Israeli Defense Officials Cast Doubt on Threat to Attack Iran

An Israeli Boeing KC-135 Stratotanker and F-16 fighter jets performing over Jerusalem in April. Atef Safadi/EPA
An Israeli Boeing KC-135 Stratotanker and F-16 fighter jets performing over Jerusalem in April. Atef Safadi/EPA
TT

Israeli Defense Officials Cast Doubt on Threat to Attack Iran

An Israeli Boeing KC-135 Stratotanker and F-16 fighter jets performing over Jerusalem in April. Atef Safadi/EPA
An Israeli Boeing KC-135 Stratotanker and F-16 fighter jets performing over Jerusalem in April. Atef Safadi/EPA

With diplomatic efforts to curb Iran’s nuclear program teetering, Israel’s defense minister has ordered his forces to prepare a military option, warning the world that Israel would take matters into its own hands if a new nuclear agreement did not sufficiently constrain Iran.

But several current and former senior Israeli military officials and experts say that Israel lacks the ability to pull off an assault that could destroy, or even significantly delay, Iran’s nuclear program, at least not anytime soon. One current high-ranking security official said it would take at least two years to prepare an attack that could cause significant damage to Iran’s nuclear project.

A smaller-scale strike, damaging parts of the program without ending it entirely, would be feasible sooner, experts and officials say. But a wider effort to destroy the dozens of nuclear sites in distant parts of Iran — the kind of attack Israeli officials have threatened — would be beyond the current resources of the Israeli armed forces.

“It’s very difficult — I would say even impossible — to launch a campaign that would take care of all these sites,” said Relik Shafir, a retired Israeli Air Force general who was a pilot in a 1981 strike on an Iraqi nuclear facility.
“In the world we live in, the only air force that can maintain a campaign is the US Air Force,” he said.

The recent discussion of a military attack on Iran is part of an Israeli pressure campaign to make sure that the countries negotiating with Iran in Vienna do not agree to what Israeli officials consider “a bad deal,” one that in their view would not prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons.

At the moment, there appears to be little chance of that as the talks, aimed at resurrecting the 2015 nuclear agreement with Iran, have only regressed since Iran’s new hard-line government rejoined them last month.

Until now, Israel has tried to curb Iran’s nuclear program, which it considers an existential threat, through a combination of aggressive diplomacy and clandestine attacks. Israeli officials considered it a coup when they were able to persuade President Donald J. Trump to withdraw from the 2015 agreement, which President Biden now wants to salvage.

Israel has also waged a shadow war through espionage, targeted assassinations, sabotage and cyberattacks — smaller-scale operations that it has never formally claimed. Israel secretly considered mounting full-scale airstrikes in 2012 before abandoning the plan.

But as Iran’s nuclear enrichment program approaches weapons-grade levels, Israeli politicians have warned in increasingly open fashion what the world has long assumed: that Israel could turn to open warfare if Iran was allowed to make progress toward developing a nuclear weapon, a goal Iran denies.

In September, the head of the Israeli armed forces, Lt. Gen. Aviv Kochavi, said large parts of a military budget increase had been allocated to preparing a strike on Iran. Early this month, the Mossad chief, David Barnea, said Israel would do “whatever it takes” to stop Iran from making a nuclear bomb.

This month, during a visit to the United States, Defense Minister Benny Gantz publicly announced that he had ordered the Israeli Army to prepare for a possible military strike on Iran.
But Israeli experts and military officials say that Israel currently lacks the ability to deal Iran’s nuclear program a knockout blow by air.

Iran has dozens of nuclear sites, some deep underground that would be hard for Israeli bombs to quickly penetrate and destroy, Mr. Shafir said. The Israeli Air Force does not have warplanes large enough to carry the latest bunker-busting bombs, so the more protected sites would have to be struck repeatedly with less effective missiles, a process that might take days or even weeks, Mr. Shafir added.

One current senior security official said Israel did not currently have the ability to inflict any significant damage to the underground facilities at Natanz and Fordow.

Such an effort would be complicated by a shortage of refueling planes. The ability to refuel is crucial for a bomber that may have to travel more than 2,000 miles round trip, crossing over Arab countries that would not want to be a refueling stop for an Israeli strike.

Israel has ordered eight new KC-46 tankers from Boeing at a cost of $2.4 billion but the aircraft are back-ordered and Israel is unlikely to receive even one before late 2024.

Aside from the ability to hit the targets, Israel would have to simultaneously fend off Iranian fighter jets and air-defense systems.

Any attack on Iran would also likely set off retaliatory attacks from Hezbollah in Lebanon and Hamas in Gaza, allies of Iran that would try to force Israel to fight a war on several fronts simultaneously.

Iran’s defense capabilities are also much stronger than in 2012, when Israel last seriously considered attacking. Its nuclear sites are better fortified, and it has more surface-to-surface missiles that can be launched swiftly from tunnels.

“It is very possible that when the Israeli planes try to land back in Israel, they will find that the Iranian missiles destroyed their runways,” said Tal Inbar, an aviation expert and former head of the Fisher Institute for Air and Space Strategic Studies, an aviation-focused research group.

Other military experts, however, say that Israel could still take out the most important elements of the Iranian nuclear apparatus, even without newer aircraft and equipment.

“It’s always good to replace a car from 1960 with a brand-new car from 2022,” said Amos Yadlin, a former air force general who also participated in the 1981 strike. “But we have refueling capabilities. We have bunker busters. We have one of the best air forces in the world. We have very good intelligence on Iran. We can do it.

“Can the American Air Force can do it better? Definitely. They have a much more capable air force. But they don’t have the will.”

He cautioned that he would only support a strike as a last resort.

Israeli officials refuse to discuss the red lines Iran must cross to warrant a military strike. However, a senior defense official said that if Iran were to begin enriching uranium to 90 percent purity, weapons-grade fuel, Israel would be obliged to intensify its actions. American officials have said Iran is currently enriching uranium up to 60 percent purity.

The fact that it could take years to ramp up a program to carry out a massive air campaign against Iran should come as no surprise to Israeli military officials. When Israel considered such an attack in 2012, the preparations for it had taken more than three years, Israeli officials said.

But the distance between the current government’s threats and its ability to carry them out has provoked criticism of the former prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, who led Israel’s government until last June and was a dogged advocate for a harsher approach to Iran.

Since 2015, training for a strike on Iran had slowed, a senior Israeli military official said, as the defense establishment focused on confrontations with militias in Lebanon, Syria and Gaza.

In 2017, the Israeli Air Force determined it needed to replace its refueling planes, but Mr. Netanyahu’s government did not order them until last March.

And another senior military official said the army had asked Mr. Netanyahu since 2019 for extra funds to improve Israel’s ability to attack Iran, but was rebuffed.

In a statement, Mr. Netanyahu’s office said the opposite was true, that it was Mr. Netanyahu who pushed for more resources and energy on a strike on Iran while the military chiefs insisted on spending most of their budget on other issues and slowed down preparations to strike Iran.

“Were it not for the political, operational and budgetary actions led by Prime Minister Netanyahu over the past decade, Iran would have long had an arsenal of nuclear weapons,” the statement added.

Whether or not Mr. Netanyahu restricted the funding, experts have said that the money under discussion would not have significantly changed the army’s ability to attack Iran.

“You can always improve — buying more refueling airplanes, newer ones, bigger loads of fuel,” Mr. Shafir said. But even with these improvements and a superior air force, he said, Israeli airstrikes would not end Iran’s nuclear program.

They would likely, however, set the region on fire.

The New York Times



Trump Arrives in Manila for Quad Talks Ahead of China Visit

US President Donald Trump waves as he walks to board Air Force One at Joint Base Andrews, Maryland, on November 16, 2026. (AFP)
US President Donald Trump waves as he walks to board Air Force One at Joint Base Andrews, Maryland, on November 16, 2026. (AFP)
TT

Trump Arrives in Manila for Quad Talks Ahead of China Visit

US President Donald Trump waves as he walks to board Air Force One at Joint Base Andrews, Maryland, on November 16, 2026. (AFP)
US President Donald Trump waves as he walks to board Air Force One at Joint Base Andrews, Maryland, on November 16, 2026. (AFP)

US President Donald Trump arrived in the Philippines on Tuesday at the tail end of a Southeast Asian summit, with protests awaiting him as he prepares for the first meeting in two years of the Quad group of Indo-Pacific countries.

Trump's Asia trip, which includes the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum in Shenzhen and a much-anticipated trilateral meeting with his Chinese and Russian counterparts, comes after his Republican Party's defeat in midterm elections, plus spy allegations and new US curbs on China's access to AI chips that could complicate a fragile trade-war truce.

Demonstrators gathered in Manila for a fifth day of protests that have included the burning of Trump effigies, calls for an end to the Middle East war and scrapping of the US-led Pax Silica supply chain initiative.

Trump arrived late afternoon at the end of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations summit ‌and will join a ‌US-ASEAN "Special Summit" later on Tuesday.

He will first hold a meeting of the Quad – ‌the ⁠US, Japan, Australia and ⁠India – which will be his first and takes place two years after the last gathering of the group, which Trump's predecessor Joe Biden regarded as a signature foreign policy initiative.

It comes ahead of the APEC gathering hosted by Chinese President Xi Jinping, who has previously objected to the Quad as an effort to encircle Beijing. Quad members have said the grouping is not directed against any one country.

QUAD MEETING THE 'BEST POSSIBLE SIGNAL'

At the ASEAN summit on Monday, Chinese Premier Li Qiang hailed what he called "truly extraordinary" economic achievements of China and ASEAN in the face of global trade restrictions, expressing Beijing's commitment to free trade and the need to "stand united, ward off interference, and work together".

China ⁠is ASEAN's largest trading partner and a key source of investment, but the biggest economies ‌of the 11-member bloc – which has a combined GDP of more than $3.9 trillion – ‌want to deepen ties with the US despite protracted trade and diplomatic uncertainty under the Trump administration.

Former US Deputy Secretary of State Kurt ‌Campbell credited Washington's top diplomat, Marco Rubio, with the timing and reconvening of the Quad, which he said had lost ambition ‌under Trump.

"Part of what he (Rubio) is thinking is that this is probably the best possible signal if you're going to go into a trilateral meeting," said Campbell, co-founder of The Asia Group, referring to Thursday's US-China-Russia talks.

"The linchpin of everything that we do in Asia is the US-Japan relationship, and a perception that this is not at the top of the president's mind would concern me."

White House spokesperson Olivia Wales on Friday ‌said that under Trump's leadership, the Quad had demonstrated it is "a partnership of action, tackling the region's toughest challenges and driving opportunities to ensure a free and open Indo-Pacific".

A Japanese foreign ⁠ministry official said it was ⁠expected that Quad leaders would try to show unity, with maritime security, export restrictions, critical-minerals supply-chain diversification and AI among potential discussion points.

Undersea cables, emerging technology and disaster relief were also likely to be covered, a source familiar with the matter said.

JAPAN TO PLAY MORE PROACTIVE ROLE, PM SAYS

ASEAN's leaders held meetings on Tuesday involving counterparts of Japan, South Korea, China and India.

Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi pledged to work with ASEAN to boost regional economic and energy resilience to address export restrictions and vulnerabilities from rapid AI development, and strengthen supply chains, including on critical minerals.

"While the international order is experiencing a period of great instability, Japan will play an ever more proactive role," Takaichi said.

Trump will sign a joint statement with Thai Prime Minister Anutin Charnvirakul on Tuesday on an agreement on reciprocal trade. Thai media have reported the two would hold talks and the statement would be about progress on negotiations.

The US is Thailand's largest export market, accounting for 24% of its total shipments this year. The US designated Thailand as a major non-NATO ally in 2003.

Trump will on Wednesday meet Ferdinand Marcos Jr, president of US defense ally the Philippines, before heading to Shenzhen.


Pakistan Army Chief and Iran FM Discuss Regional Peace, Security

Vessels at the Strait of Hormuz, as seen from Musandam, Oman, November 17, 2026. (Reuters)
Vessels at the Strait of Hormuz, as seen from Musandam, Oman, November 17, 2026. (Reuters)
TT

Pakistan Army Chief and Iran FM Discuss Regional Peace, Security

Vessels at the Strait of Hormuz, as seen from Musandam, Oman, November 17, 2026. (Reuters)
Vessels at the Strait of Hormuz, as seen from Musandam, Oman, November 17, 2026. (Reuters)

Asim Munir, the powerful army chief of mediating country Pakistan, met with Iranian foreign minister Abbas Araghchi, the Pakistani military said Tuesday, during continued efforts to end the war between the United States and Iran.

Pakistan brokered a June accord that led to a brief halt in fighting between the United States and Iran and set a roadmap for further agreement on reopening the crucial Strait of Hormuz waterway and for negotiations on Tehran's nuclear program.

But the truce collapsed with Washington and Tehran accusing each other of violating the agreement and prompting months of shuttle diplomacy to resuscitate the ceasefire, led principally by mediators Qatar and Pakistan.

During the meeting on Monday, "matters of mutual interest, regional security dynamics and evolving geopolitical developments were discussed," the Pakistani military's media wing said in a statement.

Munir "underscored the importance of sustained engagement, mutual trust and close coordination between the two brotherly countries for promoting regional peace and stability", it added.

Araghchi arrived in Pakistan late on Sunday for a meeting of the Economic Cooperation Organization, a group of nations from Central and South Asia and the Middle East.

Pakistani Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar said on Monday he had held "very candid, very frank" discussions with Araghchi, during the conference confirming that Iran had put forward a two-day proposal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz as part of efforts to end the war with the United States.

He said Washington had not yet responded.

The United States and Israel launched the war on February 28, killing members of Iran's leadership and demanding it cease any nuclear-related activities.

The war plunged the Middle East into violence, with Tehran's retaliatory strikes targeting Gulf countries and sending global energy prices skyrocketing.

Tehran has insisted that Washington meet conditions including the release of frozen assets abroad, sanctions relief and an end to the US naval blockade of Iranian ports in exchange for reopening the Strait of Hormuz.


US Probes Why a Router Installation Sparked Mass Flight Grounding

A person takes a photo of a screen displaying information of delayed and cancelled flights at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport in Atlanta, Georgia, US, November 13, 2026. (Reuters)
A person takes a photo of a screen displaying information of delayed and cancelled flights at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport in Atlanta, Georgia, US, November 13, 2026. (Reuters)
TT

US Probes Why a Router Installation Sparked Mass Flight Grounding

A person takes a photo of a screen displaying information of delayed and cancelled flights at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport in Atlanta, Georgia, US, November 13, 2026. (Reuters)
A person takes a photo of a screen displaying information of delayed and cancelled flights at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport in Atlanta, Georgia, US, November 13, 2026. (Reuters)

US Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said on Monday it remains unclear why a router installed by L3Harris Technologies in a remote Arkansas facility triggered a nearly five-hour nationwide aviation ground stop on Friday.

Shares of L3Harris, the contractor for the Federal Aviation Administration, closed down 3.7% after the government blamed the mass flight shutdown on its router installation. Airlines canceled more than 18,000 flights as a result.

Shares of Hewlett Packard Enterprise, which owns Juniper Networks, the maker of the routers that L3Harris installed, dropped 4.5% on Monday.

L3Harris has said it is ‌cooperating with ‌the official investigation into what went wrong.

Duffy, speaking on CNBC, said the ‌installation ⁠at an FAA radio ⁠communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas, led to an overload of a key government communications system at a rate of 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds.

That destabilized aircraft communications and radar feeds, affecting 17 of 22 FAA en route air traffic control centers that were using old routers and prompting the ground stop, Duffy said. He added that he has urged Congress to fund the construction of a new telecom network that is not owned by L3Harris.

Duffy is set to brief US senators ⁠on the investigation on Tuesday.

The FAA had said on Sunday that the ‌initial investigation suggested the data overload could have happened in ‌two locations: the El Dorado site and a radar site in Amarillo, Texas. Duffy said L3Harris had replaced ‌the router in Amarillo three weeks earlier.

Duffy said testing of the two routers was taking ‌place at an L3Harris lab in Florida overseen by the FAA. He invited the FBI to attend the investigation to make sure the review is being done correctly.

The FAA said that after the data "inconsistencies" occurred, L3Harris ultimately blocked those two locations, stabilizing the network. The broadcasting function was also disabled on all the new routers as ‌well as 60 other routers in the system as a precaution, it added.

L3Harris had been installing Juniper Networks routers to replace Cisco routers, produced ⁠in 2001, which ⁠were supposed to have been replaced in 2006, the FAA said.

"Based on what we know and have been told by others, our equipment was working as configured," HPE said on Monday. "The FAA is assessing the configuration and performance of all infrastructure involved to determine the cause."

Duffy has asked for billions of dollars from Congress to build a new fiber network operated by AT&T, Verizon and Lumen to replace the old L3Harris-owned copper network.

"I have the architecture ready. These companies are ready to deploy tomorrow. All I need is the money to tell them to start," he said on NBC on Sunday. "I want to get away from L3Harris and get to a new one. But they own the network. So I can’t cancel the network that they own and I operate on."

The FAA said the Arkansas router replacement was part of the $1 billion a year it spends to maintain and sustain the existing 1980s telecom network, but not part of its broader modernization effort.