Biden's Vaccine Rules to Set Off Barrage of Legal Challenges

President Joe Biden walks along the Colonnade towards the Oval Office as he returns to the White House after visiting Brookland Middle School in northeast Washington, Friday, Sept. 10, 2021. (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta)
President Joe Biden walks along the Colonnade towards the Oval Office as he returns to the White House after visiting Brookland Middle School in northeast Washington, Friday, Sept. 10, 2021. (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta)
TT

Biden's Vaccine Rules to Set Off Barrage of Legal Challenges

President Joe Biden walks along the Colonnade towards the Oval Office as he returns to the White House after visiting Brookland Middle School in northeast Washington, Friday, Sept. 10, 2021. (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta)
President Joe Biden walks along the Colonnade towards the Oval Office as he returns to the White House after visiting Brookland Middle School in northeast Washington, Friday, Sept. 10, 2021. (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta)

President Joe Biden’s sweeping new vaccine requirements have Republican governors threatening lawsuits. His unapologetic response: “Have at it.”

The administration is gearing up for another major clash between federal and state rule. But while many details about the rules remain unknown, Biden appears to be on firm legal ground to issue the directive in the name of protecting employee safety, according to several experts interviewed by The Associated Press.

“My bet is that with respect to that statutory authority, they’re on pretty strong footing given the evidence strongly suggesting … the degree of risk that (unvaccinated individuals) pose, not only to themselves but also unto others,” said University of Connecticut law professor Sachin Pandya.

Republicans swiftly denounced the mandate that could impact 100 million Americans as government overreach and vowed to sue, and private employers who resist the requirements may do so as well. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott called it an “assault on private businesses" while Gov. Henry McMaster promised to "fight them to the gates of hell to protect the liberty and livelihood of every South Carolinian.” The Republican National Committee has also said it will sue the administration “to protect Americans and their liberties.”

Such cases could present another clash between state and federal authority at a time when Biden's Justice Department is already suing Texas over its new state law that bans most abortions, arguing that it was enacted “in open defiance of the Constitution.”

The White House is gearing up for legal challenges and believes that even if some of the mandates are tossed out, millions of Americans will get a shot because of the new requirements — saving lives and preventing the spread of the virus.

Biden is putting enforcement in the hands of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, which is drafting a rule “over the coming weeks,” Jeffrey Zients, the White House coronavirus response coordinator, said Friday. He warned that “if a workplace refuses to follow the standard, the OSHA fines could be quite significant.”

Courts have upheld vaccination requirements as a condition of employment, both before the pandemic — in challenges brought by health care workers — and since the coronavirus outbreak, said Lindsay Wiley, director of the Health Law and Policy Program at American University Washington College of Law.

Where Biden's vaccine requirements could be more open to attack is over questions of whether the administration followed the proper process to implement them, she said.

“The argument that mandatory vaccination impermissibly infringes on bodily autonomy or medical decision making, those arguments have not been successful and I don’t expect that to change,” Wiley said. “I think the challenges that are harder to predict the outcome of are going to be the ones that are really sort of the boring challenges about whether they followed the right process.”

Emergency temporary standards — under which the rules are being implemented on a fast track — have been particularly vulnerable to challenges, Wiley said. But the risks presented by the coronavirus and the existence of a declared public health emergency could put this one “on stronger footing than any other ones past administrations have tried to impose that have been challenged in court,” she said.

Indeed, the question of whether the mandate is legally sound is separate from whether it will be upheld by judges, including by a conservative-majority Supreme Court which has trended toward generous interpretations of religious freedom and may be looking to ensure that any mandate sufficiently takes faith-based objections into account.

Vaccination “has become politicized and there are many Republican district judges who might be hostile to the regulation for political reasons," said Michael Harper, a Boston University law professor.

“I could imagine an unfortunate opinion that attempted to justify this political stance by rejecting the use of OSHA against infectious disease rather than against hazards intrinsic to the workplace,” Harper wrote in an email.

The expansive rules mandate that all employers with more than 100 workers require them to be vaccinated or test for the virus weekly, affecting about 80 million Americans. And the roughly 17 million workers at health facilities that receive federal Medicare or Medicaid also will have to be fully vaccinated.

Biden is also requiring vaccination for employees of the executive branch and contractors who do business with the federal government — with no option to test out. That covers several million more workers.

Republican-dominated Montana stands alone in having a state law on the books that directly contradicts the new federal mandate. The state passed a law earlier this year making it illegal for private employers to require vaccines as a condition for employment.

But University of Montana constitutional law professor Anthony Johnstone said the federal rules would trump the state law. That means larger Montana businesses that previously couldn’t require their employees to get vaccinated will now likely be required to, including hospitals that are some of the largest employers in the sparsely populated state.

Given that the rules are still being drafted and haven't been released, experts say the devil is in the details. It remains to be seen exactly what the rule will require employers to do or not do, and how it accounts for things such as other rights that unvaccinated employees may assert, such as the right to a disability accommodation, Pandya said.

For example — with the growing number of fully remote businesses and workers — if the rules are written to include people who don't have workplace exposure, “there certainly is room for an issue there," said Erika Todd, an employment attorney with Sullivan & Worcester in Boston.

Charles Craver, a labor and employment law professor at George Washington University, said the mandate presented a “close question" legally. But he said the Biden administration did have a legitimate argument that such a requirement was necessary for employers to protect the safety of workers, customers and members of the public.

The thornier question, though, is how employers — and courts — will sort through requests for accommodations for employees on religious or other grounds.
Though such accommodations may include having an employee work from home, “you can have a situation where someone has to be present and you can’t provide an accommodation because of the danger involved," he added.

“I would not be a betting person if this went up before the Supreme Court,” Craver said. “I could even picture the court divided 5-4, and I wouldn’t bet which way it would go.”



US Attacks Iran’s Qeshm Island in Strait of Hormuz

An aerial view of the Iranian shores and the island of Qeshm in the Strait of Hormuz, December 10, 2023. (Reuters)
An aerial view of the Iranian shores and the island of Qeshm in the Strait of Hormuz, December 10, 2023. (Reuters)
TT

US Attacks Iran’s Qeshm Island in Strait of Hormuz

An aerial view of the Iranian shores and the island of Qeshm in the Strait of Hormuz, December 10, 2023. (Reuters)
An aerial view of the Iranian shores and the island of Qeshm in the Strait of Hormuz, December 10, 2023. (Reuters)

The United States on Tuesday carried out several attacks on Iran's southern Island of Qeshm, located in the Strait of Hormuz, a local Iranian official said.

"The American attack on locations on Qeshm island caused no damage to residential, commercial, or infrastructural areas," said Ahmad Nafisi, deputy provincial governor of the southern province of Hormozgan, quoted by the official IRNA news agency.

"The situation on Qeshm island is under control, and all relief, service, and executive agencies are on full alert," he added.

"The sounds of five to six explosions were heard on Qeshm on Tuesday evening," IRNA said.

Earlier in the day Iran's Revolutionary Guards said they had launched a drone attack targeting a radar system in Bahrain operated by the United States.

Since the outbreak of the Middle East war in late February, Tehran has attempted to restrict traffic through the strategic waterway, insisting vessels use only routes authorized by the country.

It has regularly targeted ships that transit without its authorization.

The United States has in response imposed a naval blockade on Iranian ports and helped tankers travel the strait, which normally carries about one-fifth of global oil supplies.

In recent weeks, Tehran has made multiple announcements saying ships have caught fire in the strait, often claiming they struck mines.

On Tuesday, the Iranian armed forces said three oil tankers struck naval mines while attempting to transit Hormuz.

The US military recently said it had cleared all mines from the main routes through the waterway.

US Central Command, which oversees US military operations in the region, said last month that it had helped Gulf countries export 1.5 billion barrels of oil via Hormuz since the summer.


4 Detained in North Macedonia for Alleged Iran-Backed Assassination Plot in Greece

Domestic security agency director Bojan Hristovski speaks to media after announcing the detention of four people implicated in an alleged Iran-backed assassination plot in neighboring Greece, in Skopje, North Macedonia, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP)
Domestic security agency director Bojan Hristovski speaks to media after announcing the detention of four people implicated in an alleged Iran-backed assassination plot in neighboring Greece, in Skopje, North Macedonia, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP)
TT

4 Detained in North Macedonia for Alleged Iran-Backed Assassination Plot in Greece

Domestic security agency director Bojan Hristovski speaks to media after announcing the detention of four people implicated in an alleged Iran-backed assassination plot in neighboring Greece, in Skopje, North Macedonia, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP)
Domestic security agency director Bojan Hristovski speaks to media after announcing the detention of four people implicated in an alleged Iran-backed assassination plot in neighboring Greece, in Skopje, North Macedonia, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP)

Authorities in North Macedonia have detained four people for questioning over an alleged Iran-linked assassination plot in neighboring Greece, officials said Tuesday.

Bojan Hristovski, director of North Macedonia's domestic security agency, said Tuesday that the suspects are all Macedonian citizens, adding that a fifth person had also been questioned and a sixth remained wanted by the authorities.

Hristovski named one of the Iranian recruiters as Naji Sharifi Zindashti, who is wanted in the United States for allegedly operating a criminal network that targets Iranian dissidents and activists abroad.

He did not give details of the alleged target in Greece, and Greek authorities did not immediately comment on the announcement.

“This concerns the dismantling of an Iranian proxy network involved in planning a terrorist attack,” Hristovski said.

“The network operating in Macedonia consisted of individuals embedded in criminal organizations within the country,” he said. “Acting on direct instructions from an Iranian national, they undertook preparatory and logistical activities for a terrorist act — an assassination targeting a previously identified individual located in Greece.”

Iran's mission to the United Nations did not immediately respond to a request for comment.


Hundreds Protest in Western Iran Over Deadly Bus Crash

Iranians shop at a market in Tehran, Iran, 17 November 2026, amid the ongoing conflict between the US and Iran. (EPA)
Iranians shop at a market in Tehran, Iran, 17 November 2026, amid the ongoing conflict between the US and Iran. (EPA)
TT

Hundreds Protest in Western Iran Over Deadly Bus Crash

Iranians shop at a market in Tehran, Iran, 17 November 2026, amid the ongoing conflict between the US and Iran. (EPA)
Iranians shop at a market in Tehran, Iran, 17 November 2026, amid the ongoing conflict between the US and Iran. (EPA)

Hundreds of people took to streets in western Iran on Tuesday to protest the deaths of 13 people in a bus crash in the same region, local media reported.

"A protest gathering began an hour ago in Vali-e Asr Square in Abdanan," Fars news agency said.

"The gathering initially consisted of 200 to 300 people, but the number of participants later grew to approximately 1,000," the report said, adding that the crowd then moved from the square towards other streets.

Fars said the slogans initially revolved around the incident, such as "today is the day of mourning" and "resign, resign," but after a while the chants took on a political tone, though it did not provide any details.

"During the march, some individuals attempted to damage public property and incite other participants," it said, adding that police forces were at the scene to manage the situation.

Meanwhile, the prosecutor for Abdanan warned the protesters there would be a firm response, according to the judiciary's Mizan Online website.

"Individuals who seek to exploit this incident to disrupt public order or incite public sentiment will be dealt with firmly," said Amrollah Misaie, public and revolutionary prosecutor of Abdanan, according to Mizan.

"All aspects of the incident will be investigated; once expert opinions are provided, those at fault will be held accountable, and the case will be pursued until a final resolution is reached," he added.

Thirteen people were killed and over a dozen injured when a bus overturned in western Iran on Saturday.

Iran has a poor road safety record. Traffic accidents claimed nearly 20,000 lives in the 12 months to March, the official Iranian Legal Medicine Organization said in June.