UN Experts Say Arrest of Belgian Citizen in Iran Violates Int’l Law

An undated photograph made available by the family of Bernard Phelan on January 18, 2023, shows French-Irish citizen Bernard Phelan in an undisclosed location. (Photo by Handout / FAMILY HANDOUT / AFP)
An undated photograph made available by the family of Bernard Phelan on January 18, 2023, shows French-Irish citizen Bernard Phelan in an undisclosed location. (Photo by Handout / FAMILY HANDOUT / AFP)
TT

UN Experts Say Arrest of Belgian Citizen in Iran Violates Int’l Law

An undated photograph made available by the family of Bernard Phelan on January 18, 2023, shows French-Irish citizen Bernard Phelan in an undisclosed location. (Photo by Handout / FAMILY HANDOUT / AFP)
An undated photograph made available by the family of Bernard Phelan on January 18, 2023, shows French-Irish citizen Bernard Phelan in an undisclosed location. (Photo by Handout / FAMILY HANDOUT / AFP)

UN rights experts have condemned Iran’s “arbitrary” detention of Belgian aid worker Olivier Vandecasteele and demanded his immediate release.

“We believe Mr. Vandecasteele has been arbitrarily deprived of his liberty and is a victim of enforced disappearance for periods of detention,” the independent UN human rights experts said in a statement.

“His right to a fair trial before an independent and impartial tribunal has been violated. These are flagrant violations of Iran’s obligations under international law,” they said.

Vandecasteele, 40, was arrested on February 24, 2022.

In their statement, the UN experts declared that he had suffered ill-treatment in detention and that his health condition was critical.

Vandecasteele had been sentenced to 40 years of imprisonment and 74 lashes on charges of espionage against Iran, cooperating with the US, currency smuggling, and money laundering.

Under Iranian law, Vandecasteele is eligible for appeal after 12 years and six months.

“We are gravely concerned over the mental and physical health of Mr. Vandecasteele,” the experts said. “Mr. Vandecasteele requires special attention and medication.” 

Belgian-Iranian ties have been tense since the arrest of Iranian diplomat Asadollah Asadi who was sentenced to 20 years in prison in Belgium over plots to stage a “terrorist” attack against the Iranian opposition.

The statement urged Iran to release the many foreign and dual national citizens who remain arbitrarily detained in Iran and condemned the execution on January 14 of the British-Iranian, Alireza Akbari.

Moreover, France is extremely worried about the health of Bernard Phelan, a French-Irish citizen held in Iran since October 2022, who relatives say is on hunger strike, the foreign ministry said on Tuesday.

Local media reported that a German national was also arrested.

"He is showing serious signs of physical and psychological exhaustion," said a French diplomatic source, adding he was in a "critical state."

The Iranian authorities have so far refused to release Phelan on medical grounds despite repeated requests from the French and Irish authorities, the source said.

The French Foreign Ministry said Phelan was one of seven French nationals currently held arbitrarily by Iran, and Paris was “extremely worried about his health, which is poor and requires appropriate medical monitoring, which is not ensured in detention”.

Phelan’s sister, Caroline Masse-Phelan, told AFP her brother had started a dry hunger strike on Monday, refusing water, in addition to the food hunger strike he had been on since the start of the year.

“We are stepping up the pressure on Iran, in coordination with the Irish government, to ensure that our compatriot is released without delay,” the French foreign ministry said.

Tehran is accused of using western nationals to put pressure on the West.



Angry Macron Blasts Media over Reporting of Israel Comments

Emmanuel Macron lashed out at media, commentators and his own ministers - AFP
Emmanuel Macron lashed out at media, commentators and his own ministers - AFP
TT

Angry Macron Blasts Media over Reporting of Israel Comments

Emmanuel Macron lashed out at media, commentators and his own ministers - AFP
Emmanuel Macron lashed out at media, commentators and his own ministers - AFP

French President Emmanuel Macron on Friday faced accusations of seeking to reduce the media to merely reproducing press releases after blaming journalists, ministers and commentators for the furore over comments attributed to him on Israel.

A visibly furious Macron late Thursday began his press conference after an EU summit in Brussels with a tirade against those who he accused of distorting remarks made in a closed-door cabinet meeting and showing a "lack of professionalism" in their work.

The remarks attributed to Macron that Israel needed to adhere to UN resolutions in its campaigns in Lebanon and Gaza as the state was created by the world body angered Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu but also sparked strong reactions in France.

"Mr Netanyahu must not forget that his country was created by a decision of the UN," Macron told ministers, referring to the resolution adopted in November 1947 by the United Nations General Assembly on the plan to partition Palestine into a Jewish state and an Arab state, AFP reported.

Netanyahu accused Macron of a "distressing distortion of history" and "disrespect". In France, the speaker of the upper house Senate, Gerard Larcher, said he was "astounded" by the remarks and accused the president of showing his "ignorance" of history.

"I would like you to allow me to recall a few rules," Macron solemnly told reporters at the start of his news conference on Thursday.

"I must tell you how astonished I was to read so many comments, comments on comments, reactions, including from political leaders, foreign or French, to remarks that I made without seeking to know what exactly I said."

Macron attacked "ministers", "journalists" and "commentators" for the ensuing controversy, denying his remarks "as they were reported", arguing his words were taken out of context.

"I believe I say enough about the situation in the Middle East not to need a ventriloquist," he added.

- 'Checks sources rigorously' -

He called on ministers to "show respect for the rules and functions so as not to circulate false information" and on journalists "to treat the remarks reported with the necessary precautions".

After come critics in France questioned whether Macron had been casting doubt on Israel's right to exist, the president said that "there is no ambiguity" in the position of France.

But the Association of the Presidential Press (APP), which groups together reporters covering the head of state, said Macron had "seriously questioned the ethics of the press, which investigates and cross-checks its sources rigorously."

"Our work cannot be limited to repeating official statements. The definition of journalism cannot be a presidential prerogative," it said.

With heavy sarcasm, Greens MP Benjamin Lucas said on X: "That's right, journalists, why don't you simply and blindly reproduce the official press releases? Why bother searching, by cross-checking sources, to seek the truth?"

But after a controversy that has dogged Macron all week some supporters applauded his reactions.

Foreign policy is one of the few areas where the president retains leeway after the inconclusive outcome to summer legislative elections and appointment of a right-wing government left the centrist looking increasingly isolated.

"The voice of France in the world deserves better than the distortion of the truth. Those who engage in this are playing a very dangerous game for the country," said pro-Macron MP Mathieu Lefevre.