Referees' Strict Rulings on Unseen Handball Microcrimes are Ruining Football

Referee Martin Atkinson reviews a goal by Aston Villa during an Arsenal-Aston Villa game, in London, Britain, Nov. 8, 2020. (AFP)
Referee Martin Atkinson reviews a goal by Aston Villa during an Arsenal-Aston Villa game, in London, Britain, Nov. 8, 2020. (AFP)
TT

Referees' Strict Rulings on Unseen Handball Microcrimes are Ruining Football

Referee Martin Atkinson reviews a goal by Aston Villa during an Arsenal-Aston Villa game, in London, Britain, Nov. 8, 2020. (AFP)
Referee Martin Atkinson reviews a goal by Aston Villa during an Arsenal-Aston Villa game, in London, Britain, Nov. 8, 2020. (AFP)

There was a chilling moment during BT Sport’s coverage of Chelsea v Rennes earlier this month. A laughably punitive penalty kick had just been awarded against Rennes defender Dalbert Henrique. In the same flourish, Henrique also received a second yellow card for the crime of existing near a football while in possession of standard human arms.

As Dalbert trudged off looking sad, Darren Fletcher expressed some reservations on commentary about the justice of all this. “You might not like it Darren,” former referee Peter Walton replied, with an air of calm, vengeful assurance. “But it’s the law.”

The words seemed to hang in the air, to echo along some fresh and vital faultline. Let’s be clear, and with all due deference to Peter Walton, it’s not actually the law. The laws of football, so prissily insistent on their status, are not laws in any meaningful sense of the word. They’re transient things conjured into existence to give temporary shape to a game of ball-kicking. They’re stuff that some blokes have written down.

This isn’t meant as a personal criticism of Walton, who comes across on TV as an agreeable, well-informed figure, delivering his pronouncements with the quietly haunted air of a minor civic official being held captive by off-screen assailants and forced at gunpoint to talk in a slow, steady voice about degrees of contact and the unnatural positioning of arms.

The point here is the weird fetishizing of the penalty kick itself, the insistence that every achievable penalty kick must be awarded, on a granular strict liability basis. And that this previously hidden river of evil – the unseen microfoul, the handball microcrime – must be purged from the sporting world by a new class of tooled-up refereeing superhero.

Penalties have become a problem. There are, simply, too many of them. 36 penalty kicks have been awarded in the Premier League. All things being equal this would lead to a total of 195 across the season, double the standard tally, and a ludicrous 103 more than last year. At the end of which one needs-must part of football, a tool to fix a problem, is threatening to overwhelm all the other working parts. The award, dispute, taking and retaking of penalties is the biggest growth area in the elite game. The penalty kick has won. It’s a star – something that is both tedious in practice and a symptom of more profound textural change elsewhere.

This is not about the handball law, which is poorly adapted to the new reality and continues to create weird outcomes. These can be fixed. Serie A also had a record 187 penalties last year. But dig down and, as in England, the key driver is stupid fiddly fouls, not the more headline-grabbing stupid fiddly handballs. The issue isn’t VAR either, which will solve itself, and whose future lies in refinement, AI and more competent human handlers. The problem, for now, is penalty dominance, penalty culture, the penalty supremacy. We just need fewer of them.

It is worth recalling the basic point of a penalty kick. Penalties are a piece of artifice, a quick fix for a glitch in the machine. Penalties are what happens when football runs out of things to say. Not only does a penalty kick have no textural relationship to every other part of football – one kick at goal, in the middle of all these moving variables – it often distorts rather than reflects the flow.

There are good penalties, those that arrive out of the natural justice of a hard-earned attacking overload. Equally there are penalties that divert or independently decide the outcome. We may remember here the late penalty awarded to Manchester United at Paris Saint-Germain in March 2019, where a hopeful shot struck a hand while the ball was heading wide of goal.

A penalty kick awarded for a non-crime that affected nothing turned a creditable away goals defeat into a miraculous United win. A false narrative of promise and progress was born. From there came the permanent hiring of a manager who won five of his next 24 games and still looks genuinely surprised to be asked questions about the internal workings of Manchester United FC each time he appears in public.

More alarming is the way penalty culture is changing the way the game is played. There are matches where trying to draw a trip or strike a hand feels like the simplest route to victory, players whose value has been significantly boosted by cleverly refined penalty winning skills.

So much attacking play feels stilted and loose. Watch as Player A slaloms his way across the penalty area, Maradona-style, while his opponents Michael-Flatley away from him. Is this authentic? Is a wonder goal really a wonder goal when skilled defenders are reduced to bouncing around with their arms behind their back like a troupe of skinheads dancing to Jimmy Cliff? Some will find this staccato, interventionist style more to their liking. Those who yearn for completeness and perfectibility will see it as progress. Others will see a tepid tyranny of detail.

My own dislike of video refereeing has always been an emotional, semi-rational thing, based in the idea that football is one of the last remaining free collective experiences, unfiltered through a screen, unmediated by invisible hands. Football is a real-time gymnastic art, not a tech-driven quest for deep refereeing truths.

What is certain is this is something different, a step-change as the sport adapts to its status as a purely televisual product. My own compromise would be a clearly defined stiffening of the weight of evidence required to award a penalty kick, a higher bar for the ultimate sanction of the law. Walton’s literal-minded bunker of truth is a powerful voice in this process. For now it has, without warning or discussion, become the defining one.

The Guardian Sport



‘Not Competitive’ Brazil Can Improve, Insists Ancelotti

Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
TT

‘Not Competitive’ Brazil Can Improve, Insists Ancelotti

Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)

Brazil coach Carlo Ancelotti on Monday promised an improved performance in the year-ending clash against Singapore, admitting that his squad was "currently not competitive."

The Selecao lost 3-2 against Japan in a friendly in Singapore on Saturday, where Ancelotti and skipper Raphinha were red-carded after Japan scored the dramatic clincher in stoppage time.

"Given that the team is currently not competitive, I want to do more," Ancelotti told reporters in Singapore, where Brazil play on Tuesday.

The Italian, Brazil's first-ever permanent foreign coach, said: "I want to do more because I enjoy being here, so that the team can become more competitive on the global stage.

"The priority is to play well first (tomorrow) and to do well."

Ancelotti, 67, is coming under increasing pressure, following a string of underwhelming performances including two defeats, two wins and a draw in Brazil's last five international outings.

Japan avenged a 2-1 defeat by Brazil in their previous meeting at this year's World Cup, when the South Americans beat them in a round-of-32 clash.

After Saturday's loss, Ancelotti faced a barrage of criticism, including from former Brazilian national team star Romario.

Ancelotti brushed off Romario's remarks, saying "like anyone he has the right to express an opinion."

But the former Real Madrid coach, who reacted with fury after Brazil appealed for a foul in the build-up to Japan's winning goal on Saturday -- which was upheld by VAR -- said that his team "didn't deserve to lose" against Japan.

Japan face Paraguay on Tuesday in the second match of the double-header at Singapore's National Stadium.


Vinicius Says Less Training and Transfer Distractions May Explain Dip in Form

 Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
TT

Vinicius Says Less Training and Transfer Distractions May Explain Dip in Form

 Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)

Real Madrid winger Vinicius Junior says ‌his reduced training schedule, and transfer interest, may have affected his performances in an underwhelming start to his Real Madrid season.

The Brazilian signed a new contract until 2032 in August, but so far his output on the pitch has fallen short of his own previous standards. Press scrutiny in Spain has been intensified by the impressive start of Ivorian signing Yan Diomande, who has eclipsed Vinicius in his preferred left-sided role.

“I don’t think I prepared as well as I could have after the World Cup, because ‌the impact of ‌that tournament is so significant for all ‌Brazilians," ⁠he told a ⁠press conference in Singapore on Monday.

"Being knocked out so early was something we hadn’t expected. So, I took advantage of my holidays to enjoy myself, rest, relax, and spend more time with my family. I ended up training less than in previous years," he said.

“That may have affected my start to the season."

Vinicius' future ⁠at Real Madrid was a talking point in ‌Spain for months as he entered ‌the final year of his contract before re-signing in August. Premier ‌League champions Arsenal were said to be interested at the ‌time.

"On top of that, regarding my contract renewal, with so many clubs showing interest last summer, I felt truly overwhelmed, as with the situation at Real Madrid. But it’s a very long season.”

The 26-year-old said he ‌had a track record of hitting top form in the decisive moments of the season, ⁠and that he ⁠was on a positive trajectory.

“Maintaining such a high level for so long is always very difficult," said Vinicius.

"I think only Cristiano Ronaldo and (Lionel) Messi have managed to do this for so many years, reaching the same kinds of numbers."

"I am human, I often make mistakes, but I always try to improve.”

This season Vinicius has scored one goal and given three assists in his 12 Real Madrid appearances. Coach Jose Mourinho has only used him for a full 90 minutes on three occasions.

Nevertheless, he did score twice on Saturday in Brazil's 3-2 loss to Japan, and is likely to feature in another friendly against Singapore on Tuesday.


Belgium’s Lukaku Retires from International Football

Belgium's forward #09 Romelu Lukaku celebrates after scoring his team third goal during the UEFA Nations League, League A - Group 1, football match between Belgium and Turkey at the Maurice Dufrasne stadium, in Liege, eastern Belgium on October 2, 2026. (AFP)
Belgium's forward #09 Romelu Lukaku celebrates after scoring his team third goal during the UEFA Nations League, League A - Group 1, football match between Belgium and Turkey at the Maurice Dufrasne stadium, in Liege, eastern Belgium on October 2, 2026. (AFP)
TT

Belgium’s Lukaku Retires from International Football

Belgium's forward #09 Romelu Lukaku celebrates after scoring his team third goal during the UEFA Nations League, League A - Group 1, football match between Belgium and Turkey at the Maurice Dufrasne stadium, in Liege, eastern Belgium on October 2, 2026. (AFP)
Belgium's forward #09 Romelu Lukaku celebrates after scoring his team third goal during the UEFA Nations League, League A - Group 1, football match between Belgium and Turkey at the Maurice Dufrasne stadium, in Liege, eastern Belgium on October 2, 2026. (AFP)

Belgium forward Romelu Lukaku on Monday retired from international football after scoring 94 goals in 135 games for his country, saying he was "at peace" with his decision.

Lukaku featured in four World Cups for the Red Devils and helped them reach the quarter-finals of this year's tournament before losing to eventual winners Spain.

The 33-year-old, who now plays for Turkish club Fenerbahce, made his debut in 2010 as a teenager and was an unused substitute in Sunday's 4-1 Nations League win over Italy.

"These 16 years I gave all I had for the national team. It was a nice ride and I enjoyed every single moment," Belgium's record goal scorer said on Instagram.

"To the Belgium fans, thank you for the support you gave our team. I am proud to have represented my country in 4 World Cups and 3 European Championships.

"I will never forget those moments. I'm at peace with my decision to stop here," Lukaku said.

The former Chelsea, Manchester United and Inter Milan forward was part of Belgium's so-called "golden generation".

Lukaku, alongside Kevin De Bruyne, Thibaut Courtois and Eden Hazard, finished third at the 2018 World Cup, a best-ever finish for Belgium in the tournament but they failed to lift a trophy during the period.

"I played with amazing teammates that I will always be grateful for," Lukaku said.

"I want to thank them all. I want to thank all the coaches as well for pushing and trusting me to help the team," he added.

- 'Legend, my brother' -

A host of fellow Belgian players paid tribute to Lukaku.

"Legend, my brother," midfielder Axel Witsel said on Instagram.

"Thank you for everything my bro," Courtois said.

"So many amazing memories," the Real Madrid goalkeeper added.

Lukaku's last appearance for his country came in October's 4-1 loss to France.

"Beyond his exceptional performances on the pitch, he has been a true leader, with a strong personality and an essential role in the dressing room," Lukaku's former team-mate and now Belgium's technical director Simon Mignolet said in a statement from the Belgian football association.

"We respect his decision and are deeply grateful to him for everything he has brought to our national team," the former Liverpool goalkeeper added.

Belgium's first game without Lukaku will be a Nations League last-eight fixture in March.

"We must now turn our attention to the future and prepare for the Nations League quarter-finals," Mignolet said.

"With the ambition of continuing to make progress as a team," he added.