Why There Is No Accounting for a Large Slice of Luck in the Premier League

 Claude Puel was sacked by Leicester after a ‘dismal’ sequence of results. Or was it actually a desperate run of luck? Photograph: Andrew Couldridge/Action Images via Reuters
Claude Puel was sacked by Leicester after a ‘dismal’ sequence of results. Or was it actually a desperate run of luck? Photograph: Andrew Couldridge/Action Images via Reuters
TT

Why There Is No Accounting for a Large Slice of Luck in the Premier League

 Claude Puel was sacked by Leicester after a ‘dismal’ sequence of results. Or was it actually a desperate run of luck? Photograph: Andrew Couldridge/Action Images via Reuters
Claude Puel was sacked by Leicester after a ‘dismal’ sequence of results. Or was it actually a desperate run of luck? Photograph: Andrew Couldridge/Action Images via Reuters

Back in the late 1990s a bookmaking firm came up with an interesting new game to keep the customers in its betting shops amused while they were waiting for the racing to start. It ran computer simulations of entire seasons in football’s top flight, several times each morning and squeezed into just a few minutes, complete with “pre‑season odds” to attract fivers and tenners from fans of the big-name teams. It was a little like Wembley, the 1970s board game that did something similar for the FA Cup, and the virtual, highly accelerated Football League proved quite a hit with the regulars.

That was until the morning when, much to the surprise of all concerned, they cranked up the computer, fed in all the odds and possibilities, hit return and five minutes later watched as Charlton were installed as the newly simulated champions of England after starting their imaginary campaign completely unbacked at odds of 2,000-1.

The punters felt they had been played for mugs and yelled “Fix”, but the bookie was as genuinely astonished as any of the customers. They had all been confounded by the basic rule of probability that says that even the most unlikely eventualities will come to pass if you give them enough time and opportunity.

The computer, admittedly, had come up with some distinctly odd results to get Charlton to the top of the pile, but it did not produce any that were, in isolation, unimaginable. What was unusual was the sheer number that happened to crop up in the same simulation, not only in relation to Charlton but also for the teams that set out with – on (virtual) paper – a much better chance of success.

Jump forward about 20 years and much the same was true for Leicester in 2015-16 when they performed well above expectation and got the rub of the green while the big six sides that dominated the betting at the outset all chose the same season to do the opposite. Leicester were an excellent side, but, like the virtual Addicks, they still needed a big dollop of luck, most obviously in an unusual number of unlikely results elsewhere, to get over the line with only 81 points.

These two highly unexpected results, one virtual and one actual, came to mind while trawling through metrics on the most recent Premier League season on fivethirtyeight.com, which was founded by the American data-analysis legend (and sports fan) Nate Silver. The 2018-19 season was, on the face of it, one that largely followed the script. Manchester City, the odds-on favourites, beat the second-favourites, Liverpool, with the next four teams in the betting duly taking the next four spots in the table. Yet the data suggests there were still many dozens of matches throughout the season when the result bore little or no resemblance to the outcome predicted by the data.

FiveThirtyEight uses three metrics to analyse Premier League matches, the simplest of which is expected goals – xG – the increasingly familiar number that seeks to assess how many goals a team could have expected to score from the chances created in any given match. There were 380 matches in the 2018-19 Premier League season with the home teams scoring a total of 596 goals, very close to the xG prediction of 615. Away teams scored 476, against an xG prediction of 496. So far, so good.

Compare the results of individual matches against the xG numbers, however, and some startling discrepancies begin to appear. In all there were 64 games when the difference between the actual outcome and the result predicted by xG amounted to at least two goals – which can be enough to turn three points into none. That is 64 matches, almost exactly one in every six over the course of the season, when the xG data suggests the result was down to a large slice of luck.

There were a dozen matches when the scoreline and the xG forecast disagreed by at least three goals, including three where the difference was four or more. Two of these were thrashings when the final scoreline merely exaggerated the xG numbers, although Southampton fans who witnessed their 6-1 drubbing at the Etihad might – or might not – want to know that an xG of 2.49/1.96 suggests the same set of chances on another day could easily have seen them leave with a point. Nor is this the result of an obvious drawback in some xG estimates, which assess the quality of a chance but not the quality of the player presented with it. The FiveThirtyEight numbers are modified to reflect the “historic conversion rates” of City’s starting forward line of Sterling, Agüero and Sane, all of whom scored.

But there was less of an imbalance in the third match with a four-goal difference between xG and actuality. Tottenham’s 3-1 defeat of Leicester in February was, by this measure, the travesty of the season, achieved despite xG’s insistence (1.18 to 3.18) that it should really have been the other way around.

This was also Claude Puel’s penultimate game in charge of Leicester. Their previous outing, a 1-0 home defeat by Manchester United, was 1.9 to 1.3 in Leicester’s favour on xG, while the game before that, a 1-1 draw at Anfield, was 0.6/1.2 to the Foxes on xG. Yet, after shipping four at home to Crystal Palace a fortnight later (and in a match that was a rather less damning 1.1/1.9 on xG), Puel’s tenure came to what was variously described as an “inevitable” conclusion after a “dismal” sequence of results.

Inevitable? Dismal? Or a desperate run of luck at the worst possible time, in a league where pure chance plays a significant, possibly decisive, role in one match in six?

There are many fans and commentators who remain suspicious of xG and similar metrics that attempt to bring some statistical rigour to football analysis. They are often the same fans and commentators who claim that “luck evens out over the season” or that “the final table never lies” – which is, and always will be, baloney.

The Guardian Sport



Alonso to Enter Dakar Rally with Loeb and Aston Martin Team

November 5, 2026 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso during a press conference ahead of the F1 Sao Paulo Grand Prix. (Reuters)
November 5, 2026 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso during a press conference ahead of the F1 Sao Paulo Grand Prix. (Reuters)
TT

Alonso to Enter Dakar Rally with Loeb and Aston Martin Team

November 5, 2026 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso during a press conference ahead of the F1 Sao Paulo Grand Prix. (Reuters)
November 5, 2026 Aston Martin's Fernando Alonso during a press conference ahead of the F1 Sao Paulo Grand Prix. (Reuters)

Double Formula One champion Fernando Alonso will compete in next January's Dakar Rally in an Aston Martin Dreadnought entry run by engineering partner Prodrive.

The 45-year-old Spaniard, a 32-time Grand Prix winner and two-time Le Mans 24 Hours winner, will be racing in the annual event for the second time after competing with Toyota in 2020, finishing 13th.

France's nine-time world rally champion Sebastien Loeb and Brazil's reigning world rally-raid champion Lucas Moraes will be his teammates in a three-car entry.

The 49th edition of the Dakar Rally will ‌be held in ‌Morocco from January 9 to 23, with a prologue and first ‌stage ⁠in Portugal, after ⁠being moved from Saudi Arabia due to security concerns.

The 24-round Formula One season is due to start in Bahrain in March after testing in late February.

Alonso, who will again have compatriot and five-time motorcycle Dakar winner Marc Coma as co-driver, is racing in the Las Vegas Grand Prix this weekend. He said he had turned his thoughts to Dakar after deciding to continue in Formula One with Aston Martin.

“In the end, the decision became simple. I wanted to embrace ⁠the challenge completely and take on both Formula One and the ‌Dakar Rally in the same year," he explained in ‌a statement.

"In 2020, Dakar was one of the most challenging and enjoyable experiences of my career. ‌I have enormous respect for this race and the specialists who have mastered it.

"Formula One ‌remains my priority. But I am a racing driver, and challenges like this are why I love competing. I’m looking forward to seeing what we can achieve."

LOEB CHASES FIRST DAKAR WIN

In October, Alonso told reporters at the Singapore Grand Prix that he felt the desert endurance race would be physically ‌incompatible with his Formula One commitments.

Loeb, 52, will also be chasing a first Dakar win after 10 previous attempts that have brought ⁠him 28 stage ⁠wins to date.

“Winning the Dakar is very important to me,” said the Frenchman, who will be partnered by Belgian Fabian Lurquin. “We have come close several times, and the motivation is there to keep working until we achieve it."

The Dreadnought is a digital-only tactical SUV created exclusively for gamers playing "Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4" that will now be brought into the real world by Prodrive, Aston Martin's partners in endurance GT racing.

The Dakar will be Aston Martin Racing’s debut in the world rally-raid championship.

"Aston Martin's ambition for this program has been clear from the outset: to create a car capable of competing at the front of the world's toughest motorsport event," said Prodrive Chairman David Richards.

"By combining Aston Martin's vision with Prodrive's experience in rallying, endurance racing and Dakar competition, we have built a strong foundation. With an exceptional driver line-up and a highly capable engineering team, we look forward to seeing Dreadnought take on this remarkable challenge."


Owono Does Not Deserve 12-Match Ban Over De Miguel Death, Says Andorra Owner Pique

Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
TT

Owono Does Not Deserve 12-Match Ban Over De Miguel Death, Says Andorra Owner Pique

Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)

FC Andorra owner Gerard ‌Pique said goalkeeper Jesus Owono did not deserve the 12-match suspension he received following the challenge that led to the death of Tenerife forward Jesus de Miguel.

Owono and De Miguel collided during a Spanish second-tier match on November 2. De Miguel was taken to intensive care and died the following day.

The disciplinary committee of the Spanish football federation (RFEF) banned Owono for violent conduct which resulted in serious ‌injury last week.

"Players, ‌former players, coaches, goalkeepers, everyone has ‌called ⁠it an accident," ⁠Pique said in a video posted on social media late on Monday.

"I truly believe that imposing the maximum sanction on Jesus for this action puts him in a situation he does not deserve, because he is not to blame for all of ⁠this having happened."

Former Barcelona player Pique ‌pointed to the three-match ‌ban handed to Albacete's Jose Corpas for accidentally kicking Sabadell ‌player Quadri Liameed in the head during a ‌recent match in Spain.

"Fortunately Quadri is fine, the consequences in this case were not fatal, and the committee decided to sanction Corpas with three matches," Pique added.

"With ‌all this, my reflection is: what is being sanctioned, the action or the ⁠consequences?"

The RFEF ⁠did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside regular business hours in Spain.

Owono, 25, has withdrawn from Equatorial Guinea's squad for Africa Cup of Nations qualifiers against Zimbabwe this month and Pique said it was unlikely the goalkeeper would return to action as soon as his suspension is up.

"Jesus is going to need far more than 12 matches before he is available and able to compete," he added. "No sanction is going to bring Demi (De Miguel) back to us."


Alcaraz Says Experience Helped Him Crack Indoor Code after Back-to-back Title Wins

Tennis - ATP Finals - Palasport Olimpico, Turin, Italy - November 16, 2026  Spain's Carlos Alcaraz in action during his group stage match against Francis Tiafoe of the US. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane
Tennis - ATP Finals - Palasport Olimpico, Turin, Italy - November 16, 2026 Spain's Carlos Alcaraz in action during his group stage match against Francis Tiafoe of the US. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane
TT

Alcaraz Says Experience Helped Him Crack Indoor Code after Back-to-back Title Wins

Tennis - ATP Finals - Palasport Olimpico, Turin, Italy - November 16, 2026  Spain's Carlos Alcaraz in action during his group stage match against Francis Tiafoe of the US. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane
Tennis - ATP Finals - Palasport Olimpico, Turin, Italy - November 16, 2026 Spain's Carlos Alcaraz in action during his group stage match against Francis Tiafoe of the US. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane

Carlos Alcaraz said experience has finally taught him how to get the best out of his game on indoor courts, with the world number three carrying his title-winning form from Vienna and Paris into this week's ATP Finals in Turin.

Only three of his 29 career titles have come on indoor hard courts, with his first coming in Rotterdam last year.

The 23-year-old has enjoyed a strong run of form since ⁠returning to the ⁠tour in August after nearly five months out with a right wrist injury.

His 6-2 6-2 win over Frances Tiafoe in his opening match at the ATP Finals on Monday showed he could be a real force at ⁠the season finale.

"I've always said that I'm not bad on indoor courts," the seven-times Grand Slam champion told reporters. "I just feel like others are a little bit better than me.

"It was about time, it was about getting more experience and it was about understanding how I should play on indoor courts,” Reuters quoted him as saying.

The faster conditions can mean Alcaraz has less time to ⁠impose ⁠his game, but he said he was confident of going toe-to-toe with the big servers and flatter hitters.

Tiafoe was in no doubt about Alcaraz's current level.

"He has moments where he's definitely Superman and he's playing pretty insane," Tiafoe said.

"But again, it's one of those things, you've got to appreciate greatness."

Alcaraz continues his campaign for a first ATP Finals crown when he takes on former champion Daniil Medvedev on Wednesday.