Iran’s Protest Movement and the Future of the Regime

Protesters clash with police after taking to the streets in Tehran in wake of the death of Mahsa Amini, September 21. (AFP)
Protesters clash with police after taking to the streets in Tehran in wake of the death of Mahsa Amini, September 21. (AFP)
TT

Iran’s Protest Movement and the Future of the Regime

Protesters clash with police after taking to the streets in Tehran in wake of the death of Mahsa Amini, September 21. (AFP)
Protesters clash with police after taking to the streets in Tehran in wake of the death of Mahsa Amini, September 21. (AFP)

Since assuming power in 1989, Iran’s supreme leader Ali Khamenei did not find any president agreeable to his desires and line of thought until Ebrahim Raisi, the current president, took office in 2021. Even Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who came to office with the support of the Revolutionary Guards (IRGC), and pretended to be obedient to Khamenei, gradually adopted positions opposing Khamenei’s will, which, in his second term, brought him into direct conflict with the Iranian leader.  

The conflict between Khamenei and the three presidents, Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani (1989-1997), Mohammad Khatami (1997-2005), and Hassan Rouhani (2013-2021), was mainly over the leader’s unconditional support of the hard-line conservatives, which on several occasions would lead to sabotaging the three presidents’ policies.  

Foreign policy was at the heart of the clash between Khamenei and the Revolutionary Guards, on one side, and the presidents on the other. Relations with the world, especially with the United States and to a lesser degree with the West in general, and regional policies that Khamenei and the IRGC viewed as a means to broaden the Islamic Republic’s sphere of influence (inspired by the doctrine of exporting the revolution) stood at the center of the battle.

Hard-liners, who form the core of power, consider enmity with America a justification of their existence and identity. Reconciliation with America would mean the end of the revolution. With the end of the revolution, there would be no need for the leader of the revolution, nor for the Revolutionary Guards, and the hard-liners’ camp would become totally irrelevant. The IRGC emphasizes that the US-Iran conflict is “fundamental, ideological, and existential and cannot be resolved through negotiations”.  

At the end of Hassan Rouhani's presidency in 2021, Khamenei and his supporters decided to put an end to the caricature-like state of democracy in Iran for good and purge reformists and moderates inside the pyramid of power for good.  

Hard-liners, under the leadership of Khamenei, decided that, by having the Guardian Council disqualify moderate or reformist first-tier, and even second-tier, candidates, they would pave the way for the hard-liners to gain control over the legislative and executive branches, thus, extinguishing any glimmers of hope for a huge faction of the society that supports modernity - a major reason behind the current uprising.  

In fact, the current uprising is mainly the continuation of a century-old battle between the conservative camp, meaning the traditionalists, and the modernists (liberal Muslims and secularists). In any case, the disaffected faction of society, which for about 25 years was devoted to the theory that reforms are possible through the ballot box, faced a new reality.  

As a result, this extremely large faction turned their backs on the ballot boxes in the 2019 parliamentary elections. The turnout rate was slightly more than 40%, the lowest in 11 parliamentary elections. In the Tehran province, participation decreased from 50% in the previous elections to 25%: of about 10 million eligible voters, about 7.5 million did not vote.  

Since holding an independent and reliable poll is not possible in Iran, it is hard to determine accurately what percentage of society opposes the regime. But perhaps one of the most striking findings from the secret bulletin, prepared by Fars News - the news agency managed by the IRGC - for IRGC commander Hossein Salami and leaked by the hacker group Black Reward, depicts “religious democracy” in Iran.  

The report states: “70% of people do not want to participate in a march in support of the regime and the revolution while 21.4% chose the option ‘very much’ and 5.9% chose the option ‘somewhat.’” Simply put, according to a survey conducted by the regime itself, between 70 and 75% of the country's population do not support the regime, considering that conservative supporters of the regime are too devoted not to participate in a simple demonstration.  

There are many reports about the protests of November 2019 (known as Bloody November), all of which emphasize that the backbone of the protests was the poor “tohidestan”.  

Outspoken former MP Ali Motahari said in a speech in parliament: “According to the confession of the intelligence agencies, the protesters were the poor masses.” With the widespread and brutal crackdown on the protests, which, according to Yadullah Javani, the political deputy of the IRGC, took place “in 29 provinces” (out of 31) and “hundreds of cities”, the regime became overconfident that it had nullified the potential for new protest movements for several years. 

Following the elimination of reformist and moderate candidates in the parliamentary elections, the Guardian Council also staged the 2021 presidential elections, which led to the election of Ebrahim Raisi and his accompanying team, undoubtedly the most incompetent among all post-revolutionary administrations.  

A glaring outcome of this move was the new administration adopting a scornful position during the nuclear talks in Vienna, thus losing the opportunity to reach a nuclear agreement, which would lead to the removal of the US sanctions and the release of billions of dollars of Iran’s blocked funds. For instance, the hard-line negotiators insisted that an inquiry by the International Atomic Energy Agency into nuclear particles found at Iran’s nuclear sites must be dropped as a pre-condition to signing a nuclear agreement. 

Confident that they would face no resistance, radical fanatics reactivated the Guidance Patrol, now operating under the Morality Police, to arrest women who violated the Islamic dress code. Shocking scenes of arresting women over the hijab issue were recorded and posted on social networks.  

The tragic death of 22-year-old Mahsa Amini in September, following a violent encounter with the Morality Police, was the spark that activated the dormant volcano of public anger. “Woman, life, freedom” became the central slogan of the protests, and women formed the main pillar of the movement in an unprecedented way.   

But a major difference between this new wave of protests and those in 2019 was evident. The massive attacks by the protesters on chain stores and banks in 2019 showed that the poor were the leading force behind that uprising. Slogans also indicated that protesters’ main concerns were livelihood and economic hardships. Slogans such as: “poverty, massacre, high cost - people have become victims” or “fuel has become more expensive - the poor have become poorer” were common, although the slogans of “death to the dictator” and “death to Khamenei” were also chanted.  

In the recent protests, however, the slogans are mainly based on women’s rights and express intense abhorrence of dictatorship. 

Another point that distinguishes the protests of 2019 and 2022 from each other was the 2019 use of slogans praising the last two Shahs of Iran, whose dynasty the 1979 revolution overthrew. Those slogans have not been heard often in the recent protests. This shows that the 2019 protesters were not sensitive about dictatorship and were only looking for relief from livelihood hardships. 

On the contrary, this year’s protesters had a strong anti-dictatorship position and, even opposing the Islamic Republic, did not demand the return of a government like that of Reza Shah and Mohammad Reza Shah. 

This year's protests, like all in the past, lacked a “leader with high popularity beyond the reach of the Islamic Republic” and were therefore vulnerable. A false comparison was common among protesters who argued that the countries where the “Arab Spring” took place did not have any clear and well-known leaders. The problem with this argument is that, precisely for that reason, all those movements faced defeat after the fall of the incumbent regimes.  

To succeed, a protest movement needs a popular leader who can mobilize and unite the protesters, give them direction, and, finally, fill the power vacuum after the fall of the current regime.  

Another major weakness of the current protests is the inability to attract the low-income classes of the society. Since the driving force of the movement is the defense of women’s rights and opposition to the dictatorship, livelihood-related slogans were seldom heard. The protests do not attract the huge low-income faction of society whose concern is bread.  

It is puzzling that, throughout the life of the Islamic Republic, no matter who has appeared as the leader of the opposition, inside and outside of Iran and including reformist leaders who came from the urban middle classes, not one emerged as the voice of the huge population of the poor.

According to the Ministry of Labor, 30 million Iranians live in “absolute poverty. A report by the semiofficial Iranian Labour News Agency (ILNA) maintains that seven out of ten Iranians live under poverty line.

The leader of the Iranian 1979 revolution, Khomeini, grasped this concept. He constantly emphasized that the main feature of his movement was the revolution of kookh’neshinan (those who live in very poor accommodations), the barefoot, and the oppressed.  

He used to say, “We will build housing for the homeless all over Iran. We will provide free water and electricity for the poor, free buses for the poor,” although not a single one of those promises was fulfilled. 

Explaining the state of Iran's disintegrated economy requires a separate article. It is enough to know that food prices have risen so dramatically that, according to the latest World Bank report, Iran is third in “real food inflation” among 161 countries, after Zimbabwe and Lebanon. 

To tackle the economic crisis, the Raisi administration, as dictated by Khamenei, instead of seeking the removal of US sanctions to increase desperately-needed foreign currency income and release of blocked assets, printed money at an astronomical rate, leading to the explosion of prices. 

The exchange rate with the dollar, which was 250,000 rials at the beginning of Raisi's presidency, has surpassed the 420,000 mark at the time of writing this article. Simply put, within 16 months, the national currency lost 45% of its value. 

While the depreciation of the national currency has accelerated, experts in Iran consider the current internal unrest and the resulting political instability as the main reason behind the trend.  

Another factor that has caused concern in Iran and made the situation of Iran’s currency more unstable was the recent trip of Chinese President Xi Jinping to Saudi Arabia.  

Although even before this trip, China was Saudi Arabia’s largest trade partner, with a trade volume of $87 billion per year, the signing of several memoranda of understanding worth about $30 billion during the same trip and the signing of the "Comprehensive Strategic Partnership Agreement” strengthened the impression in Iran that China does not view Iran a reliable source of oil supply, because of the country’s internal instability and its belligerent foreign policy, especially its ongoing conflict with the US. At the 20th Communist Party Congress in October, Xi emphasized that “energy security” is a key priority for China.  

It seems that, to get out of the current political and economic storm, the Islamic Republic is leaning towards returning to the negotiating table to finalize a nuclear accord.  

Iran’s foreign minister Hossein Amir Abdollahian has declared Iran’s readiness to sum up the Vienna talks based on the draft of the negotiation package that was the result of months of intensive and difficult talks. Reaching an agreement would not only significantly increase the possibility of selling oil by the Islamic Republic, but also would release funds blocked in foreign banks, which a UN representative declared to be $100 to $120 billion.

All that said, signing a new nuclear agreement may provide the Iranian regime with a temporary relief but will not solve the structural problems that now, more frequently than before, destabilize the system. 

First, any agreement between the Islamic Republic and the United States is unstable. Khamenei has forbidden talks and de-escalation with America because the continuation of enmity with America, as discussed earlier, is one of the pillars of this system's survival.  

However, in the contemporary history of international relations, it is impossible to find an example where two countries have been in irreconcilable conflict with each other and do not talk to de-escalate, but an agreement between them remains stable.  

At the height of the Cold War, several agreements were signed to reduce tension (détente) between the Soviet Union and the United States. The scenario of Trump’s exit from the nuclear deal could be repeated.  

Second, the gap caused by the hostile encounter between opponents of the regime and the government has become so deep that even silencing these protests will only stoke the anger of the suppressed, like a fire under the ashes, looking for another moment to erupt. This will not be the end of it.   

Finally, a study by the US National Bureau of Economic Research, using game theory and building a mathematical model, concluded that “dictators survive not because of their use of force or ideology but because they convince the public - rightly or wrongly - that they are competent.… If citizens conclude that the dictator is incompetent, they overthrow him in a revolution.. The study shows “that incompetent dictators can survive as long as economic shocks are not too large.”

*Shahir Shahidsaless is an Iranian-Canadian political analyst and freelance journalist writing about Iranian domestic and foreign affairs, the Middle East, and the US foreign policy in the region.



US Intel Says Iran Still Has 2,500 Missiles

 A woman visits a permanent exhibition of the National Aerospace Park of the Revolutionary Guard, just outside Tehran, Iran, Monday, Nov. 9, 2026. (AP)
A woman visits a permanent exhibition of the National Aerospace Park of the Revolutionary Guard, just outside Tehran, Iran, Monday, Nov. 9, 2026. (AP)
TT

US Intel Says Iran Still Has 2,500 Missiles

 A woman visits a permanent exhibition of the National Aerospace Park of the Revolutionary Guard, just outside Tehran, Iran, Monday, Nov. 9, 2026. (AP)
A woman visits a permanent exhibition of the National Aerospace Park of the Revolutionary Guard, just outside Tehran, Iran, Monday, Nov. 9, 2026. (AP)

The US intelligence community assesses that Iran has between 1,500 and 2,500 missiles in its arsenal, leaving Tehran with significant capacity to attack US and allied targets if all-out war resumes, the Wall Street Journal reported Sunday, citing US officials.

That is a low-confidence assessment, the officials said, due to the complications of tracking the precise number of missiles Iran has ready for launch or in storage. Even so, officials said it was clear Iran retained a formidable stockpile.

Despite the damage inflicted on Iran's missile production facilities by US and Israeli strikes, Tehran has continued replenishing its arsenal, albeit at a slower pace than before the war, relying primarily on components it had stored in advance, according to the WSJ. Iran also retains a large number of drones and short-range missiles, the officials said.

Iran's efforts to replenish its arsenal contradict statements by senior US administration officials, including President Donald Trump himself, that its military had been destroyed.

According to the officials, the rebuilding effort is also influencing internal discussions within the Trump administration over whether to launch another offensive against Iran alongside Israel.

Israeli military officials, meanwhile, estimate that Iran still possesses more than 1,500 ballistic missiles, although assessments vary among officials in the region because of the difficulty of determining the exact number.

Simone Ledeen, who served as deputy assistant secretary of defense for the Middle East during Trump's first term, said that even the lowest estimate of 1,500 missiles would mean Iran had replenished more than half of its estimated prewar stockpile.

She said Tehran rebuilt its arsenal between the 12-day war in June 2025 and the start of the current war in February.

50 missiles a month

Last week, western intelligence assessment cited by Bloomberg indicated that Iran can produce roughly 50 ballistic missiles per month, about half its prewar capacity, despite months of US and “Israeli” airstrikes that have heavily damaged its industrial base.

According to a Western official citing military intelligence reports, Iran most likely retains at least 1,700 ballistic missiles and continues building more at roughly half the prewar rate.

Its conventional military forces have largely been wiped out by the air campaign, yet the remaining stockpile and production capacity provide significant retaliatory potential.

Israel had estimated Iran possessed about 2,500 ballistic missiles before the war.

Since the conflict began on Feb. 28, Iran has launched more than 4,900 Shahed propeller-driven cruise missiles and at least 2,200 ballistic missiles, according to Bloomberg Economics.

Meanwhile, a bigger issue for US forces is missile interceptors: the more than 6,000 weapons Iran launched around the region ate up at least 1,000 Lockheed Martin Corp. Patriot PAC-3 interceptors, according to Bloomberg Economics analysis, $4 million weapons that are produced at a rate of just 650 a year.

Missiles are displayed in a permanent exhibition of the National Aerospace Park of the Revolutionary Guard, just outside Tehran, Iran, Monday, Nov. 9, 2026. (AP)

A WSJ report in April said Iran had thousands of short- and medium-range ballistic missiles at underground sites. US and Israeli strikes had blocked the entrances to some of these facilities. However, satellite images later showed that Iran had managed to clear the debris and regain access to some of them.

An Israeli official said the missiles stored at the underground sites likely survived intact.

Sophisticated tactics

Israeli and US officials said Iran's use of ballistic missiles, drones and more sophisticated tactics to target US military facilities, radar installations and early-warning systems across the Middle East prompted Washington to relocate numerous US military assets to Israel, which is considered safer.

Iran has also improved the effectiveness of its attacks by enhancing its intelligence and targeting data, with the help of allies, including Russia, and through tactics such as combining missiles and drones.

Bilal Saab, senior managing director of Washington-based geopolitical risk firm Trends US, said the number of missiles is not the only thing that matters.

“It's not just the size of that arsenal. It's how Iran uses it, and its commanders have learned a few tricks to be more effective,” he said.

Iran’s messages

In recent days, Iran has sought to send messages regarding the resumption and expansion of its ballistic missile program, after the US and Israeli militaries targeted most of its known missile bases during the recent war.

Iran’s Revolutionary Guard Corps spokesman General Hossein Mohebbi confirmed the removal of the 2,000-kilometer ceiling.

“That restriction has been lifted for us,” he declared, without specifying a new range or whether Iran possessed missiles exceeding the previous limit. He promised to demonstrate those capabilities “in practice.”

Iran is known to possess missiles with a range not exceeding 2,000 kilometers.

Earlier this month, Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei had issued an order to respond to threats of any scale or type with an “immediate and effective response without geographical restrictions.”

Khamenei issued the directives during his first publicly announced meeting with senior military commanders since taking office.

Meanwhile, Iranian state television displayed an inspection of a strategic missile facility belonging to the IRGC.

It aired footage on Tuesday describing the underground complex as a new “missile city.”

During his inspection of the strategic missile facility, Armed Forces Chief of Staff Maj. Gen. Ali Abdollahi said, “If the enemy makes a foolish move, our response will extend beyond the region,” promising further “surprises” in the next war.

On Saturday, Iran’s Tasnim news agency said the country could introduce technical modifications to its long-range missiles, enabling them to reach US territory.

The agency said modifications to the Khorramshahr-4’s warhead could increase its range to 3,000 or 4,000 kilometers by reducing the weight of its warhead to 1,500-kilogram instead of 2,000.


UN to Debate Rules for ‘Killer Robots’

Activists from the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, a coalition of non-governmental organizations opposing lethal autonomous weapons or so-called "killer robots", stage a protest at Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, Germany, March, 21, 2019. (Reuters)
Activists from the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, a coalition of non-governmental organizations opposing lethal autonomous weapons or so-called "killer robots", stage a protest at Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, Germany, March, 21, 2019. (Reuters)
TT

UN to Debate Rules for ‘Killer Robots’

Activists from the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, a coalition of non-governmental organizations opposing lethal autonomous weapons or so-called "killer robots", stage a protest at Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, Germany, March, 21, 2019. (Reuters)
Activists from the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, a coalition of non-governmental organizations opposing lethal autonomous weapons or so-called "killer robots", stage a protest at Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, Germany, March, 21, 2019. (Reuters)

Countries will debate whether to start talks on binding rules for autonomous weapons systems -- dubbed "killer robots" by critics -- at the UN from Monday, as concerns grow about their increasing use on the battlefield.

Warfare is undergoing a radical transformation as armies seek to capitalize on the boom in artificial intelligence to boost their fighting abilities by identifying and striking targets more quickly and more accurately.

But a chorus of voices, from campaigners to UN chief Antonio Guterres and Pope Leo XIV, have warned against the dangers of handing the power of life and death to fully autonomous machines.

"The need to regulate autonomous weapons has taken on new urgency" with developments in artificial intelligence, said Laurent Gisel, head of the Weapons and Conduct of Hostilities Unit at the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC).

Russia has reportedly used fully autonomous drones to deadly effect in its war on Ukraine, while Ukraine's own defense industry is pushing to develop autonomous "drone swarms".

Human Rights Watch said the meeting in Geneva this week of the UN's Review Conference of the Convention on Conventional Weapons (CCW) would leave civilians "dangerously exposed" if it failed to act decisively.

The meeting will bring together 128 countries to decide whether to open negotiations on legally binding rules.

- 'Carefully cultivated ambiguity' -

But while many states are in favor of tighter rules, as with other advanced military capabilities such as nuclear weapons, countries that have acquired the technology are reluctant to have their hands tied.

At the UN General Assembly last month, 163 states adopted a resolution calling for negotiations on rules governing autonomous weapons.

Five countries voted against -- the United States, Russia, Belarus, Israel and North Korea, which last week boasted of a new AI-enabled torpedo system.

Nine abstained, including Iran and China, which has maintained a "carefully cultivated ambiguity", said Laure de Roucy-Rochegonde of the French Institute of International Relations.

Washington has proposed a five-year process to develop a non-binding instrument, while NGOs and the ICRC are advocating for a one-year timeline.

In 2023, Guterres and ICRC President Mirjana Spoljaric Egger called on states to ban autonomous weapons before 2026.

The ICRC is calling for a ban on two categories of autonomous weapons: so-called "unpredictable autonomous weapons" and those designed or used to directly target humans.

Given the opposition from leading international powers, observers say it looks unlikely agreement will be reached this week to start talks on binding rules.


2 Planes Collide on the Ground in Miami, Only Minor Injuries Reported

FILE - Vehicles drive past the entrance to Miami International Airport in Miami May 12, 2020, (AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee, File)
FILE - Vehicles drive past the entrance to Miami International Airport in Miami May 12, 2020, (AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee, File)
TT

2 Planes Collide on the Ground in Miami, Only Minor Injuries Reported

FILE - Vehicles drive past the entrance to Miami International Airport in Miami May 12, 2020, (AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee, File)
FILE - Vehicles drive past the entrance to Miami International Airport in Miami May 12, 2020, (AP Photo/Wilfredo Lee, File)

Federal aviation safety officials on Sunday were investigating a minor collision between two planes at a taxiway intersection at Miami International Airport, where one aircraft's wingtip struck the nose of another, authorities said. Two people reported minor injuries.

The accident happened at about 9 p.m. Saturday and involved a Copa Airlines Boeing 737 passenger aircraft with 172 people aboard and a UPS Boeing 767 cargo plane, according to the National Transportation Safety Board and Copa Airlines. The wing of the Copa flight and the nose of the UPS plane collided, the NTSB said.

Photos taken at the scene show the UPS plane nose with a horizontal gash on one side and a larger hole in the middle, The Associated Press reported.

On audio recorded by ATC.com, a pilot on the UPS plane told air traffic control that he went too far at the intersection and his plane was clipped by the Copa flight. Air traffic control told the UPS pilot that he was supposed to yield to the Copa aircraft.

The NTSB said it was gathering information and may provide an update on Sunday.

The Copa plane had just arrived from Panama City and the UPS plane was headed to Bogota, Colombia, officials said.

In a statement on social media, Copa called the collision minor and said two of its passengers were treated at the scene for minor injuries.

UPS said it was working with authorities to determine what happened.

“We cannot speculate on the details of the incident,” UPS said in a statement.

“The National Transportation Safety Board is responsible for investigating incidents like this and will control the flow of information.”

The mishap came two months after an Amazon cargo plane careened off a runway at Miami International and smashed into a van carrying workers for a company that cleans airplanes, killing five people.