A Century on, Hemingway’s Prose Lures Revelers to Spain’s Pamplona 

Txistu musicians play traditional music as they wade through a crowd of thousands of revelers after the opening of Sanfermines in Pamplona, Spain, July 6, 2023. (Reuters)
Txistu musicians play traditional music as they wade through a crowd of thousands of revelers after the opening of Sanfermines in Pamplona, Spain, July 6, 2023. (Reuters)
TT

A Century on, Hemingway’s Prose Lures Revelers to Spain’s Pamplona 

Txistu musicians play traditional music as they wade through a crowd of thousands of revelers after the opening of Sanfermines in Pamplona, Spain, July 6, 2023. (Reuters)
Txistu musicians play traditional music as they wade through a crowd of thousands of revelers after the opening of Sanfermines in Pamplona, Spain, July 6, 2023. (Reuters)

The bell tolls - eight chimes. A fuse is lit and a rocket takes off. The pen doors open and out burst 12 behemoths - six bulls and six steers - working their pace up to a gallop, hooves thundering on the cobbled streets.

On cue, throngs of white-clad runners begin to sprint. They glance back, ready to dodge the charging beasts' piked horns with balletic moves defying a gory demise. Enraptured onlookers cheer on from balconies above.

It's the feast of St Fermin, the famed bull-running festival that engulfs downtown Pamplona every July when revelers from around the globe descend upon the northern Spanish city for nine days of adrenaline.

Some are drawn to the Sanfermines - as the festival is popularly known - by the timeless prose of one of the grandees of 20th-century American literature.

Ernest Hemingway (1899-1961) became besotted with the Sanfermines on his first visit, exactly 100 years ago. The bull-running, the bullfighting local experts - and the hedonistic partying - captivated him so deeply that he returned eight times between 1924 and 1959.

In 1926, he set his debut novel "The Sun Also Rises" partly in Pamplona. Based on his experiences there and among the American and British expat community in Paris, Hemingway quickly established himself with the book as the voice of what became known as the post-World War One "Lost Generation."

In the book, the narrator - Hemingway's alter-ego - chronicles a tale of excess, of constant and in some ways desperate carousing broken only by trips to the bullring to watch the bloody encounters.

"I can't stand it to think my life is going so fast and I'm not really living it," says one character in a famous exchange.

"Nobody ever lives their life all the way up except bull-fighters," replies the narrator.

Bill Hillmann, an English professor from Chicago and expert bull-runner, first read "The Sun Also Rises" while in college when he was 20. When the now 41-year-old turned the last page, he knew two things: He wanted to become a writer, and he would run in front of Pamplona's bulls someday.

Hillmann's first run was in 2005. He's been a fixture ever since.

"I got here and I was just blown away by it. It was everything in the book but times ten, you know. It was bigger. It was wilder. It was crazier," he says.

Over the years, he became friends with Hemingway's grandson John and great-grandson Michael. Being gored twice, in 2014 and 2017, hasn't dampened his enthusiasm.

"I've basically been kind of following Hemingway's ghost around, you know, and I'm a little bit haunted by him," Hillmann says.

For Cheryl Mountcastle, 69, her first encounter with "The Sun Also Rises" was at her New Orleans high school. For the past 24 years, she has rented the same apartment in Pamplona for the festival with her family. She says the novel's emphasis on drinking omits another side of the festival - such as sharing food and dancing in the street.

Leontxi Arrieta is one of the few remaining Pamplonians who met Hemingway in the flesh. The 91-year-old tells Reuters her family hosted the writer and his fourth wife, Mary Welsh, in their last visit to Sanfermines in 1959, two years before his death.

What has changed and what hasn’t

There's a recurring debate among Pamplona's residents: Is the city's overcrowding during Sanfermines Hemingway's fault? Did he misrepresent its essence in his writings? Has it been a victim of the novel's success?

Last year, 1.7 million people attended, leaving 1,200 tons of broken glass and assorted waste behind. A coveted spot on a balcony with a prime view of the bull-running can easily fetch 200 euros ($220) per person.

Pamplona native Miguel Izu, 63, who among several books on Sanfermines has penned one about the festival's links to Hemingway, believes the novelist's influence on its popularity has been exaggerated.

"It's true that he's contributed to making Sanfermines famous and bringing people here, but before Hemingway, tourists were already coming, especially from France," Izu explains.

Hemingway was unknown during his 1923 trip, he says, and only became a world-renowned figure after earning the Nobel Prize in 1954.

Izu acknowledges the city was still exploiting Hemingway's image to promote itself, "either deliberately or unconsciously". But the reverse also applies: "We made him into a sort of Sanfermines icon - you can't talk about them without mentioning Hemingway."

But not every foreigner at the festival has been lured by the author, especially since the rise of social media. Australian William Kappal, 23, and his friends were instead attracted by YouTube videos showcasing the exhilarating danger of the bull-running coupled with plenty of roistering.

Asked if they had ever heard of Hemingway, Kappal chuckles.

"Nah. Should we look him up?"

Many things have changed since 1923 - the familiar white outfits decked with red scarves and waistbands worn by runners, for instance, only came into fashion after 1931 - and northern Spain has transitioned from an agrarian to an industrialized society. But the essence of the festival remains, Izu says.

Cafes featured in the book such as the Iruña still welcome revelers. Visitors still party, and pray, and seek a space in the crowded streets to get a view of the bulls without risk of being gored by those devilish horns.

Says Izu: "I think that if (Hemingway) came back to life ... he would look around and say: 'Some things are strange, but well, it's basically the same old Sanfermines.'"



Indonesia Showcases Returned Artifacts it Had Sought for Decades from the Netherlands

Indonesia Showcases Returned Artifacts it Had Sought for Decades from the Netherlands
TT

Indonesia Showcases Returned Artifacts it Had Sought for Decades from the Netherlands

Indonesia Showcases Returned Artifacts it Had Sought for Decades from the Netherlands

Centuries-old stone Buddha statues and precious jewelries repatriated by the Dutch government to its former colony are on display at Indonesia's National Museum, providing a glimpse into the country's rich heritage that the government had struggled to retrieve.
The collection is part of more than 800 artifacts that were returned under a Repatriation Agreement signed in 2022 between Indonesia and the Netherlands, said Gunawan, the museum's head of cultural heritage. The objects are not just those looted in conflict, but also seized by scientists and missionaries or smuggled by mercenaries during the four centuries of colonial rule, The Associated Press reported.
“I was so amazed that we have all of these artifacts,” said Shaloom Azura, a visitor to the museum in Jakarta. She hoped other historical objects can be repatriated too, "so we don’t have to go to the Netherlands just to see our own cultural heritage.”
The agreement to return cultural objects was inspired by the new era of global restitution and repatriation efforts.
In 2021, France said it was returning statues, royal thrones and sacred altars taken from the West African nation of Benin. Belgium returned a gold-capped tooth belonging to the slain Congolese independence hero Patrice Lumumba.
Cambodia in 2023 welcomed the return of priceless stolen artifacts that had been seized during periods of war and instability. Many of the items returned so far have come from the United States. And the Berlin museum authority said it would return hundreds of human skulls from the former German colony of East Africa.
The Dutch government announced the same year the return of the Indonesian treasures and looted artifacts from Sri Lanka.
Only a few objects made it back before a deal was struck. The repatriation “is not something out of the blue” but followed a lengthy process, said I Gusti Agung Wesaka Puja, former Indonesian ambassador to the Netherlands who also headed the government's team tasked to recover the objects.
He said negotiations with the Dutch government have been ongoing since Indonesia’s independence in August 1945, but it was only in July 2022 that Indonesia formally requested the return of its cultural objects with a list of specific items.
“This repatriation is important for us to reconstruct history that may be lost or obscured or manipulated,” Puja said. “And we can fill the gap of the historical vacuum that has existed so far.”
The Dutch government in 1978 returned the famous 13th-century statue of princess Pradnya Paramita from the Javanese Singhasari Kingdom. During the same visit to Indonesia, then-Queen Juliana also returned a saddle and spear seized from Prince Diponegoro, a Javanese nobleman considered a national hero for his struggle against colonial rule in the 19th century.
The prince's scepter was returned in 2015. In 2020, Dutch King Willem-Alexander handed over Diponegoro's gold-plated kris dagger in his first state visit to Indonesia.
Also pending is the return of the “Java Man” — the first known example of homo erectus that was collected by Dutch paleoanthropologist Eugene Dubois in the 19th century.
“The importance of the most recent repatriation is knowledge creation, that will give society a more complete knowledge of our past history,” said Puja.
He said the recent repatriation efforts seem to also be motivated by practical considerations, such as when the Delf city administration sent back 1,500 objects in 2019. They were part of the bankrupted Nusantara Museum collection.
However, Marc Gerritsen, the Dutch ambassador to Indonesia, said the repatriation would only focus on cultural objects that are requested, rather than emptying out European museums.
“There is a huge interest from the Dutch public in Indonesian history and Indonesian culture, so we do know that if Dutch museums put these objects on display, there will be an interest,” Gerritsen said, “But again, the heart of the matter is that the colonial collections artifacts that were stolen during the colonial period are returned on the basis of this process that was established.”
He said the Netherlands, the largest investor from the European Union in Indonesia, has a unique relationship with Southeast Asia’s biggest economy.
“Of course, we have elements of which we are not proud, but we are really grateful for the fact that Indonesia is so much attached to preserving that history,” Gerritsen said.
To support its former colony in safeguarding its repatriated cultural heritage, the Dutch government has offered to assist in improving museum storage conditions and staff expertise.
Some researchers have criticized Indonesia, the world’s largest archipelago nation of 17,000 islands, for a lack of legal framework to protect its rich cultural heritage and natural conservation.
At least 11 cases of museum thefts were reported between 2010 and 2020, according to a 2023 report by Rucitarahma Ristiawan, a lecturer of cultural science at Gajah Mada University, and two other researchers.
In 2023, dozens of ships dredged the bottom of the Batanghari River in Jambi province, and the crews looted archaeological objects including porcelain, coins, metal and gold artifacts, which are believed to have been sold abroad, the report said.
“I think there is a lot to be reviewed from our historical works that are still kept in other countries,” said Frengky Simanjuntak, who marveled at the Repatriation Exhibition at the National Museum, on display since October. “So it’s not just about bringing them back home, but how to protect them."