Lebanese Children 'Miss Out' on Education as Crisis Takes Toll

School teachers lift placards during a sit-in outside Lebanon's parliament protesting poor pay at public schools. ANWAR AMRO / AFP
School teachers lift placards during a sit-in outside Lebanon's parliament protesting poor pay at public schools. ANWAR AMRO / AFP
TT

Lebanese Children 'Miss Out' on Education as Crisis Takes Toll

School teachers lift placards during a sit-in outside Lebanon's parliament protesting poor pay at public schools. ANWAR AMRO / AFP
School teachers lift placards during a sit-in outside Lebanon's parliament protesting poor pay at public schools. ANWAR AMRO / AFP

Rana Hariri doesn't know when she'll be able to send her children back to school, as Lebanon's grinding economic crisis thrusts the fate of public education into uncertainty.

Lack of funding for the school system has precipitated repeated teachers' strikes and school closures, resulting in children being increasingly pulled out of the formal learning system, and in some cases being forced to work.

Hariri, 51, says her nine-year-old daughter Aya "repeatedly asks me: 'When will I go back to school?' But I do not know what to tell her."

Lebanon's public institutions have been crumbling since the economy collapsed in late 2019, pushing most of the population into poverty and dealing a heavy blow to state schools, AFP said.

Public sector workers, including teachers, have repeatedly gone on strike as the value of their salaries crashed after the Lebanese pound lost more than 98 percent of its worth against the dollar.

"My children stayed at home for three months last year due to the strikes," said Hariri.

She had hopes that her 14-year-old daughter Menna would someday become a doctor.

But now, "I just hope she'll be able to go to school in the first place," she said, sitting at her friend's house surrounded by her four children.

"For the past four years, teachers have failed to secure their rights, while our children miss out on basic education."

Public sector teachers earn the equivalent of $150 to $300 per month, while the education ministry has sounded the alarm over lack of funding.

Hariri took her anger to the streets, protesting alongside teachers who demanded better wages at a sit-in in September.

The school year is due to begin in early October, but amid uncertainty over the start date, her two sons, aged 13 and 17, have taken up work with their father, a plumber.

Her daughters have meanwhile been forced to wait at home.

"I want them to have a degree... but this country is killing their future," she said with a sigh.

Public education 'in danger'
Since 2019, children have "experienced devastating disruption to their education", according to the United Nations' children's agency.

The disruptions were attributed to the economic crisis, the coronavirus epidemic, a deadly 2020 blast that rocked Beirut's port and strikes that forced school closures.

"A growing number of families" can no longer afford "the cost of education including transport to school, food, textbooks, stationery, and clothes", UNICEF Lebanon said.

At least 15 percent of households have pulled their children out of schools, UNICEF found in a June report, up from 10 percent a year ago.

And one in 10 families have been forced to send children, sometimes as young as six years old, to work to make ends meet, the report said.

"Being out of school exposes children... to violence,... poverty," and increases risks of child marriage in girls, said Atif Rafique, chief of education at UNICEF Lebanon.

Education Minister Abbas Halabi has repeatedly complained of funding problems, warning in September that "public education is in danger".

"The most urgent problem today is financial," he said, adding that his ministry was still working on securing funding for the upcoming school year.

The education ministry mostly relies on government credit lines and donor funding, mainly from the World Bank and the UN, to educate the more than 260,000 Lebanese pupils and over 152,000 Syrians enrolled in public schools.

But Halabi said donors had informed him they could not afford to give more money to public school employees.

'Catastrophic'
According to a recent Human Rights Watch report, the education ministry has slashed the number of teaching days from 180 in 2016 to about 60 in the past two years, "citing financial constraints".

Year after year, the ministry has had "no plan" to secure the funds needed for schools to remain open without interruption, said Ramzi Kaiss, HRW's Lebanon researcher.

"If we're going to have a fifth year that is lost or interrupted, it's going to be catastrophic," he told AFP.

But despite the setbacks, more pupils have poured into Lebanon's public schools as families can no longer afford private education.

Homemaker Farah Koubar, 35, said she fears she one day won't even be able to afford sending her three young children to public school.

"I'm afraid they will miss out on their education," she told AFP from her small home in Beirut.

"Every year life becomes more difficult," she said, holding back tears as she recalled how she has had to ask acquaintances for financial help to secure her family's survival.

"Everything is expensive, food, water, gasoline -- even bread."



Israeli Cluster Bombs Create ‘Renewed’ Disaster in Southern Lebanon

A Lebanese soldier works to remove a landmine (Lebanese Army website)
A Lebanese soldier works to remove a landmine (Lebanese Army website)
TT

Israeli Cluster Bombs Create ‘Renewed’ Disaster in Southern Lebanon

A Lebanese soldier works to remove a landmine (Lebanese Army website)
A Lebanese soldier works to remove a landmine (Lebanese Army website)

Lebanon is still clearing cluster bombs dropped by Israel during the 2006 war, and reports suggest that the threat is growing. Israel is believed to be using cluster bombs again in southern Lebanon, an area already severely damaged.

While the war continues, some sources in southern Lebanon claim that Israel has dropped cluster bombs, especially in agricultural areas. This could make it impossible for farmers to use the land in the future, as unexploded bombs could detonate at any time. The danger has already caused hundreds of deaths and injuries since 2006.
Before the latest conflict, Lebanon’s Mine Action Center requested four more years to finish clearing the bombs left over from 2006. However, it has not been able to confirm whether Israel has used cluster bombs in this new conflict. The center is waiting for the war to end to confirm the types of weapons used.
Hezbollah accused Israel of using cluster bombs in southern Lebanon in a statement last month, calling on international human rights organizations to condemn the attack.
Hezbollah’s statement, released on Oct. 15, said Israeli forces dropped cluster bombs in several areas, including near the towns of Aalman and Deir Siryan. The group said this action violated international law, especially during wartime.
Retired Gen.
Abdul Rahman Chehaitli, who was Deputy Chief of Staff for Operations in the Lebanese Army during the 2006 war, explained that Israel dropped cluster bombs just two days before the war ended.
These bombs were dropped randomly, making it impossible to create accurate maps for their removal.
Chehaitli told Asharq Al-Awsat that Lebanon received incomplete maps of the bomb locations from Israel through UNIFIL, but some areas still remain dangerous. Removing these bombs is risky and slow, and unexploded bombs still pose a major threat to civilians.
He warned that the use of cluster bombs in the current conflict could lead to another disaster once the fighting ends.
According to the Lebanese National News Agency, Israeli warplanes dropped over 5 million cluster bombs in southern Lebanon during the 2006 war. By 2020, these bombs had killed 58 people and injured around 400 others, many of whom were farmers and shepherds.
The Lebanese Army’s Mine Action Center works with UNIFIL and local and international organizations to remove these bombs. However, a lack of funding has reduced the number of organizations able to help, especially in southern Lebanon and the western Bekaa.
Hassan Faqih, head of the Tobacco and Tombac Farmers’ Union in Lebanon, described the continued threat of cluster bombs. Since 2006, many farmers have been unable to use their land because of unexploded bombs. Some have been injured or disabled after bombs went off.
Faqih told Asharq Al-Awsat that areas like the town of Hamila in the Nabatieh district are still full of unexploded ordnance, preventing farmers from working. He also confirmed that Israel has used cluster bombs again in this conflict.
Local residents can recognize the bombs by their shape and the sounds they make.
Cluster bombs are dropped from aircraft or fired as missiles and contain hundreds of smaller bombs that scatter over a large area. Though intended to target military forces, they are highly dangerous to civilians, especially children.