The prospect of autonomy in eastern Libya has returned to the political forefront after the government appointed by the House of Representatives threatened to assert financial and administrative independence.
The move has revived questions about whether such an arrangement is feasible and what it could mean for the unity of state institutions and the management of resources and powers in a country divided for years.
The debate has widened among Libyan politicians, tribal leaders and activists since Benghazi-based Prime Minister Osama Hammad raised the possibility on Monday of allowing his government to independently manage resources and public facilities within the territory under its authority.
Hammad’s warning came in response to the Government of National Unity, headed by Prime Minister Abdul Hamid Dbeibeh, preventing a House of Representatives session from taking place in the western city of Zintan.
The incident renewed disputes over the powers of Libya’s rival institutions and the geographic and administrative limits of their authority.
Supporters of autonomy argue that it would protect the interests of eastern and southern Libya and allow the regions to manage their resources without being held back by the dysfunction of central institutions.
Critics, however, warn that such a move could entrench the country’s divisions in the absence of national consensus and constitutional guarantees governing the distribution of power and wealth.
The Federal System
Political analyst Abdullah al-Dibani believes Hammad’s government has the legal and executive means to pursue financial and administrative independence, or autonomy, as a way to protect citizens’ interests and ensure continued development.
Al-Dibani told Asharq Al-Awsat that the move draws its legitimacy from the government’s appointment by the elected House of Representatives, as well as the security stability, reconstruction projects and infrastructure development achieved in eastern and southern Libya.
He described the proposed move as a response to political deadlock and the disruption of legislative activity, aimed at preventing political disputes from holding the country’s resources and citizens’ livelihoods hostage.
Independent management of resources, he argued, could help ensure a fairer distribution of wealth and the continued provision of public services.
The debate echoes longstanding calls by Libyan politicians for a federal or quasi-federal system that would grant the country’s three historic regions - Cyrenaica, Tripolitania and Fezzan - greater powers to manage their own affairs.
Yet the proposal appears to lack consensus even among those who regard federalism as a possible solution to Libya’s current crisis.
Abu Bakr al-Qatrani, a leading figure in Libya’s federalist movement, argues that federalism already exists in practice because of the division between rival governments in the east and west, but that it has neither been enshrined in the constitution nor established democratically.
Libya abolished its federal system in 1963 under Constitutional Amendment Law No. 1 of that year, which established a unitary state.
In a Facebook post, al-Qatrani warned that adopting federalism would not address the roots of the crisis as long as disputes persisted over ministries and sovereign institutions, which he described as the real focus of the struggle among Libyan factions.
Complexities and Obstacles
Questions about Libya’s political future intensified after a video circulated showing young Libyans at a heritage festival organized by the Libyan Heritage and Wildlife Authority in Benghazi on Tuesday.
During a traditional dance, participants chanted slogans calling for Saddam Haftar, deputy commander-in-chief of the eastern-based Libyan National Army, to be installed as president of Libya.
They also displayed a banner featuring his photograph in civilian clothing alongside the word “President.”
Others, however, consider autonomy unlikely at present.
Among them is Dr. Aref Teer, a professor of political science at the Libyan Academy for Postgraduate Studies, who argues that threatening to assert financial and administrative independence does not necessarily mean it can be implemented at this stage.
He cited political, economic and social complexities, as well as the need for constitutional and institutional arrangements that could take decades to establish.
“Libyan public opinion does not appear receptive to the idea of dividing the country or undermining its unity,” he said, pointing to the historical symbolism of King Idris al-Senussi, whose legacy is associated with Libya’s declaration of independence and the unification of its regions in 1951.
Speaking to Asharq Al-Awsat, Teer stressed that the interconnected nature of Libya’s sovereign financial and economic institutions, together with the overlap of resources and revenues among regions, posed obstacles to establishing an independent financial administration.
These factors also raised questions about the place of Fezzan and southern Libya in any future arrangements, he added.
On the international front, Teer considered it unlikely that neighboring countries or the broader international community, including the United States, Britain, Russia and China, would accept such a move at present.
He did not, however, rule out a change in circumstances over the longer term if divisions persisted and efforts to reach a comprehensive political settlement continued to falter, potentially prompting rival parties to explore alternative administrative arrangements.
Between these competing positions, Mohamed al-Mubasher, chairman of the Libyan Council of Elders for Reconciliation, advocates an approach centered on citizens’ rights and the fair distribution of wealth.
“Libya’s problem is not a problem of maps,” he said, arguing that people across the country’s cities and regions share similar needs, including salaries, medicine, education and employment opportunities.
Al-Mubasher acknowledged that demands for federalism had legitimate motivations, particularly feelings of marginalization and the accumulation of unfulfilled promises.
But he questioned the value of changing the structure of the state without fair institutions and effective mechanisms for oversight and accountability, warning that corruption and favoritism could simply be transferred to the regions.
Instead, he proposed empowering municipalities by granting them meaningful authority and independent budgets, alongside transparent rules for distributing revenues.
He pointed to the interconnected nature of Libya’s economy, banking system, currency, oil wealth and social ties across regions as foundations for preserving the country’s unity.