VAR – Let’s Press Pause on Boxing Day and Check If We Want to Rewind Technology

 Graham Scott receives the VAR decision to disallow a goal scored by Sheffield United’s David McGoldrick against Tottenham on Saturday. Photograph: Peter Nicholls/Reuters
Graham Scott receives the VAR decision to disallow a goal scored by Sheffield United’s David McGoldrick against Tottenham on Saturday. Photograph: Peter Nicholls/Reuters
TT

VAR – Let’s Press Pause on Boxing Day and Check If We Want to Rewind Technology

 Graham Scott receives the VAR decision to disallow a goal scored by Sheffield United’s David McGoldrick against Tottenham on Saturday. Photograph: Peter Nicholls/Reuters
Graham Scott receives the VAR decision to disallow a goal scored by Sheffield United’s David McGoldrick against Tottenham on Saturday. Photograph: Peter Nicholls/Reuters

Three minutes and 47 seconds is a long time in football. An awful lot can happen. Twenty years ago in the Nou Camp it was long enough to enable Manchester United to recover from a position of defeat at the end of 90 minutes against Bayern Munich and, with the German club’s ribbons already on the trophy, to use added time first to draw level and then to win the Champions League final. Those three minutes contained as much drama and emotion as some entire seasons.

At Tottenham Hotspur’s new stadium on Saturday three minutes and 47 seconds was the length of time in which no football took place at all. On the hour, two minutes after Son Heung-min had put the home side ahead, Sheffield United celebrated an equaliser when David McGoldrick applied the finish to Enda Stevens’ cross from the left. But then the referee, Graham Scott, passed the decision over to the VAR room at Stockley Park. Twenty-two players stood around waiting as, 20 miles away in west London, it took almost four minutes of deliberation to conclude that John Lundstram had been offside by the length of his big toe when he received the ball on the right wing before sending in a cross that was half-cleared to John Fleck, who fed the ball to Stevens before it was turned across to McGoldrick.

Several objections were raised against the decision. First, if Lundstram was offside, it was immaterial because so much else had taken place before the move reached its conclusion. That’s hard to defend because his part in the action was intrinsic to its outcome. Second, it was a marginal decision made by a system whose terms of reference are supposedly confined to identifying “clear and obvious” errors by the officials on the pitch. That one holds a little more water. Third, how can we be sure the VAR technology is capable of operating to such fine margins? Answer: we can’t, and decisions as close as this will continue to be subject to the officials’ interpretation.

And so Lundstram’s big toe takes its place alongside Roberto Firmino’s armpit, the piece of the Brazilian’s anatomy judged offside a week earlier when he scored a disallowed equaliser against Aston Villa. Subsequent arguments concentrated on whether Tyrone Mings’ knee had played Firmino’s armpit onside. That is what we have come to.

At this point in the argument it is customary to try and disclaim Luddite tendencies. Not here, however. This column believes that an experienced rugby referee’s intuitive judgment on whether a touchdown has been made amid a pile of bodies will almost always be more reliable than the examination of seven different angles provided by slo-mo TV cameras while the players stand around getting cold. It believes that cricket’s ball-tracker is inherently suspect because it attempts to predict the behaviour of something whose unpredictability is one of the fundamental features of the game. It thinks that installing sensors to ensure that grand prix drivers stay within track limits is an insult to the memory of those whose limits were defined by brick walls.

Straightforward in/out decisions – adjudicated by HawkEye in tennis or football’s goal-line technology – are one thing. Any decision involving a judgment call is another matter altogether. And, as we are now painfully aware, some decisions in football will always be a matter of judgment rather than fact. Would Pep Guardiola have gone into such paroxysms of rage on Sunday had the referee on the pitch been the sole arbiter of the double handball incident that directly preceded Liverpool’s opening goal at Anfield on Sunday? The implication that VAR has made adjudication infallible might just be exacerbating anger at justice supposedly denied.

Human fallibility is removed from sport only at the risk of destroying the precious flow and expression of spontaneous emotion that makes it different from, say, the opera. The remoteness of the VAR decision-making process is in itself an alienating factor; it might be mitigated by greater use of a pitchside screen, but to have the referee dashing back and forth is simply another form of interruption.

VAR is like Brexit. Whatever sensible arguments are to be made in good faith on either side they are swamped by the damage it has caused, by the expense and the bother and the division it has created, as well as by the lurking suspicion that its existence serves somebody else’s interests, in this case the people who supply the technology and the broadcasters who welcome another source of debate for their celebrity pundits.

So here is a constructive suggestion. Wait until Boxing Day, when half the Premier League season will be over, and press pause on VAR. Run the remaining 19 games without it. Monitor them very carefully. See how many marginal decisions are made and examine the outcomes and the reaction. Then compare them with a very careful analysis of the first half of the season.

The comparison cannot be exact but it might tell us something. More importantly, perhaps, it might give spectators as well as players a chance to think about what kind of football they want to see.

Perhaps the result will be a discovery that people preferred the old, pre-VAR atmosphere of hurling vain abuse at allegedly blind refs to the new world of having to wait to unleash their joy in a process of gaudium reservatum. Or maybe it will become obvious that the technology is, in fact, getting nearer to the point where it can clear away all doubts over potentially contentious decisions and thereby make the game a better, more contemporary spectacle. Either way, given the state we’re in, it’s got to be worth a try.

The Guardian Sport



Owono Does Not Deserve 12-Match Ban Over De Miguel Death, Says Andorra Owner Pique

Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
TT

Owono Does Not Deserve 12-Match Ban Over De Miguel Death, Says Andorra Owner Pique

Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
Equatorial Guinea's goalkeeper #01 Jesus Owono leaves the pitch at half time during the Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) Group E football match between Equatorial Guinea and Algeria at Moulay Hassan Stadium in Rabat on December 31, 2025. (AFP)

FC Andorra owner Gerard ‌Pique said goalkeeper Jesus Owono did not deserve the 12-match suspension he received following the challenge that led to the death of Tenerife forward Jesus de Miguel.

Owono and De Miguel collided during a Spanish second-tier match on November 2. De Miguel was taken to intensive care and died the following day.

The disciplinary committee of the Spanish football federation (RFEF) banned Owono for violent conduct which resulted in serious ‌injury last week.

"Players, ‌former players, coaches, goalkeepers, everyone has ‌called ⁠it an accident," ⁠Pique said in a video posted on social media late on Monday.

"I truly believe that imposing the maximum sanction on Jesus for this action puts him in a situation he does not deserve, because he is not to blame for all of ⁠this having happened."

Former Barcelona player Pique ‌pointed to the three-match ‌ban handed to Albacete's Jose Corpas for accidentally kicking Sabadell ‌player Quadri Liameed in the head during a ‌recent match in Spain.

"Fortunately Quadri is fine, the consequences in this case were not fatal, and the committee decided to sanction Corpas with three matches," Pique added.

"With ‌all this, my reflection is: what is being sanctioned, the action or the ⁠consequences?"

The RFEF ⁠did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside regular business hours in Spain.

Owono, 25, has withdrawn from Equatorial Guinea's squad for Africa Cup of Nations qualifiers against Zimbabwe this month and Pique said it was unlikely the goalkeeper would return to action as soon as his suspension is up.

"Jesus is going to need far more than 12 matches before he is available and able to compete," he added. "No sanction is going to bring Demi (De Miguel) back to us."


Alcaraz Says Experience Helped Him Crack Indoor Code after Back-to-back Title Wins

Tennis - ATP Finals - Palasport Olimpico, Turin, Italy - November 16, 2026  Spain's Carlos Alcaraz in action during his group stage match against Francis Tiafoe of the US. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane
Tennis - ATP Finals - Palasport Olimpico, Turin, Italy - November 16, 2026 Spain's Carlos Alcaraz in action during his group stage match against Francis Tiafoe of the US. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane
TT

Alcaraz Says Experience Helped Him Crack Indoor Code after Back-to-back Title Wins

Tennis - ATP Finals - Palasport Olimpico, Turin, Italy - November 16, 2026  Spain's Carlos Alcaraz in action during his group stage match against Francis Tiafoe of the US. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane
Tennis - ATP Finals - Palasport Olimpico, Turin, Italy - November 16, 2026 Spain's Carlos Alcaraz in action during his group stage match against Francis Tiafoe of the US. REUTERS/Guglielmo Mangiapane

Carlos Alcaraz said experience has finally taught him how to get the best out of his game on indoor courts, with the world number three carrying his title-winning form from Vienna and Paris into this week's ATP Finals in Turin.

Only three of his 29 career titles have come on indoor hard courts, with his first coming in Rotterdam last year.

The 23-year-old has enjoyed a strong run of form since ⁠returning to the ⁠tour in August after nearly five months out with a right wrist injury.

His 6-2 6-2 win over Frances Tiafoe in his opening match at the ATP Finals on Monday showed he could be a real force at ⁠the season finale.

"I've always said that I'm not bad on indoor courts," the seven-times Grand Slam champion told reporters. "I just feel like others are a little bit better than me.

"It was about time, it was about getting more experience and it was about understanding how I should play on indoor courts,” Reuters quoted him as saying.

The faster conditions can mean Alcaraz has less time to ⁠impose ⁠his game, but he said he was confident of going toe-to-toe with the big servers and flatter hitters.

Tiafoe was in no doubt about Alcaraz's current level.

"He has moments where he's definitely Superman and he's playing pretty insane," Tiafoe said.

"But again, it's one of those things, you've got to appreciate greatness."

Alcaraz continues his campaign for a first ATP Finals crown when he takes on former champion Daniil Medvedev on Wednesday.


Goalkeeper Martinez Set for Argentina Return After Jaw Injury

Football - International Friendly - Argentina v Uruguay - Estadio La Bombonera, Buenos Aires, Argentina - November 13, 2026 Argentina's Emiliano Martinez during the warm up before the match. (Reuters)
Football - International Friendly - Argentina v Uruguay - Estadio La Bombonera, Buenos Aires, Argentina - November 13, 2026 Argentina's Emiliano Martinez during the warm up before the match. (Reuters)
TT

Goalkeeper Martinez Set for Argentina Return After Jaw Injury

Football - International Friendly - Argentina v Uruguay - Estadio La Bombonera, Buenos Aires, Argentina - November 13, 2026 Argentina's Emiliano Martinez during the warm up before the match. (Reuters)
Football - International Friendly - Argentina v Uruguay - Estadio La Bombonera, Buenos Aires, Argentina - November 13, 2026 Argentina's Emiliano Martinez during the warm up before the match. (Reuters)

Argentina ‌coach Lionel Scaloni said goalkeeper Emiliano Martinez will feature in Tuesday's friendly against Costa Rica after he recovered from a jaw fracture.

Martinez underwent surgery after colliding with Everton defender Jarrad Branthwaite in ‌Chelsea's 2-0 ‌victory last month.

He returned ⁠to Chelsea training ⁠earlier this month and was called up by Scaloni despite not having played for the Premier League club since ⁠the Everton game.

Martinez, ‌34, ‌did not feature in Argentina's 2-1 ‌loss to Uruguay on ‌Friday.

"Emiliano is going to play in goal, he'll be there," Scaloni told reporters on ‌Monday, ahead of the friendly match in Cordoba.

"Maybe ⁠he ⁠was fit for the previous match, but it was a risk, and since we trust Gero (Geronimo Rulli), Juan (Musso) and Santi (Santiago Beltran), we chose to look after him. An extra three days was a prudent choice."