Israeli General: US Withdrawal from Iran Nuclear Deal was a 'Strategic Mistake'

Major-General Gadi Eisenkot (File Photo: Reuters)
Major-General Gadi Eisenkot (File Photo: Reuters)
TT

Israeli General: US Withdrawal from Iran Nuclear Deal was a 'Strategic Mistake'

Major-General Gadi Eisenkot (File Photo: Reuters)
Major-General Gadi Eisenkot (File Photo: Reuters)

Former Israeli army chief Gadi Eisenkot condemned the 2018 US decision to withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal, calling it a "strategic mistake," according to The Times of Israel.

"To us, it was completely out of the blue. In my opinion, it was also a strategic mistake," he added.

Eisenkot said the US pullout from the deal removed "certain shackles" on Iran, granting it "legitimacy" to push forward its nuclear program in violation of the pact.

Eisenkot stated that top Israeli security officials were kept in the dark ahead of then-US president Donald Trump's decision to withdraw from the 2015 accord, which curbed Iran's nuclear program in exchange for sanctions relief.

Eisenkot was commanding the Israeli military when the deal was signed.

"Only Yossi Cohen, Ron Dermer, and Benjamin Netanyahu dealt with this issue of leaving the nuclear deal. No one spoke with the security establishment," Eisenkot said, referring to the former prime minister and two of his closest confidantes.

Netanyahu was a vocal opponent of the deal when it was reached during the Obama administration and pushed for world powers to scrap the agreement before Trump withdrew.

Eisenkot, who led the Israel Defense Forces from 2015 to 2019, expressed his belief that "the sanctions are partial, and there is no oversight, the Chinese and Russians do not cooperate with the Americans."

He said that the United States of today is different from the United States in 2015.

"How much the Iranians are taking the Americans into account is a very relevant component," stated Eisenkot, adding that they are not considering them and not taking into account a US attack.

"They are taking advantage of the situation, and this is a problem."

Asked if Israel was capable on its own of striking Iran, Eisenkot said, "It's complicated."

The former general criticized Prime Minister Naftali Bennett for ruling out a meeting with the US Special Envoy on Iran, Robert Malley, before he visited Israel in November, noting Israeli requests for armaments after the conflict in May with the Hamas group.

"There's a sort of arrogance here for domestic purposes. I understand the fear of Bibi [Netenyahu], but to earn a point and a half in public relations, you don't do a thing like this," he added.

Eiseknot claimed Israel nearly assassinated Iranian General Qassem Soleimani, who headed al-Quds Force of Iran's Revolutionary Guard, in May 2018 after Iranian forces in Syria fired rockets at the Golan Heights.

"There was a decision that got approval to hit everyone in this incident who took action against us," Eisenkot said.

"We decided that if he were in some command post or operations room or the area, we'd take him down," he indicated, adding that: "We had permission for that, but we didn't succeed in carrying it out."

Eisenkot issued a thinly veiled threat to Soleimani in 2019 as he was leaving the Israeli forces, and reports from 2018 said Israel discussed assassinating the Iranian general with the US.

Soleimani was killed in January 2020 by a US drone as he arrived in Baghdad.

Eisenkot claimed the Israeli Forces was involved in the campaign against ISIS, arguing that Israel was working with "many armies, on countless special operations" against ISIS.

"I can estimate that in our operations, hundreds of ISIS operatives were killed and over a thousand wounded, facilities and infrastructure destroyed," he said.



‘War Ruined Me’: Lebanon’s Farmers Mourn Lost Season

This photo shows burnt agricultural fields that were hit during Israeli shelling in the southern Lebanese area of Marjeyoun, on October 30, 2024, amid the ongoing war between Israel and Hezbollah. (AFP)
This photo shows burnt agricultural fields that were hit during Israeli shelling in the southern Lebanese area of Marjeyoun, on October 30, 2024, amid the ongoing war between Israel and Hezbollah. (AFP)
TT

‘War Ruined Me’: Lebanon’s Farmers Mourn Lost Season

This photo shows burnt agricultural fields that were hit during Israeli shelling in the southern Lebanese area of Marjeyoun, on October 30, 2024, amid the ongoing war between Israel and Hezbollah. (AFP)
This photo shows burnt agricultural fields that were hit during Israeli shelling in the southern Lebanese area of Marjeyoun, on October 30, 2024, amid the ongoing war between Israel and Hezbollah. (AFP)

Lebanese farmer Abu Taleb briefly returned to his orchard last month to salvage an avocado harvest but ran away empty handed as soon as Israeli air raids began.

"The war broke out just before the first harvest season," said Abu Taleb, displaced from the village of Tayr Debba near the southern city Tyre.

"When I went back in mid-October, it was deserted... it was scary," said the father of two, who is now sheltering in Tripoli more than 160 kilometers to the north and asked to be identified by a pseudonym because of security concerns.

Abu Taleb said his harvesting attempt was interrupted by an Israeli raid on the neighboring town of Markaba.

He was forced back to Tripoli without the avocados he usually exports every year.

Agricultural regions in Lebanon have been caught in the crossfire since hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah ramped up in October last year, a full-scale war breaking out on September 23.

The UN's agriculture agency, FAO, said more than 1,909 hectares of farmland in south Lebanon had been damaged or left unharvested between October last year and September 28.

The conflict has also displaced more than half a million people, including farmers who abandoned their crops just when they were ready to harvest.

Hani Saad had to abandon 120 hectares of farmland in the southern region of Nabatiyeh, which is rich in citrus and avocado plantations.

"If the ceasefire takes place within a month, I can save the harvest, otherwise, the whole season is ruined," said Saad who has been displaced to the coastal city of Jounieh, north of Beirut.

When an Israeli strike sparked a fire in one of Saad's orchards, he had to pay out of his own pocket for the fuel of the fire engine that extinguished the blaze.

His employees, meanwhile, have fled. Of 32 workers, 28 have left, mainly to neighboring Syria.

- 'Worst phase' -

Israeli strikes have put at least two land crossings with Syria out of service, blocking a key export route for produce and crops.

Airlines have suspended flights to Lebanon as insurance costs soar.

This has dealt a deadly blow to agricultural exports, most of which are destined for Gulf Arab states.

Fruit exporter Chadi Kaadan said exports to the Gulf have dropped by more than 50 percent.

The supply surplus in the local market has caused prices to plummet at home, he added.

"In the end, it is the farmer who loses," said Saad who used to earn $5,000 a day before the war started. Today, he barely manages $300.

While avocados can stay on the tree for months, they are starting to run out of water following Israeli strikes on irrigation channels, Saad said.

Citrus fruits and cherimoyas have already started to fall.

"The war has ruined me. I spend my time in front of the TV waiting for a ceasefire so I can return to my livelihood," Saad told AFP.

Gaby Hage, a resident of the Christian town of Rmeish, on the border with Israel, is one of the few farmers who decided to stay in south Lebanon.

He has only been able to harvest 100 of his 350 olive trees, which were left untended for a year because of cross-border strikes.

"I took advantage of a slight lull in the fighting to pick what I could," he told AFP.

Hage said agriculture was a lifeline for the inhabitants of his town, which has been cut off by the war.

Ibrahim Tarchichi, president of the farmers' union in the Bekaa Valley, which was hit hard by the strikes, believes that agriculture in Lebanon is going through the "worst phase" of its recent history.

"I have experienced four wars, it has never been this serious," he said.