As Solskjær Soars, How Many Extra Points Does a Manager Really Add?

 Disentangling the skill of Ole Gunnar Solskjær from the quality of players at his disposal is tricky. Photograph: Matthew Ashton - AMA/Getty Images
Disentangling the skill of Ole Gunnar Solskjær from the quality of players at his disposal is tricky. Photograph: Matthew Ashton - AMA/Getty Images
TT

As Solskjær Soars, How Many Extra Points Does a Manager Really Add?

 Disentangling the skill of Ole Gunnar Solskjær from the quality of players at his disposal is tricky. Photograph: Matthew Ashton - AMA/Getty Images
Disentangling the skill of Ole Gunnar Solskjær from the quality of players at his disposal is tricky. Photograph: Matthew Ashton - AMA/Getty Images

Just how exceptional a manager is Ole Gunnar Solskjær? For all the praise lavished on the likeable Norwegian, I remain glued to the fence. Don’t get me wrong. He’s clearly doing well. It’s just that it is fiendishly tricky to separate the upturn in Manchester United’s mood and form since he took over – as reflected by that spectacular feat of alchemy in Paris – with the obvious fact that any club with that much money and world-class players should be winning most of their matches.

Throw into the mix the astringency of José Mourinho’s last few months at Old Trafford, the effect of the new manager bounce and Solskjær’s previous record at Cardiff, and we are all playing guessing games about how good the Norwegian might be. Disentangling the skill of a manager – his special sauce, so to speak – from the quality of the players at his disposal and the club’s budget isn’t easy. After all, no one believes Roberto Di Matteo is a great coach, even though he led Chelsea to the 2012 Champions League after riding the sort of luck rarely seen outside a Euromillions jackpot winner. Avram Grant was also just a fluffed John Terry spot-kick away from conquering Europe in 2008.

However, a team of German academics believe they have found a way to separate the impact of a manager from the team effect after forensically examining every coach’s reign in Bundesliga from 1993-1994 to 2013-14. Their paper, published in the Journal of Sports Economics last August, looked at 6,426 matches, every club’s budget per season and even every coach’s playing career, and some of their findings were unsurprising. Representing the national team as a player, for instance, did not make someone a better manager. Similarly, there was no evidence that playing in any one position as a player made them a better coach later in life. But by paying particular attention to how the same managers performed at different clubs – and by applying similar statistical wizardry used to assess how much difference bosses make to productivity in the US – they made two intriguing findings.

First, that the top 20% of managers over the 21-year period – which included Jürgen Klopp and Lucien Favre – improved a team by around 0.3 points a game on average over someone ranked in the bottom 20%, even after taking team strength and budget into account. That is 10.2 points on average over a 34-game Bundesliga season. Second, that measure of ability had a substantial predictive power for future performance of the teams employing the respective manager.

Advertisement

The research, incidentally, appears to back up what I and others have written before about managerial talent. In essence it is like a U-curve, with the best and worst coaches having a bigger impact on results – and those in the middle tier relying on the quality of their players, their club’s recruitment strategy and luck to succeed or fail. And, of course, relative success is only one measure a club should look at when bringing in a new manager. Their personality, how they develop and improve young players, and their style of play are all essential too.

Incidentally, the academics found something else that teams might bear in mind. Bundesliga sides whose managers were former professional players who had played in the top two tiers of German football tended to perform worse, on average, than managers who had either not played professionally at all or played no higher than the third tier. One explanation, according to Dr Gerd Muehlheusser of the University of Hamburg, is that managers who have not been former star players themselves need to be substantially better coaches in order to secure a job as a head coach in the top leagues. “In other words, they must start their managerial career in low divisions and hence have already proven to possess some managerial quality beforehand,” he says.

Maybe that shouldn’t surprise us. After all, Arrigo Sacchi was an amateur player and shoe salesman before revolutionising football at Milan, while Mourinho, Gérard Houllier and Brendan Rodgers are among many successful coaches who never played the game professionally. Still, as Omar Chaudhuri, the head of football intelligence at football consultancy 21st Club, points out it might mean that football undervalues coaches who have not played the game professionally.

“It’s not possible to know, unfortunately, if there was the same number of non and ex-pros, whether the non-ex-pros would be better on average,” says Chaudhuri, who works with several top clubs. “Still, the main thing it suggests is that potentially non-ex-pros are less of a risk than perceived by the market. The question is whether a club can use that – if non-ex-pros still have to ‘prove’ themselves, you potentially don’t know if they’re any good until they’ve proved themselves.”

Interestingly, it is a different story in the NBA, where top players tend to do better as coaches than non-players. That is probably because those players do not usually get head coach positions right away. Instead they have to prove their talent first. Maybe there is a lesson there for football clubs as well as former players.

In the meantime, 36 managers have now left their jobs in English football this season. Incredibly, 20 of those appointments lasted less than a year, including Solskjær’s old teammate Paul Scholes at Oldham, and it suggests that large parts of the game still have a problem evaluating what a good manager looks like.

The Guardian Sport



‘Not Competitive’ Brazil Can Improve, Insists Ancelotti

Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
TT

‘Not Competitive’ Brazil Can Improve, Insists Ancelotti

Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)
Brazil's head coach Carlo Ancelotti looks on before the Mizuho Blue Challenge – The Kallang Football Series international friendly match between Japan and Brazil at the National Stadium in Singapore, 14 November 2026. (EPA)

Brazil coach Carlo Ancelotti on Monday promised an improved performance in the year-ending clash against Singapore, admitting that his squad was "currently not competitive."

The Selecao lost 3-2 against Japan in a friendly in Singapore on Saturday, where Ancelotti and skipper Raphinha were red-carded after Japan scored the dramatic clincher in stoppage time.

"Given that the team is currently not competitive, I want to do more," Ancelotti told reporters in Singapore, where Brazil play on Tuesday.

The Italian, Brazil's first-ever permanent foreign coach, said: "I want to do more because I enjoy being here, so that the team can become more competitive on the global stage.

"The priority is to play well first (tomorrow) and to do well."

Ancelotti, 67, is coming under increasing pressure, following a string of underwhelming performances including two defeats, two wins and a draw in Brazil's last five international outings.

Japan avenged a 2-1 defeat by Brazil in their previous meeting at this year's World Cup, when the South Americans beat them in a round-of-32 clash.

After Saturday's loss, Ancelotti faced a barrage of criticism, including from former Brazilian national team star Romario.

Ancelotti brushed off Romario's remarks, saying "like anyone he has the right to express an opinion."

But the former Real Madrid coach, who reacted with fury after Brazil appealed for a foul in the build-up to Japan's winning goal on Saturday -- which was upheld by VAR -- said that his team "didn't deserve to lose" against Japan.

Japan face Paraguay on Tuesday in the second match of the double-header at Singapore's National Stadium.


Vinicius Says Less Training and Transfer Distractions May Explain Dip in Form

 Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
TT

Vinicius Says Less Training and Transfer Distractions May Explain Dip in Form

 Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)
Brazil's Vinicius Junior celebrates after goal during a friendly soccer match between Japan and Brazil in Singapore, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026. (AP)

Real Madrid winger Vinicius Junior says ‌his reduced training schedule, and transfer interest, may have affected his performances in an underwhelming start to his Real Madrid season.

The Brazilian signed a new contract until 2032 in August, but so far his output on the pitch has fallen short of his own previous standards. Press scrutiny in Spain has been intensified by the impressive start of Ivorian signing Yan Diomande, who has eclipsed Vinicius in his preferred left-sided role.

“I don’t think I prepared as well as I could have after the World Cup, because ‌the impact of ‌that tournament is so significant for all ‌Brazilians," ⁠he told a ⁠press conference in Singapore on Monday.

"Being knocked out so early was something we hadn’t expected. So, I took advantage of my holidays to enjoy myself, rest, relax, and spend more time with my family. I ended up training less than in previous years," he said.

“That may have affected my start to the season."

Vinicius' future ⁠at Real Madrid was a talking point in ‌Spain for months as he entered ‌the final year of his contract before re-signing in August. Premier ‌League champions Arsenal were said to be interested at the ‌time.

"On top of that, regarding my contract renewal, with so many clubs showing interest last summer, I felt truly overwhelmed, as with the situation at Real Madrid. But it’s a very long season.”

The 26-year-old said he ‌had a track record of hitting top form in the decisive moments of the season, ⁠and that he ⁠was on a positive trajectory.

“Maintaining such a high level for so long is always very difficult," said Vinicius.

"I think only Cristiano Ronaldo and (Lionel) Messi have managed to do this for so many years, reaching the same kinds of numbers."

"I am human, I often make mistakes, but I always try to improve.”

This season Vinicius has scored one goal and given three assists in his 12 Real Madrid appearances. Coach Jose Mourinho has only used him for a full 90 minutes on three occasions.

Nevertheless, he did score twice on Saturday in Brazil's 3-2 loss to Japan, and is likely to feature in another friendly against Singapore on Tuesday.


Belgium’s Lukaku Retires from International Football

Belgium's forward #09 Romelu Lukaku celebrates after scoring his team third goal during the UEFA Nations League, League A - Group 1, football match between Belgium and Turkey at the Maurice Dufrasne stadium, in Liege, eastern Belgium on October 2, 2026. (AFP)
Belgium's forward #09 Romelu Lukaku celebrates after scoring his team third goal during the UEFA Nations League, League A - Group 1, football match between Belgium and Turkey at the Maurice Dufrasne stadium, in Liege, eastern Belgium on October 2, 2026. (AFP)
TT

Belgium’s Lukaku Retires from International Football

Belgium's forward #09 Romelu Lukaku celebrates after scoring his team third goal during the UEFA Nations League, League A - Group 1, football match between Belgium and Turkey at the Maurice Dufrasne stadium, in Liege, eastern Belgium on October 2, 2026. (AFP)
Belgium's forward #09 Romelu Lukaku celebrates after scoring his team third goal during the UEFA Nations League, League A - Group 1, football match between Belgium and Turkey at the Maurice Dufrasne stadium, in Liege, eastern Belgium on October 2, 2026. (AFP)

Belgium forward Romelu Lukaku on Monday retired from international football after scoring 94 goals in 135 games for his country, saying he was "at peace" with his decision.

Lukaku featured in four World Cups for the Red Devils and helped them reach the quarter-finals of this year's tournament before losing to eventual winners Spain.

The 33-year-old, who now plays for Turkish club Fenerbahce, made his debut in 2010 as a teenager and was an unused substitute in Sunday's 4-1 Nations League win over Italy.

"These 16 years I gave all I had for the national team. It was a nice ride and I enjoyed every single moment," Belgium's record goal scorer said on Instagram.

"To the Belgium fans, thank you for the support you gave our team. I am proud to have represented my country in 4 World Cups and 3 European Championships.

"I will never forget those moments. I'm at peace with my decision to stop here," Lukaku said.

The former Chelsea, Manchester United and Inter Milan forward was part of Belgium's so-called "golden generation".

Lukaku, alongside Kevin De Bruyne, Thibaut Courtois and Eden Hazard, finished third at the 2018 World Cup, a best-ever finish for Belgium in the tournament but they failed to lift a trophy during the period.

"I played with amazing teammates that I will always be grateful for," Lukaku said.

"I want to thank them all. I want to thank all the coaches as well for pushing and trusting me to help the team," he added.

- 'Legend, my brother' -

A host of fellow Belgian players paid tribute to Lukaku.

"Legend, my brother," midfielder Axel Witsel said on Instagram.

"Thank you for everything my bro," Courtois said.

"So many amazing memories," the Real Madrid goalkeeper added.

Lukaku's last appearance for his country came in October's 4-1 loss to France.

"Beyond his exceptional performances on the pitch, he has been a true leader, with a strong personality and an essential role in the dressing room," Lukaku's former team-mate and now Belgium's technical director Simon Mignolet said in a statement from the Belgian football association.

"We respect his decision and are deeply grateful to him for everything he has brought to our national team," the former Liverpool goalkeeper added.

Belgium's first game without Lukaku will be a Nations League last-eight fixture in March.

"We must now turn our attention to the future and prepare for the Nations League quarter-finals," Mignolet said.

"With the ambition of continuing to make progress as a team," he added.