Pundits are Good for the Game Even if Ex-Players’ Censure Can Feel Out of Line

 From a current player’s perspective, Gary Neville’s trenchant criticism of Arsenal in the Carabao Cup final seemed almost like the unspoken rule of protection had been broken. Photograph: Mark Leech/Offside/Getty Images
From a current player’s perspective, Gary Neville’s trenchant criticism of Arsenal in the Carabao Cup final seemed almost like the unspoken rule of protection had been broken. Photograph: Mark Leech/Offside/Getty Images
TT

Pundits are Good for the Game Even if Ex-Players’ Censure Can Feel Out of Line

 From a current player’s perspective, Gary Neville’s trenchant criticism of Arsenal in the Carabao Cup final seemed almost like the unspoken rule of protection had been broken. Photograph: Mark Leech/Offside/Getty Images
From a current player’s perspective, Gary Neville’s trenchant criticism of Arsenal in the Carabao Cup final seemed almost like the unspoken rule of protection had been broken. Photograph: Mark Leech/Offside/Getty Images

“Three … two … one … and we’re live on air.” It’s a phrase I have heard more and more over the last few months because of my first steps into the world of sports broadcasting and punditry.

I must admit that as a player I didn’t have an appreciation of the hard work by the floor staff, the producers and directors constantly instructing you through your earpiece, and the presenters with their impressive array of knowledge and awareness to stay within time constraints, and nor did I have an understanding of actually how difficult it is to be in front of lights and a camera while a vast audience evaluates your every word as you try to be as interesting and informative as possible, while knowing that any slip-up cannot be re-recorded.

With the ever-growing popularity of the Premier League all over the world and the increasingly competitive battle for TV rights and viewing figures, the art of punditry is becoming an increasing part of our sport with millions of fans expecting not only great games but informative, insightful analysis during and after matches because of the money they are paying to watch.

After Manchester City’s 3-0 win against Arsenal in last Sunday’s Carabao Cup final much of the furore wasn’t about City’s dominant performance or a bad day at the office for the Gunners, it concerned the in-game analysis of Gary Neville and his damning appraisal of the performance of Arsène Wenger’s team. As Neville stated afterwards there has now become an “analysis of analysis”, which is the perfect way to sum up what happened.

From a current player’s perspective, before I had any kind of understanding of the difficulty of being a live TV pundit, I would have taken the position that what Neville said during the game and the manner in which he said it were a step too far from someone who has been in the very same position that those Arsenal players found themselves in on Sunday afternoon. Being outclassed in a final is hurtful enough, but then having your name picked out as someone lacking effort and desire during the match is not what you would expect from a fellow, if former, pro. It’s almost like the unspoken rule of protection had been broken.

However, being fortunate enough to have had first-hand experience of being in Neville’s shoes, I understand that he’s being paid to give his expert opinion and call football matches as he sees them, live without the luxury of time to think, something that every fee-paying member of the public is more than entitled to hear and dissect in their own way. The fact is that Neville is no longer a player and, because he is now being paid to be a TV pundit, he is at liberty to say what he thinks and accept the repercussions of his words in his new occupation.

Since he has started working for Sky, Neville has raised the bar in terms of tactical analysis of football – not only commenting on what is happening on the field of play but why it is happening and the outcomes of every individual and team performance in the Premier League, which is now being appraised in a much more intelligent, in-depth and objective manner to the general public.

This can only be good for our game, even if for players such as me it means that any defensive mistake is critically analysed in front of millions of people on a Monday night. But surely objectively critiquing tactics, player performance and a coach’s decisions in an impartial manner creates an increased pressure on players and coaches, and in turn an acceptance of responsibility and accountability for our actions on the field of play.

With the increased profile of pundits such as Neville, Jamie Carragher, Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard on our TV screens with their extensive knowledge and experience of football at the highest level, they educate not only supporters but younger players listening to every word while continually raising standards – in terms of objectively and impartially analysing matches, giving their insight without resorting to making scapegoats of players and making them easy targets for abuse in the stadiums and sensationalist phone-in radio stations, not to mention social media.

We have repeatedly seen assertions from players and managers who complain that it’s easy to talk about football away from the game in the comfort of a TV studio, out of the hotseat and away from the pressures at sharp end, and I understand that viewpoint, but in my experience it is not as easy as some make it look!

I believe that if TV punditry is performed correctly, with the homework, impartiality, professionalism and diligence that Neville exemplifies in his broadcasting, it can bring a huge benefit to our game, increasing the football knowledge of supporters at home who are a lot more intelligent than many of our previous media have catered for. And as players and coaches in an era when we are being analysed more than ever we must remember that the analysts must be analysed and challenged too because that is the nature of the game.

The Guardian Sport



Irish Boxer Lee Reeves Dies at Age 31, Three Months after Dublin Title Fight Injury

Irish boxer Lee Reeves. Reuters
Irish boxer Lee Reeves. Reuters
TT

Irish Boxer Lee Reeves Dies at Age 31, Three Months after Dublin Title Fight Injury

Irish boxer Lee Reeves. Reuters
Irish boxer Lee Reeves. Reuters

Irish boxer Lee Reeves has died more than three months after being injured during a fight in Dublin, promoter Queensberry said Tuesday. He was 31.

"Everyone at Queensberry is devastated to learn of the passing of Lee Reeves," Queensberry Promotions said in a statement.

Reeves was hospitalized after being knocked out by compatriot Gary Cully in the 10th and final round of their Boxing Union of Ireland Celtic super-lightweight title fight on Aug. 1.

Reeves was carried from the ring on a stretcher after receiving initial treatment.

Queensberry had said after the fight that his condition was critical but stable.

“Lee was an immensely talented boxer, as well as a true role model and inspiration to his community,” the statement added Tuesday, according to The Associated Press. “Our deepest condolences go to Lee’s family, friends and all those who loved him. We ask that their privacy be respected at this incredibly difficult time. Rest in peace, Lee.”


Alonso to Enter Dakar Rally with Loeb and Aston Martin Team

November 5, 2026 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso during a press conference ahead of the F1 Sao Paulo Grand Prix. (Reuters)
November 5, 2026 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso during a press conference ahead of the F1 Sao Paulo Grand Prix. (Reuters)
TT

Alonso to Enter Dakar Rally with Loeb and Aston Martin Team

November 5, 2026 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso during a press conference ahead of the F1 Sao Paulo Grand Prix. (Reuters)
November 5, 2026 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso during a press conference ahead of the F1 Sao Paulo Grand Prix. (Reuters)

Double Formula One champion Fernando Alonso will compete in next January's Dakar Rally in an Aston Martin Dreadnought entry run by engineering partner Prodrive.

The 45-year-old Spaniard, a 32-time Grand Prix winner and two-time Le Mans 24 Hours winner, will be racing in the annual event for the second time after competing with Toyota in 2020, finishing 13th.

France's nine-time world rally champion Sebastien Loeb and Brazil's reigning world rally-raid champion Lucas Moraes will be his teammates in a three-car entry.

The 49th edition of the Dakar Rally will ‌be held in ‌Morocco from January 9 to 23, with a prologue and first ‌stage ⁠in Portugal, after ⁠being moved from Saudi Arabia due to security concerns.

The 24-round Formula One season is due to start in Bahrain in March after testing in late February.

Alonso, who will again have compatriot and five-time motorcycle Dakar winner Marc Coma as co-driver, is racing in the Las Vegas Grand Prix this weekend. He said he had turned his thoughts to Dakar after deciding to continue in Formula One with Aston Martin.

“In the end, the decision became simple. I wanted to embrace ⁠the challenge completely and take on both Formula One and the ‌Dakar Rally in the same year," he explained in ‌a statement.

"In 2020, Dakar was one of the most challenging and enjoyable experiences of my career. ‌I have enormous respect for this race and the specialists who have mastered it.

"Formula One ‌remains my priority. But I am a racing driver, and challenges like this are why I love competing. I’m looking forward to seeing what we can achieve."

LOEB CHASES FIRST DAKAR WIN

In October, Alonso told reporters at the Singapore Grand Prix that he felt the desert endurance race would be physically ‌incompatible with his Formula One commitments.

Loeb, 52, will also be chasing a first Dakar win after 10 previous attempts that have brought ⁠him 28 stage ⁠wins to date.

“Winning the Dakar is very important to me,” said the Frenchman, who will be partnered by Belgian Fabian Lurquin. “We have come close several times, and the motivation is there to keep working until we achieve it."

The Dreadnought is a digital-only tactical SUV created exclusively for gamers playing "Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4" that will now be brought into the real world by Prodrive, Aston Martin's partners in endurance GT racing.

The Dakar will be Aston Martin Racing’s debut in the world rally-raid championship.

"Aston Martin's ambition for this program has been clear from the outset: to create a car capable of competing at the front of the world's toughest motorsport event," said Prodrive Chairman David Richards.

"By combining Aston Martin's vision with Prodrive's experience in rallying, endurance racing and Dakar competition, we have built a strong foundation. With an exceptional driver line-up and a highly capable engineering team, we look forward to seeing Dreadnought take on this remarkable challenge."


Owono Does Not Deserve 12-Match Ban Over De Miguel Death, Says Andorra Owner Pique

Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
TT

Owono Does Not Deserve 12-Match Ban Over De Miguel Death, Says Andorra Owner Pique

Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)

FC Andorra owner Gerard ‌Pique said goalkeeper Jesus Owono did not deserve the 12-match suspension he received following the challenge that led to the death of Tenerife forward Jesus de Miguel.

Owono and De Miguel collided during a Spanish second-tier match on November 2. De Miguel was taken to intensive care and died the following day.

The disciplinary committee of the Spanish football federation (RFEF) banned Owono for violent conduct which resulted in serious ‌injury last week.

"Players, ‌former players, coaches, goalkeepers, everyone has ‌called ⁠it an accident," ⁠Pique said in a video posted on social media late on Monday.

"I truly believe that imposing the maximum sanction on Jesus for this action puts him in a situation he does not deserve, because he is not to blame for all of ⁠this having happened."

Former Barcelona player Pique ‌pointed to the three-match ‌ban handed to Albacete's Jose Corpas for accidentally kicking Sabadell ‌player Quadri Liameed in the head during a ‌recent match in Spain.

"Fortunately Quadri is fine, the consequences in this case were not fatal, and the committee decided to sanction Corpas with three matches," Pique added.

"With ‌all this, my reflection is: what is being sanctioned, the action or the ⁠consequences?"

The RFEF ⁠did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside regular business hours in Spain.

Owono, 25, has withdrawn from Equatorial Guinea's squad for Africa Cup of Nations qualifiers against Zimbabwe this month and Pique said it was unlikely the goalkeeper would return to action as soon as his suspension is up.

"Jesus is going to need far more than 12 matches before he is available and able to compete," he added. "No sanction is going to bring Demi (De Miguel) back to us."