Between AlUla’s Rocks and Munich’s Halls: A Dialogue Reshaping Global Security

Gulf leaders at the Gulf Cooperation Council summit held in AlUla (SPA)
Gulf leaders at the Gulf Cooperation Council summit held in AlUla (SPA)
TT

Between AlUla’s Rocks and Munich’s Halls: A Dialogue Reshaping Global Security

Gulf leaders at the Gulf Cooperation Council summit held in AlUla (SPA)
Gulf leaders at the Gulf Cooperation Council summit held in AlUla (SPA)

In a move laden with symbolism, Saudi Arabia’s AlUla hosted the Munich Security Conference Leaders’ Meeting this year for the first time, shifting a gathering long tied to the Bavarian capital into the heart of the Arabian desert.

For decades, Munich was the annual stage where world leaders and policymakers debated the most pressing political and security challenges.

This year, around 100 senior officials and decision-makers convened in AlUla’s Maraya concert hall, a mirrored structure set among sandstone mountains, drawing a line of continuity between two distant yet resonant cities - Munich with its European legacy, and AlUla with its ancient Arab heritage.

Munich has long witnessed Europe’s political transformations and served as a cradle of culture, art and thought. AlUla, once a crossroads for civilizations from the Lihyanites to the Nabataeans, carries a record of human passage etched in rock inscriptions that still speak to visitors today.

Speaking to Asharq Al-Awsat, Benedikt Franke, the Vice-Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of the Munich Security Conference (MSC), said Saudi Arabia today is one of the biggest regional players, and it has become one of the most important actors in international diplomacy.

He highlighted the symbolism of AlUla’s Elephant Rock, which he said aligns with the conference’s theme of addressing the “elephant in the room.”

Franke praised Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s efforts to create stability so that the government can focus on long-term and sustainable prosperity.

The setting of AlUla stood in stark contrast to Munich’s Alpine greenery and rivers, but both landscapes offered a striking backdrop for dialogue between humanity, history and nature.

Abdulaziz Sager, chairman of the Gulf Research Center, called the MSC “one of the most important global security conferences,” drawing ministers of foreign affairs, defense and intelligence as well as experts from think tanks and academic centers.

He noted that while the MSC has been held annually in Munich since its founding in the 1960s as a transatlantic forum, it has also taken its debates abroad, most recently to the US.

“This year’s meeting in AlUla underscores Saudi Arabia’s political, security and international role, making it the key stop after the US for the conference of leaders,” Sager told Asharq Al-Awsat.

“The MSC has evolved into a laboratory for strategic decision-making in international politics,” Sager added. “Its convening in the kingdom is recognition of Saudi Arabia’s growing weight in global affairs.”

Munich earned its reputation as an unofficial capital for security debates by acting as a bridge between Europe and the US. AlUla, with its mix of archaeological depth and modern ambition, now seeks to play a similar role, bridging continents and cultures.

If Munich is famed for Oktoberfest, AlUla is carving its own profile through cultural festivals such as Winter at Tantora, alongside high-profile summits, including the 2021 Gulf Cooperation Council meeting that marked a turning point in regional diplomacy.

The relocation of the MSC gathering was more than a choice of venue; it was a message that Saudi Arabia, with its political and economic weight, is now an indispensable partner in shaping global security debates.

As Munich grew beyond its local boundaries to become a global stage for security, AlUla is stepping from its deep history into an international spotlight, where diplomacy, culture, and dialogue converge.



Sources to Asharq Al-Awsat: Hamas Held Secret Meeting with French Lawmakers, Diplomats

This photograph shows the Statue de la Reublique with the Palestinian flag in support of the Palestinians in Gaza, at Place de la Reublique in Paris on June 13, 2025. (AFP)
This photograph shows the Statue de la Reublique with the Palestinian flag in support of the Palestinians in Gaza, at Place de la Reublique in Paris on June 13, 2025. (AFP)
TT

Sources to Asharq Al-Awsat: Hamas Held Secret Meeting with French Lawmakers, Diplomats

This photograph shows the Statue de la Reublique with the Palestinian flag in support of the Palestinians in Gaza, at Place de la Reublique in Paris on June 13, 2025. (AFP)
This photograph shows the Statue de la Reublique with the Palestinian flag in support of the Palestinians in Gaza, at Place de la Reublique in Paris on June 13, 2025. (AFP)

Three Palestinian sources told Asharq Al-Awsat that senior leaders of Hamas’ political bureau recently held a highly confidential meeting with a French delegation that included current and former diplomats, as well as members of parliament from both parties within France’s governing coalition and the opposition.

Two of the sources — one affiliated with a Palestinian civil society organization involved in programs with France and other European countries, and another linked to a Palestinian faction close to Hamas — said the meeting took place “recently” in an unspecified country in the region. Both declined to identify the location but described the gathering as “extremely secret.”

According to the sources, several governments, Palestinian factions, and mediators involved in Gaza ceasefire efforts, including Egypt, Qatar, and Türkiye, were informed of the meeting shortly before or soon after it occurred. One source said Hamas informed a number of parties that the meeting was taking place, without disclosing details.

Two Hamas officials confirmed to Asharq Al-Awsat that the meeting had occurred but declined further comment.

The meeting is notable because it appears to be the first known encounter between European officials and Hamas leaders since the group’s October 7, 2023, attack on Israel.

Since then, Hamas representatives have met US officials and presidential envoys as part of ceasefire negotiations that resulted in the release of hostages held by the group. Those contacts were publicly praised at the time by President Donald Trump, despite Washington’s designation of Hamas as a terrorist organization since 1997.

France does not formally designate Hamas as a terrorist organization under its national legal framework, although French authorities prosecute individuals accused of financing the group. Following the October 7 attack, debate intensified in Paris over calls to formally classify Hamas as a terrorist organization.

The European Union has listed Hamas and its military wing, the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades, on its terrorist sanctions list since 2001. In May, the EU imposed additional sanctions on Hamas and the Palestinian Islamic Jihad movement.

The reported meeting also comes amid nearly two years of strained relations between Paris and Tel Aviv, as well as growing tensions between French President Emmanuel Macron and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu over Israel’s military campaigns in Gaza and Lebanon and its strikes in Syria.

After France recognized the State of Palestine, Netanyahu accused Macron in August of “fueling antisemitism,” prompting a sharp response from the Elysee Palace, which described the remarks as “base” and founded on falsehoods.

Pro-Palestinian demonstrators carry a huge Palestinian flag as they gather outside the Sorbonne University, where they tried to set up a protest camp before being evacuated by police in Paris, France, 29 April 2024. (EPA)

Issues discussed

A source from Palestinian civil society said the talks focused broadly on the Palestinian situation, including efforts to reorganize Palestinian internal affairs, improve national reconciliation, and advance a political process aimed at ending the conflict with Israel.

According to the source, discussions also touched on supporting Palestinians’ right to establish an independent state based on the June 4, 1967, borders.

France has been a leading advocate of the two-state solution and, alongside Saudi Arabia, has spearheaded international efforts that helped generate a wave of diplomatic recognition for a Palestinian state and broader support within the United Nations.

The disclosure of the meeting comes as Hamas is engaged in difficult negotiations over the future of its weapons arsenal.

The group has linked any discussion of disarmament to a clearly defined political process that guarantees Palestinian self-determination and the establishment of a sovereign state.

A history of contacts

The reported meeting is not unprecedented. In 2008, Hamas disclosed that it had held discussions with several European officials, including French representatives.

Then-French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner acknowledged such contacts but emphasized that France would not establish formal relations with Hamas unless it recognized Israel and renounced violence.

At the time, Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri said European interlocutors were seeking to understand the movement’s positions on political developments and the prospects for a Palestinian state.

Those contacts coincided with Hamas’ gradual adoption of a position accepting a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders as an interim solution, while stopping short of recognizing Israel and insisting on the right of return for Palestinian refugees and East Jerusalem as the capital of a future Palestinian state.

In 2009, then-Hamas political bureau chief Khaled Meshaal met two French lawmakers in Damascus.

A further shift came in 2017, when Hamas elected a new leadership headed by Ismail Haniyeh and revised its political document to accept a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders.

The movement also expanded outreach to Russia, Iran, Arab and Islamic countries, and European states, while expressing openness to dialogue with a broad range of international actors, including the United States.

More recently, Hamas has sought through international law firms and legal initiatives to challenge its designation as a terrorist organization in several European countries, particularly Britain.

Supporting those efforts was a document signed by Moussa Abu Marzouk, a member of Hamas’ political bureau and head of its international relations office, arguing that Hamas is a national liberation movement, not an antisemitic organization, and does not pose a threat to Western countries.


Lebanon's Berri to Asharq Al-Awsat: We Are in Constant Contact with Aoun, Salam Despite Difference in Ideas

01 October 2020, Lebanon, Beirut: Speaker of the Lebanese parliament Nabih Berri speaks during a press conference in Beirut. (Lebanese Parliament/dpa)
01 October 2020, Lebanon, Beirut: Speaker of the Lebanese parliament Nabih Berri speaks during a press conference in Beirut. (Lebanese Parliament/dpa)
TT

Lebanon's Berri to Asharq Al-Awsat: We Are in Constant Contact with Aoun, Salam Despite Difference in Ideas

01 October 2020, Lebanon, Beirut: Speaker of the Lebanese parliament Nabih Berri speaks during a press conference in Beirut. (Lebanese Parliament/dpa)
01 October 2020, Lebanon, Beirut: Speaker of the Lebanese parliament Nabih Berri speaks during a press conference in Beirut. (Lebanese Parliament/dpa)

Lebanese parliament Speaker Nabih Berri stressed on Sunday that he was in “constant” contact with President Joseph Aoun and Prime Minister Nawaf Salam “despite differences in ideas.”

In remarks to Asharq Al-Awsat, he said: “I don't think we have a problem as long as we are united in demanding that Israel first withdraw from the South and then that the army be deployed there and that the people are allowed to return to their homes.”

The demands also include the release of detainees held by Israel and coming up with a plan, with Arab and international backing, to rebuild what Israel destroyed during the war, he added.

Berri made his remarks on the eve of the launch of the fifth round of US-sponsored Lebanese-Israeli military and political negotiations.

The speaker expressed his “satisfaction” with the efforts that have led to a ceasefire in the fighting between Israel and Hezbollah. Berri is a close ally to the Iran-backed group.

He hoped the ceasefire will last, saying that that hinges on Israel respecting it, which will in turn lead Hezbollah to respect it as well “because it is unjust to negotiate under fire.”

Berri revealed that Israel had requested the ceasefire through the “mechanism” committee that is responsible for overseeing the implementation of the 2024 truce between Israel and Hezbollah.

He noted that Israel came under American pressure to agree to a ceasefire following “two bloody days in the South that claimed dozens of civilian lives.”

He stressed that Hezbollah is “committed to the ceasefire,” accusing Israel of violating it.

“We hope that the ceasefire, with US pressure, will stand. We welcome any effort to pressure Israel to cease its hostile war against Lebanon,” he continued.

Moreover, the speaker expressed his rejection of “pilot zones” in the South, saying that reaching an agreement over their geographic borders could take years.

Israel and Lebanon agreed to move quickly towards establishing “pilot zones” in which the Lebanese Armed Forces would exercise exclusive control “to the exclusion of all non-state actors”.

Berri said that Lebanon “has not interest in wasting time that would allow Israel to continue its hostile activities. The solution lies in adopting a timetable for its withdrawal from the entire South in exchange for the deployment of the Lebanese army.”

“This remains the shortest path towards the South’s liberation from occupation instead of remaining bogged down by talks over the ‘pilot zones’,” he added.


Syria President Denies Wanting to Intervene in Lebanon After Trump Remarks

Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa. (AFP file)
Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa. (AFP file)
TT

Syria President Denies Wanting to Intervene in Lebanon After Trump Remarks

Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa. (AFP file)
Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa. (AFP file)

Syrian President Ahmed al-Sharaa denied on Sunday that his country sought to intervene militarily in Lebanon where Israel and Hezbollah are at war, after US President Donald Trump repeatedly suggested Damascus could get involved.

"We are looking for economic channels between Lebanon and Syria, not military ones," Sharaa said in an interview broadcast on television channel Al Mashhad.

On Sunday, Trump told Fox News he was "disappointed Israel can't put Hezbollah away", adding in reference to the fight against the militant group: "I'm close to giving it over to Syria."

Hezbollah drew Lebanon into the Middle East war on March 2 with rocket fire at Israel to avenge the killing of its backer Iran's supreme leader in US-Israeli strikes days earlier.

Israel responded with airstrikes and a ground invasion.

An Iran-US deal signed this week on ending the regional conflict includes Lebanon, where fighting has paused since Saturday evening.

At the G7 summit in France this week, Trump also said "if Israel can't do the job (against Hezbollah) without killing everyone else, then he (Sharaa) will do the job. Syria will do the job."

- Syria 'greatly concerned' -

Sharaa said in Sunday's interview that "we proposed with the United States that the war must stop," adding that "there must be various solutions, including economic, political and social, and the re-establishment of relations and the vital economic lifeline between Syria and Lebanon."

"And alongside this, some security measures that respond firstly to Syrian and Lebanese concerns, and also Israeli concerns," he added.

Hezbollah fought alongside longtime Syrian ruler Bashar al-Assad in his country's civil war, making Sharaa and the new authorities who toppled the former leader in 2024 deeply hostile to the group.

Syria had dominated its neighbor for decades following its military intervention in Lebanon's 1975-1990 civil war, withdrawing only in 2005, making any new military involvement a fraught proposition.

Syria offers "many tools for having a positive impact within Lebanon, but this also depends primarily on Lebanon's agreement", Sharaa said.

"Syria is greatly concerned with Lebanon's domestic situation because Lebanon's security and stability are part of Syria's security and stability," he added.

Responding to a question about whether he would sit at the table with Hezbollah, Sharaa said that "if this serves Lebanon's interests and safeguards Syria's interests, why not?"

Earlier this month, Trump also told US broadcaster NBC that "I'd like to see a more surgical attack on Hezbollah... And we can help them with that, or we can recommend Syria," he said, adding that Sharaa "would love to help".