Football Behind Closed Doors May Tell US Much About How Home Advantage Works

 Atalanta’s Josip Ilicic scores an early penalty in his side’s 4-3 away win against Valencia at an empty Mestalla. Photograph: UEFA/EPA
Atalanta’s Josip Ilicic scores an early penalty in his side’s 4-3 away win against Valencia at an empty Mestalla. Photograph: UEFA/EPA
TT

Football Behind Closed Doors May Tell US Much About How Home Advantage Works

 Atalanta’s Josip Ilicic scores an early penalty in his side’s 4-3 away win against Valencia at an empty Mestalla. Photograph: UEFA/EPA
Atalanta’s Josip Ilicic scores an early penalty in his side’s 4-3 away win against Valencia at an empty Mestalla. Photograph: UEFA/EPA

The Mestalla in Valencia has to be one of the most intimidating stadiums in the world for visiting football teams. Its stands, which have the pitch of a ski jump, allow home fans to create a claustrophobic wall of noise. The rabid screams of 55,000 Valencians, bouncing off the concrete foundations, have made it something of a fortress for the local team and a popular venue for Spain’s home fixtures. A while back, I watched Valencia play Barcelona at the Mestalla, and there was a febrile menace in the air that night unlike any other I have experienced in a football ground.

The vibe at the Mestalla was rather different last week, when Valencia hosted Atalanta in the second leg of the sides’ Champions League last-16 tie. If ever a team needed a boost from their 12th man, their fans, it was now: Valencia had to make up a 4-1 deficit from the first leg. But, because of the coronavirus outbreak, the fixture was played behind closed doors. Watching the match on TV was eerie: you could hear the players shouting for the ball or celebrating or appealing for a foul. At times you had to remind yourself that it wasn’t a training exercise.

The match became even more listless after just 90 seconds, when Atalanta were awarded a penalty. The Slovenian striker Josip Ilicic buried it and added three more in a 4-3 victory. “Fabulous game missed by fans at Mestalla,” Gary Lineker tweeted. “Imagine scoring all 4 goals like Ilicic has done with barely a soul in the stadium.”

On Friday, it was announced that all elite football in England and Scotland will be postponed until at least April. The Champions League and Europa League have also been suspended. What happens next is decidedly murky. There may be play‑offs to decide titles and relegation. Euro 2020 could be delayed. And there might well be more surreal spectacles like the one that played out between Valencia and Atalanta.

If more matches do have to be played in empty stadiums without fans, can we expect it to affect the results? Will Liverpool suddenly be less formidable without the Kop behind them? Home advantage is one of the immutable facts of sport, especially football – what happens when you remove the crowd from the equation?

Playing sport behind closed doors has traditionally been used as a punishment for the home team. In football, it dates back to the early 1980s, when English clubs were feared across Europe for their tenacity on the field and their brutality off it. West Ham were the first team on the receiving end. In September 1980, the Hammers played Castilla, essentially Real Madrid’s feeder team, at the Bernabéu in the European Cup Winners Cup. When they lost 3-1 in the first leg – perhaps because they were humiliated by losing to a second‑string outfit, or maybe because they just fancied a punch-up – the West Ham supporters went on the rampage. Dozens were ejected from the stadium; outside, one was run over by a bus and died.

Uefa determined that the second leg should be played in an empty Upton Park. In fact, the official attendance was 262, when you took players, staff, ball kids and media into account. But the atmosphere was unquestionably odd: the West Ham goalkeeper Phil Parkes recalled afterwards that he had to tune out commentary on the game from a radio behind the goal. It became known as “the ghost match”.

In one sense, West Ham were punished for the riot in Madrid: the club would have expected a full house of 36,000 for the second leg, so it made a hefty dent in their income. But what about on the pitch? Did West Ham suffer from not having the Upton Park faithful roaring them on?

Not especially. Back in London, West Ham tied the match 3-1 in 90 minutes; in extra time they scored two more. It was a similar story in September 1982, when Aston Villa were made to start their European campaign on a Wednesday afternoon at 2.30pm in front of 187 spectators, as a censure for rioting by their supporters the previous season in Belgium. Again, it wasn’t much of a punishment: Villa beat Besiktas 3-1. Internazionale had to play three Champions League home games behind closed doors in 2005, and they won all three.

So we’re clear: it’s not that home clubs usually perform better when forced to play behind closed doors. That’s probably not the case, and there’s not enough statistical evidence to confirm or deny it. But these matches played without supporters do make you wonder how influential fans in the stadium are to the performance of their beloved team.

Research shows home advantage is clearly and definitely a major factor in football. Taken aAcross all teams and all leagues in England, the home team invariably wins around 45% of matches, and draws 25%. Fans might believe this is down to their support but actually the size of the crowd and the intensity of their screaming does not appear to have a significant impact on the result.

Where the home crowd can sometimes have a game-changing influence, however, is on the decisions of the referee. A couple of studies have indicated that football officials – unwittingly, of course – were wary of making controversial calls against the home team because they suspected, perhaps subliminally, that the crowd would turn on them. In practice, this means fewer yellow cards, more penalties given – and the louder and more partisan the crowd, the greater the unconscious bias.

If some of the key fixtures this season do end up being decided behind closed doors, they will be intriguing to watch (obviously on a screen, not in the stands). Will referees make better decisions? Will the intensity of home players dip without the crowd to gee them up?

Or, counter-intuitively, will these players suddenly display a new sense of freedom? Joey Barton once complained that abusive Newcastle fans at St James’ Park had destroyed the confidence of the players. Likewise, there must have been times when Gary Neville was manager at Valencia in 2016 when he wished the Mestalla was empty. As thrilling as it must be when 55,000 fans are chanting your name, imagine how soul-destroying it is when they are screaming as one: “Gary, vete ya!” or “Gary, go now!”

The Guardian Sport



Goalkeeper Martinez Set for Argentina Return After Jaw Injury

Football - International Friendly - Argentina v Uruguay - Estadio La Bombonera, Buenos Aires, Argentina - November 13, 2026 Argentina's Emiliano Martinez during the warm up before the match. (Reuters)
Football - International Friendly - Argentina v Uruguay - Estadio La Bombonera, Buenos Aires, Argentina - November 13, 2026 Argentina's Emiliano Martinez during the warm up before the match. (Reuters)
TT

Goalkeeper Martinez Set for Argentina Return After Jaw Injury

Football - International Friendly - Argentina v Uruguay - Estadio La Bombonera, Buenos Aires, Argentina - November 13, 2026 Argentina's Emiliano Martinez during the warm up before the match. (Reuters)
Football - International Friendly - Argentina v Uruguay - Estadio La Bombonera, Buenos Aires, Argentina - November 13, 2026 Argentina's Emiliano Martinez during the warm up before the match. (Reuters)

Argentina ‌coach Lionel Scaloni said goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez will feature in Tuesday's friendly against Costa Rica after he recovered from a jaw fracture.

Martinez underwent surgery after colliding with Everton defender Jarrad Branthwaite in ‌Chelsea's 2-0 ‌victory last month.

He returned ⁠to Chelsea training ⁠earlier this month and was called up by Scaloni despite not having played for the Premier League club since ⁠the Everton game.

Martinez, ‌34, ‌did not feature in Argentina's 2-1 ‌loss to Uruguay on ‌Friday.

"Emiliano is going to play in goal, he'll be there," Scaloni told reporters on ‌Monday, ahead of the friendly match in Cordoba.

"Maybe ⁠he ⁠was fit for the previous match, but it was a risk, and since we trust Gero (Geronimo Rulli), Juan (Musso) and Santi (Santiago Beltran), we chose to look after him. An extra three days was a prudent choice."


‘Not Competitive’ Brazil Can Improve, Insists Ancelotti

Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
TT

‘Not Competitive’ Brazil Can Improve, Insists Ancelotti

Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)

Brazil coach Carlo Ancelotti on Monday promised an improved performance in the year-ending clash against Singapore, admitting that his squad was "currently not competitive."

The Selecao lost 3-2 against Japan in a friendly in Singapore on Saturday, where Ancelotti and skipper Raphinha were red-carded after Japan scored the dramatic clincher in stoppage time.

"Given that the team is currently not competitive, I want to do more," Ancelotti told reporters in Singapore, where Brazil play on Tuesday.

The Italian, Brazil's first-ever permanent foreign coach, said: "I want to do more because I enjoy being here, so that the team can become more competitive on the global stage.

"The priority is to play well first (tomorrow) and to do well."

Ancelotti, 67, is coming under increasing pressure, following a string of underwhelming performances including two defeats, two wins and a draw in Brazil's last five international outings.

Japan avenged a 2-1 defeat by Brazil in their previous meeting at this year's World Cup, when the South Americans beat them in a round-of-32 clash.

After Saturday's loss, Ancelotti faced a barrage of criticism, including from former Brazilian national team star Romario.

Ancelotti brushed off Romario's remarks, saying "like anyone he has the right to express an opinion."

But the former Real Madrid coach, who reacted with fury after Brazil appealed for a foul in the build-up to Japan's winning goal on Saturday -- which was upheld by VAR -- said that his team "didn't deserve to lose" against Japan.

Japan face Paraguay on Tuesday in the second match of the double-header at Singapore's National Stadium.


Vinicius Says Less Training and Transfer Distractions May Explain Dip in Form

 Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
TT

Vinicius Says Less Training and Transfer Distractions May Explain Dip in Form

 Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)

Real Madrid winger Vinicius Junior says ‌his reduced training schedule, and transfer interest, may have affected his performances in an underwhelming start to his Real Madrid season.

The Brazilian signed a new contract until 2032 in August, but so far his output on the pitch has fallen short of his own previous standards. Press scrutiny in Spain has been intensified by the impressive start of Ivorian signing Yan Diomande, who has eclipsed Vinicius in his preferred left-sided role.

“I don’t think I prepared as well as I could have after the World Cup, because ‌the impact of ‌that tournament is so significant for all ‌Brazilians," ⁠he told a ⁠press conference in Singapore on Monday.

"Being knocked out so early was something we hadn’t expected. So, I took advantage of my holidays to enjoy myself, rest, relax, and spend more time with my family. I ended up training less than in previous years," he said.

“That may have affected my start to the season."

Vinicius' future ⁠at Real Madrid was a talking point in ‌Spain for months as he entered ‌the final year of his contract before re-signing in August. Premier ‌League champions Arsenal were said to be interested at the ‌time.

"On top of that, regarding my contract renewal, with so many clubs showing interest last summer, I felt truly overwhelmed, as with the situation at Real Madrid. But it’s a very long season.”

The 26-year-old said he ‌had a track record of hitting top form in the decisive moments of the season, ⁠and that he ⁠was on a positive trajectory.

“Maintaining such a high level for so long is always very difficult," said Vinicius.

"I think only Cristiano Ronaldo and (Lionel) Messi have managed to do this for so many years, reaching the same kinds of numbers."

"I am human, I often make mistakes, but I always try to improve.”

This season Vinicius has scored one goal and given three assists in his 12 Real Madrid appearances. Coach Jose Mourinho has only used him for a full 90 minutes on three occasions.

Nevertheless, he did score twice on Saturday in Brazil's 3-2 loss to Japan, and is likely to feature in another friendly against Singapore on Tuesday.