as well as regional developments amid the Israeli escalation and the potential impact of the war between Israel and Hezbollah in Lebanon on Iraq and other countries.
Barzani’s visit to the Turkish capital also comes amid growing signals of a new initiative to resolve the Kurdish issue in Türkiye. The visit precedes the upcoming parliamentary elections in Iraq’s Kurdistan Region, scheduled for this Sunday, after being postponed for two years.
The Turkish presidency’s statement indicated that Erdogan expressed hope for peaceful and inclusive elections and, in discussing the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza and its spillover into Lebanon, warned of the risk that Israeli aggression could lead to a broader regional war. He emphasized his country’s commitment to regional stability and security and praised the Iraqi authorities’ efforts to keep the country out of the conflict.
Türkiye views Iraq’s stability as crucial for the future of the region and aims to improve relations with Baghdad. Ankara places great importance on resolving issues between the central government in Baghdad and the Erbil government, with which it has built close ties, particularly in security, economy, and energy.
According to Turkish sources speaking to Asharq Al-Awsat, these matters were thoroughly discussed during Barzani’s meetings with Turkish foreign and intelligence officials, as well as in his meeting with Erdogan. Security cooperation, particularly in combating the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), was a priority during Barzani’s talks in Ankara.
Ankara and Baghdad have taken significant steps in their “war on terrorism” over the past year through rounds of security and economic talks, culminating in Erdogan’s visit to Baghdad in April. They agreed to collaborate against PKK elements in northern Iraq. This cooperation evolved in August into an agreement to establish a military coordination center in Baghdad and use the Bashiqa base, long controlled by Turkish forces, as a joint Turkish-Iraqi training center.
One of the key agenda items in talks between Ankara, Erbil, and Baghdad over the past 18 months has been the resumption of the Kirkuk-Ceyhan oil pipeline. The latest developments in this issue were discussed during Erdogan and Barzani’s meeting. Türkiye had previously informed Iraq of its readiness to resume the pipeline’s operations, but ongoing disputes between Baghdad and Erbil have delayed this step.

Barzani’s visit to Ankara also coincided with internal Turkish political signals suggesting the government might initiate a new “peace process” to address the Kurdish issue. These indicators have gained momentum following a historic handshake between the leader of the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP), Devlet Bahceli, and members of the pro-Kurdish Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP) during the opening of the new legislative year in early October. Erdogan expressed support for this gesture by his coalition partner.
Political analyst Murat Yetkin noted that Barzani’s visit might be linked to this new peace initiative. He pointed out that, on the day Barzani’s visit was announced, Bahceli delivered a message in parliament to the imprisoned PKK leader Abdullah Ocalan, urging him to call on his organization to lay down its arms. This was followed by demands from the HDP co-chair for an end to Ocalan’s 43-month isolation in his prison in western Türkiye.