The death of Mohamed Osman al-Mirghani, who for decades led both Sudan’s Khatmiyya Sufi order and the Democratic Unionist Party, has opened the question of succession on two fronts.
Within the religious order, several senior representatives insist that his eldest son, Ali, has the first claim to its leadership. But the party presidency remains contested, with three of al-Mirghani’s sons competing for influence amid differences over the war and political alliances inside and outside Sudan.
Al-Mirghani succeeded his father, Ali al-Mirghani, as spiritual leader of the Khatmiyya order following his death in 1968, in a transition that proceeded smoothly and without major public dispute.
In 1982, following the death of party leader Sharif Hussein al-Hindi, he assumed the presidency of the Democratic Unionist Party, combining religious and political leadership until his death in Cairo on November 13.
A source told Asharq Al-Awsat that three of al-Mirghani’s sons — Abdullah al-Mahjoub, Mohamed al-Hassan and Jaafar al-Sadiq — were competing for leadership of the party and the religious order.
They draw support from different factions and groups inside Sudan and abroad, as well as from ties to regional actors that the source said were backing some of them.
According to the source, Abdullah al-Mahjoub enjoys the support of a regional state and Sovereignty Council Chairman Abdel Fattah al-Burhan.
Mohamed al-Hassan, meanwhile, is backed by another regional state and political forces opposed to the war, including parties that signed the Framework Agreement.
Jaafar al-Sadiq relies on forces within the Democratic Bloc alliance, which he chairs, despite having differed with some of the alliance’s positions in the past.
Eldest Son Has Priority
The source said Mohamed al-Hassan’s endorsement of his elder brother Ali as head of the Khatmiyya order had introduced a fourth name into the religious succession arrangements. Ali had remained outside the political disputes among his brothers.
Under longstanding traditions within the al-Mirghani family, the eldest son has priority in inheriting the sajjada, or spiritual leadership of the Khatmiyya order, unless he declines the position.
The party presidency, however, is governed by organizational and constitutional procedures whose interpretation has become a source of disagreement among party leaders.
The source said a group of senior representatives of the order was insisting that its leadership pass to Ali al-Mirghani as the late leader’s eldest son.
Following his father’s death, Mohamed al-Hassan publicly endorsed his elder brother’s succession as head of the Khatmiyya order.
He also signed a statement identifying himself as “President of the Democratic Unionist Party (Original),” having served as deputy party president during his father’s lifetime.
A source in the party’s organizational secretariat said Ali’s claim to the religious leadership rested on traditions dating back to the order’s founder, and that Mohamed al-Hassan’s endorsement amounted to recognition of that entitlement.
Under those traditions, family members, senior representatives of the order and its followers pledge allegiance to the eldest son, the source added.
Who Will Lead the Party?
Regarding the party presidency, the organizational secretariat source, in remarks carried by a Sudanese newspaper, said Mohamed al-Hassan was authorized to manage party affairs until its general congress convenes.
The source cited a decision issued by his father in 2013 dissolving the party’s organizational bodies and establishing an interim steering committee, chaired by Mohamed Osman al-Mirghani with Mohamed al-Hassan as his deputy, to prepare for the general congress.
Following the party president’s death, responsibility for continuing to manage party affairs and completing the establishment of its institutions and organizational structures falls to his deputy on the steering committee, the source explained.
In remarks made before al-Mirghani’s death and reported by Sudan Tribune, the party’s deputy organizational secretary, Osama Hassouna, said Mohamed al-Hassan derived his constitutional and organizational legitimacy from decisions issued by his father following the Reference Conference.
In contrast, Mohamed Syed Ahmed, an adviser to the party president known as “al-Jakoumi,” said the party presidency was not hereditary.
He argued that choosing al-Mirghani’s successor was a matter for consultation and the relevant party institutions.
Jaafar al-Sadiq al-Mirghani, deputy party president and chairman of the Democratic Bloc alliance, renewed his pledge to uphold his father’s approach and mission and preserve the family’s religious and national legacy in a farewell address.
He did not address arrangements for either the political or religious succession. Some analysts, however, interpreted his emphasis on preserving the family’s legacy as an indication of his position on the succession.
Unionist leader Moataz al-Fahl told Asharq Al-Awsat that the succession question had not yet been settled, as party and religious leaders and the late leader’s sons remained occupied with mourning ceremonies.
He said Jaafar al-Sadiq, Abdullah al-Mahjoub and Ahmed al-Mirghani had traveled to Sudan to attend the funeral and had not discussed succession arrangements.
“Sayyid Mohamed Osman was too important a figure for his succession to be settled so quickly,” he said.
Disputes Predate His Death
Organizational disputes between Mohamed al-Hassan and Jaafar al-Sadiq date back several years before their father’s death.
They became public in 2022, when the brothers adopted differing positions on party management and political alliances.
In November that year, al-Mirghani issued a video directive instructing Jaafar al-Sadiq to continue his duties as deputy party president and address what he described as organizational “breaches of discipline.”
Mohamed al-Hassan’s faction, however, maintained that the 2013 decisions establishing the steering committee remained the basis of its organizational legitimacy.
The disputes resurfaced in June 2025, when decisions issued in the party president’s name called for restructuring the executive bureau and appointing Ahmed Saad Omar as its head, replacing Jaafar al-Sadiq.
The decisions drew objections from some Unionist leaders, while others maintained that they were legitimate.
An Opportunity to Reunite the Unionists
Political analyst Mohamed Latif said separating the religious leadership of the Khatmiyya order from the political leadership of the party could open the way to reunifying Unionist factions.
Some factions had distanced themselves from the original party because of its association with religious authority.
Latif told Asharq Al-Awsat that Mohamed al-Hassan’s endorsement of his elder brother Ali as head of the Khatmiyya order, alongside his own declaration that he was assuming the party presidency, marked a shift in the historic relationship between the two leadership roles. Their father had held both positions for decades.
Latif argued that the development could give the Unionist movement an opportunity to restore its unity and political role in Sudan.
He also noted that the call for an end to the war, which featured prominently in Mohamed al-Hassan’s statement, could pave the way for closer ties with civilian forces supporting a democratic transition.
The source who described the rivalry among al-Mirghani’s sons, however, warned that an escalation of their disputes could cost the family its historic influence within the party and lead to its leadership passing outside the al-Mirghani family.
The source pointed out that the presidency of the Democratic Unionist Party had been separate from leadership of the Khatmiyya order before Mohamed Osman al-Mirghani combined the two positions.
Political figures from outside the family had previously led the party, notably Ismail al-Azhari and Sharif Hussein al-Hindi.
As succession arrangements unfold, the Unionist movement faces organizational divisions and disagreements over the war and political alliances.
The party’s various factions have yet to reach a consensus on a leadership arrangement following al-Mirghani’s death.