Lebanese banks have escalated their dispute with the Ministry of Finance, announcing a one-day strike every week starting Wednesday in protest against demands to amend their tax returns for 2020 through 2024. The proposed adjustments would subject unrealized accounting gains and provisions set aside to cover actual losses to taxation.
The Association of Banks in Lebanon (ABL) has authorized its board of directors to take further action if the relevant authorities fail to respond to its demands. The association is seeking a legislative resolution to the dispute as Parliament prepares to discuss next year's draft state budget.
The unanimous decision to strike follows a letter the association received from the Finance Ministry several days ago. The ministry said its audit departments would begin reviewing banks' tax returns in the middle of next month to verify their accuracy and compliance with existing laws, while allowing taxpayers to challenge any subsequent tax assessments or penalties.
The banks have called on the authorities to withdraw the request for amended tax returns, reconsider the proposed tax treatment and take the necessary measures, including legislative amendments where needed, to exclude unrealized accounting gains and loss provisions from taxable income.
The association believes Parliament's consideration of next year's draft budget provides an opportunity to resolve the issue through legislative amendments.
Dispute Over Constitutionality of Tax Assessments
On the legal front, the banks base their objections, as previously reported by Asharq Al-Awsat, on Articles 81 and 82 of the Lebanese Constitution, which require new taxes or changes to existing taxes to be enacted through legislation passed by Parliament.
The association argues that administrative regulations cannot serve as a sufficient basis for imposing new tax liabilities. It maintains that accounting differences arising from the collapse of the Lebanese pound, calculated using the difference between historical cost and the prevailing exchange rate, do not represent genuine profits but reflect actual losses that should not be taxed.
The Finance Ministry, meanwhile, bases its position on regulatory decisions issued by the finance minister and an opinion issued by the Legislation and Consultation Commission in early 2025. Under the ministry's interpretation, these provide grounds for taxing banks on accounting differences arising from the gap between the historical cost exchange rate and the dollar's actual exchange rate at the time of assessment.
The banks warn that collecting the disputed taxes, estimated at approximately $600 million, would deplete part of their remaining cash liquidity and undermine their ability to repay depositors. They argue that the measures would place additional burdens on both banks and depositors as a result of a crisis in which the state defaulted on its obligations.
The association maintains that protecting available liquidity and directing it toward repaying depositors should take precedence over collecting taxes on gains it describes as unrealized and existing only on paper.
The dispute has intensified over recent weeks through a series of exchanges between the ministry and the banks, following the ministry's demand that lenders submit revised tax returns retroactively for the five years from 2020 through 2024.
The banks had requested joint meetings to clarify what they consider shortcomings in the proposed tax treatment before formally rejecting the required measures in their latest letter, citing legal, accounting and regulatory concerns.
According to the banking association's legal and accounting assessment, the disputed foreign exchange differences arose from the revaluation of accounts following the sharp depreciation of the Lebanese pound. They do not constitute actual profits or represent a genuine increase in banks' wealth or ability to pay taxes.
The association also argues that the provisions in question were established to cover actual losses resulting from the state's failure to meet its obligations, in accordance with applicable accounting and regulatory standards. Taxing these amounts, it says, fails to distinguish between realized profits, accounting gains and actual losses.
In explaining its position, the association draws a distinction between profits generated through economic activity and nominal or accounting gains resulting from extraordinary currency fluctuations and the revaluation of accounts. It stresses that the latter do not reflect any genuine increase in banks' wealth or taxable capacity.
As for provisions against Eurobond holdings, the association says they were established in accordance with applicable accounting and regulatory standards, with the approval of the Banking Control Commission of Lebanon, to account for losses arising from the Lebanese government's default on its debt obligations.
In a statement, the association reiterated its categorical rejection of the Finance Ministry's demand to amend tax returns, arguing that the proposed measures would impose taxes on unrealized accounting gains and provisions intended to cover losses resulting from the government's default on Eurobonds.
It said its position was driven by its responsibility to protect depositors' rights and preserve the banking sector's remaining liquidity.