‘Loss, Damage’ Funding…A Climate Breakthrough Threatened by ‘Details’

A press conference for the "Climate Action Network" discussed the issue of “loss and damage” funding during COP27 (Asharq Al-Awsat)
A press conference for the "Climate Action Network" discussed the issue of “loss and damage” funding during COP27 (Asharq Al-Awsat)
TT
20

‘Loss, Damage’ Funding…A Climate Breakthrough Threatened by ‘Details’

A press conference for the "Climate Action Network" discussed the issue of “loss and damage” funding during COP27 (Asharq Al-Awsat)
A press conference for the "Climate Action Network" discussed the issue of “loss and damage” funding during COP27 (Asharq Al-Awsat)

COP27 President Sameh Shoukry has affirmed the success of negotiations on world countries adopting for the first time a climate agenda item on the most important issue of establishing a “loss and damage” fund.

Despite being labeled a breakthrough, the step will usher in complex discussions that will determine progress on the matter.

The expression “Loss and damage” refers to the costs incurred because of extreme weather events or climate impacts, such as rising sea levels.

There were constant demands to include the issue of “loss and damage” in COP summits that began in the early 1990s.

Major industrialized countries, however, repeatedly obstructed efforts to add the topic to COP agendas out of fear that it may lead to demands for billions of dollars in compensation for poorer countries.

Recent climate disasters - such as floods in Pakistan - gave a new impetus to demands for introducing “loss and damage” to discussions at the COP27 summit currently being held in Egypt.

Before the summit, Magdi Allam, Secretary-General of the Union of Arab Environmental Experts, told Asharq Al-Awsat that the COP27 Summit would achieve important breakthroughs due to the climate warning that nature raised this year to the world, represented by the severe weather phenomena witnessed by several countries.

Even if putting the discussion of “loss and damage” on the agenda is considered a breakthrough, the devil remains in the details.

Wael Abdel Moez, a researcher specializing in climate affairs at the University of Berlin, told Asharq Al-Awsat that “there is no agreement on describing the loss and damage that should be compensated.”

“There will also be disagreement over who will pay: Will the US pay the most, as the historically biggest polluter, or will it be China, which is the biggest polluter now?”

“Certainly, the tense Chinese-US relations will affect the possibility of resolving such issues,” said Moez.

The fact is, developed countries have not fulfilled their promises to provide $100 billion in climate finance annually by 2020. Moreover, they also failed to implement what was agreed upon in the 2015 Paris Agreement.

This has made developing and poor countries look for more practical solutions to finance climate “loss and damage.”

“One of the solutions proposed in the corridors of COP27 is to have the United Nations assume the responsibility,” Moez noted.

Some countries have also proposed inviting UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres to impose a profit tax on fossil fuel companies to raise funding.



Israel's Bedouin Communities Use Solar Energy to Stake Claim to Land

This aerial view shows solar panels at an electricity-generation plant for the Bedouin community in the village of Tirabin al-Sana in Israel's southern Negev desert Photo: Menahem KAHANA
This aerial view shows solar panels at an electricity-generation plant for the Bedouin community in the village of Tirabin al-Sana in Israel's southern Negev desert Photo: Menahem KAHANA
TT
20

Israel's Bedouin Communities Use Solar Energy to Stake Claim to Land

This aerial view shows solar panels at an electricity-generation plant for the Bedouin community in the village of Tirabin al-Sana in Israel's southern Negev desert Photo: Menahem KAHANA
This aerial view shows solar panels at an electricity-generation plant for the Bedouin community in the village of Tirabin al-Sana in Israel's southern Negev desert Photo: Menahem KAHANA

At the end of a dusty road in southern Israel, beyond a Bedouin village of unfinished houses and the shiny dome of a mosque, a field of solar panels gleams in the hot desert sun.

Tirabin al-Sana in Israel's Negev desert is the home of the Tirabin (also spelled Tarabin) Bedouin tribe, who signed a contract with an Israeli solar energy company to build the installation.

The deal has helped provide jobs for the community as well as promote cleaner, cheaper energy for the country, as the power produced is pumped into the national grid.

Earlier this month, the Al-Ghanami family in the town of Abu Krinat a little further south inaugurated a similar field of solar panels.
Bedouin families have for years tried and failed to hold on to their lands, coming up against right-wing groups and hardline government officials.

Demolition orders issued by Israeli authorities plague Bedouin villages, threatening the traditionally semi-nomadic communities with forced eviction.

But Yosef Abramowitz, co-chair of the non-profit organisation Shamsuna, said solar field projects help them to stake a more definitive claim.
"It secures their land rights forever," he told AFP.

"It's the only way to settle the Bedouin land issue and secure 100 percent renewable energy," he added, calling it a "win, win".

For the solar panels to be built, the land must be registered as part of the Bedouin village, strengthening their claim over it.

Roughly 300,000 Bedouins live in the Negev desert, half of them in places such as Tirabin al-Sana, including some 110,000 who reside in villages not officially recognised by the government.

This aerial view shows solar panels at an electricity-generation plant for the Bedouin community in the village of Tirabin al-Sana in Israel's southern Negev desert
This aerial view shows solar panels at an electricity-generation plant for the Bedouin community in the village of Tirabin al-Sana in Israel's southern Negev desert Photo: Menahem KAHANA
Villages that are not formally recognied are fighting the biggest battle to stay on the land.

Far-right groups, some backed by the current government of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, have stepped up efforts in the past two years to drive these families away.
A sharp increase in home demolitions has left the communities vulnerable and whole families without a roof over their heads.

"Since 2023, more than 8,500 buildings have been demolished in these unrecognized villages," Marwan Abu Frieh, from the legal aid organization Adalah, told AFP at a recent protest in Beersheva, the largest city in the Negev.

"Within these villages, thousands of families are now living out in the open, an escalation the Negev has not witnessed in perhaps the last two decades."

Tribes just want to "live in peace and dignity", following their distinct customs and traditions, he said.

Gil Yasur, who also works with Shamsuna developing critical infrastructure in Bedouin villages, said land claims issues were common among Bedouins across the Negev.
Families who include a solar project on their land, however, stand a better chance of securing it, he added.

"Then everyone will benefit -- the landowners, the country, the Negev," he said. "This is the best way to move forward to a green economy."

In Um Batin, a recognised village, residents are using solar energy in a different way –- to power a local kindergarten all year round.

Until last year, the village relied on power from a diesel generator that polluted the air and the ground where the children played.

Now, a hulking solar panel shields the children from the sun as its surface sucks up the powerful rays, keeping the kindergarten in full working order.

"It was not clean or comfortable here before," said Nama Abu Kaf, who works in the kindergarten.
"Now we have air conditioning and a projector so the children can watch television."

Hani al-Hawashleh, who oversees the project on behalf of Shamsuna, said the solar energy initiative for schools and kindergartens was "very positive".

"Without power you can't use all kinds of equipment such as projectors, lights in the classrooms and, on the other hand, it saves costs and uses clean energy," he said.

The projects are part of a pilot scheme run by Shamsuna.

Asked if there was interest in expanding to other educational institutions that rely on polluting generators, he said there were challenges and bureaucracy but he hoped to see more.

"We need people to collaborate with us to move this forward," he said, adding that he would "love to see a solar energy system in every village".