Let’s Rescue Book Lovers from this Online Hellscape

Janik Söllner
Janik Söllner
TT

Let’s Rescue Book Lovers from this Online Hellscape

Janik Söllner
Janik Söllner

By Maris Kreizman

New York - If you have not kept up with the latest scandal in the world of young adult publishing, it is a doozy. It involves a debut author with a lot of buzz, lies, clumsy alibis, “review bombing,” a long and sordid confession — and, of course, Goodreads. Because whenever there is a meltdown in publishing, Goodreads, the Amazon-owned site that bills itself as “the largest site for readers and book recommendations,” is reliably at the center of it.

You might wonder if Goodreads isn’t just an enabler of scandal but the problem itself.

But first, the scandal: Internet sleuths figured out that an author named Cait Corrain, whose debut novel was scheduled for 2024, had created fake accounts on Goodreads in order to review-bomb other books — overwhelming them with negative one-star reviews. When confronted online, she concocted a fake online chat to divert blame to a nonexistent friend; when that hoax was uncovered, she confessed, citing a “complete psychological breakdown.” Her publisher and her agent dropped her; the planned publication of her novel was canceled.

As often happens in these scandals, the use and abuse of Goodreads — a site whose cheery name masks a recent history of abhorrent user behavior — has left many people hurt and at least one person’s career in ruins.

Goodreads is broken. What began in 2007 as a promising tool for readers, authors, booksellers, and publishers has become an unreliable, unmanageable, nearly unnavigable morass of unreliable data and unfettered ill will. Of course, the internet offers no shortage of bad data and ill will, but at its inception Goodreads promised something different: a gathering space where ardent readers could connect with writers and with one another, swapping impressions and sharing recommendations. It’s an idea that’s both obvious and essential (reading is a solitary activity, but there is great joy in talking through a book afterward). In fact, Goodreads is still an essential idea — so much so that it’s worth fighting to fix it.

When I joined the site in 2007, I felt I had finally found my place online. At the time, I was still using a physical notebook to keep a list of the books I’d read or wanted to read, so discovering a place to track, rate, and review books felt entirely novel. After Amazon’s acquisition of it in 2013, Goodreads seemed primed to either sink or soar. While Amazon had won few fans in the book community, thanks to its predatory business practices, it is also the foremost online marketplace for books, and so a companion site dedicated to discussing books seemed an obvious and potentially beneficial complement.

But Goodreads quickly began to languish in an awkward limbo — neither a retailer nor an inviting online salon. Still, it’s become the most popular book discussion site, by far, with a reported 125 million members as of late 2022. As book coverage and criticism have been slashed in other areas of popular media, Goodreads, by default, has taken on an outsize role in the book world’s imagination. But it’s also devolved into a place where users’ worst instincts are indulged or even encouraged.

Whether it’s the rampant practice of review-bombing books that are listed online long before publication (often targeting young adult novels that have acquired a whiff of offensiveness, some of which are ultimately pulled from publication) or the internet hecklers hounding beleaguered authors.

The combative culture of Goodreads is antithetical to the spirit in which it was started. My as-yet-unpublished memoir in essays already has two ratings on Goodreads, but it won’t even go out to early readers until next year. It’s become routine for publishers to warn authors that Goodreads is a site meant for readers, not for writers — which is to say, what was intended to be a forum for engagement is now a place authors enter at their peril.

In an ideal world — one in which it wasn’t owned by Amazon — Goodreads would have the functionality of a site like Letterboxd, a social network for movie fans.

Letterboxd has called itself “Goodreads for movies,” but it has far surpassed that initial tag line, having figured out how to create a smooth and intuitive user experience, provide a pleasant and inviting community and earn revenue from both optional paid memberships and advertisers, including studios that produce the films being discussed. Meanwhile, publishers still rely on Goodreads to find potential readers, but targeted advertising has grown both less affordable and less effective.

So how to fix it? It starts with people: Goodreads desperately needs more human moderation to monitor the goings-on. Obviously, part of any healthy discussion is the ability to express displeasure — those one-star reviews, ideally accompanied by well-argued rationales, are sacrosanct — but Goodreads has enabled the weaponization of displeasure.

It’s not just fledgling authors being pummeled. This year, Elizabeth Gilbert, the best-selling author of “Eat, Pray, Love,” decided to withdraw a forthcoming novel, “The Snow Forest,” after Goodreads users bombarded its page with one-star reviews objecting primarily to the fact that the novel (which no one had yet read) was set in Russia and would be published at a time when Russia and Ukraine were at war. There is most likely no way to eliminate personal attacks entirely from the site but having more human beings on hand to mitigate the damage would certainly improve the experience.

Fortifying the guard rails wouldn’t be that difficult. Currently Goodreads uses volunteer librarians who add new books to the site’s database in their free time. Hiring these people (and scores more like them) and paying them a living wage would empower Goodreads’s representatives to communicate with publishers, large and small, to facilitate posting books to the site when, and only when, a book has actually been written and edited and is ready to be shared with the world.

Given all of Goodreads’s issues, it might seem easy enough to encourage writers and readers simply to flock to another forum. Sites like The Storygraph and Italic Type have sprung up as promising alternatives, but they’re still far from reaching a critical mass of users.

As a book critic and publishing professional, I’ve spent much of my career trying to encourage rousing conversations about the literary arts in whatever venues I could find, digital or analog. Maybe that’s why I’m still committed to the idea that Goodreads, or a place like it, must exist. As the usefulness of other social platforms deteriorates, this one is worth trying to save.

Maris Kreizman is a book critic and the host of the podcast “The Maris Review.”

The New York Times



Landmark Bus Tours, Folk Arts, and Stargazing Draw Crowds to 'Wasm Hail' Cultural Festival

The program features traditional camel processions, folk arts, stage and musical performances, handicraft stalls, exhibition pavilions, and classic car displays - SPA
The program features traditional camel processions, folk arts, stage and musical performances, handicraft stalls, exhibition pavilions, and classic car displays - SPA
TT

Landmark Bus Tours, Folk Arts, and Stargazing Draw Crowds to 'Wasm Hail' Cultural Festival

The program features traditional camel processions, folk arts, stage and musical performances, handicraft stalls, exhibition pavilions, and classic car displays - SPA
The program features traditional camel processions, folk arts, stage and musical performances, handicraft stalls, exhibition pavilions, and classic car displays - SPA

The Wasm Hail events at Al-Qishlah Palace in Hail have welcomed thousands of residents and tourists from within the region and beyond to enjoy a diverse array of experiences blending heritage, culture, and entertainment.

The program features traditional camel processions, folk arts, stage and musical performances, handicraft stalls, exhibition pavilions, and classic car displays. A dedicated tourist bus service also offers guided tours of landmarks, SPA reported.

Adding an educational dimension, the festival includes an astronomical experience enabling visitors to observe the moon and planets through optical telescopes and safely view the sun via specialized solar telescopes, highlighting Hail's diverse cultural and tourism assets.


A Long-Buried Ancient Library in Rome Opens to the Public After Restoration

 Marble archaeological remains from the western library of Trajan's Forum, which archaeologists believe may have housed the ancient Bibliotheca Ulpia, one of ancient Rome's most important libraries, are displayed during a press preview of the restored site in Rome, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. (AP)
Marble archaeological remains from the western library of Trajan's Forum, which archaeologists believe may have housed the ancient Bibliotheca Ulpia, one of ancient Rome's most important libraries, are displayed during a press preview of the restored site in Rome, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. (AP)
TT

A Long-Buried Ancient Library in Rome Opens to the Public After Restoration

 Marble archaeological remains from the western library of Trajan's Forum, which archaeologists believe may have housed the ancient Bibliotheca Ulpia, one of ancient Rome's most important libraries, are displayed during a press preview of the restored site in Rome, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. (AP)
Marble archaeological remains from the western library of Trajan's Forum, which archaeologists believe may have housed the ancient Bibliotheca Ulpia, one of ancient Rome's most important libraries, are displayed during a press preview of the restored site in Rome, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. (AP)

The famed Alexandria Library in Egypt may have been lost, but another of the ancient world's repositories for texts has been restored in Rome and is reopening to the public this week.

The ruins of the Ulpia library are located in Emperor Trajan’s Forum, just next to the iconic column that celebrates his victorious campaigns against the Dacians and the Roman conquest of what is modern-day Romania. It remained inaccessible for almost a century.

“After the Alexandria Library of Egypt, after the Library of Pergamon in Asia Minor, this one in the Trajan’s Forum was certainly one of the most important, given both the number of ‘volumina,’ as books were called in ancient times, and the quantity of documents," Claudio Parisi Presicce, an archaeologist and Rome's superintendent for cultural heritage, said in an interview with The Associated Press.

The place was in a state of ruin when discovered in 1932 during clearing works by Benito Mussolini's government for the road that became the famous Via dei Fori Imperiali. Later, it was covered in concrete and used as a storage room for some of the countless pieces from Trajan's Forum, the last and greatest of the imperial fora, built in 112 AD.

But the niches in its walls were evidently spots to set cabinets for scrolls, signaling that this was one of the two, two-story buildings comprising the Ulpia library referenced in ancient texts, Presicce said.

Archaeologists from Rome's superintendency for cultural heritage identify it as the Ulpia library's western building, which ancient texts indicate stored Greek-language scrolls.

The new permanent exhibition offers visitors an idea of the space as it used to be, featuring the remains of some of the library’s rich marble decorations — white for the walls, and different colors for its floor and columns. Immersive videomapping is also projected on its walls, showing the history of the library and its discovery. Instead of scroll-filled cabinets, spread throughout the space today are broken Corinthian columns and pieces of sculptures.

The library was a fundamental part of the Forum, and a place that for centuries attracted citizens from all over Rome with its vast collection of edicts and documents.

“The libraries were used by both common citizens, those who could afford a certain cultural level and a better education than those from the lower classes, but also by magistrates who needed access to older documents, or needed to check the norms that regulated the life of the community,” he said.

Restoration started in 2025, and lasted about a year. The 1.75-million-euro cost ($1.92 million) came from the European Union’s pandemic recovery funds — just one of many restoration projects Rome is carrying out across the city with EU money.

It will initially be opened to visitors only on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays. Visits are scheduled every 40 minutes, 20 people at a time.

The library's eastern building remains buried beneath an 18th-century church, on the other side of Trajan's Forum, and stored Latin-language scrolls. There are no plans for its excavation.


Afghan Tradition Keeps Grapes Fresh for Winter Treat

This photograph taken on November 10, 2026 shows Afghan farmer Muhammad Saber Shojaei seal packing grapes in mud-and-straw discs known as Kanginas before storing them in a dark room in the Kalakan district of Kabul province. (AFP)
This photograph taken on November 10, 2026 shows Afghan farmer Muhammad Saber Shojaei seal packing grapes in mud-and-straw discs known as Kanginas before storing them in a dark room in the Kalakan district of Kabul province. (AFP)
TT

Afghan Tradition Keeps Grapes Fresh for Winter Treat

This photograph taken on November 10, 2026 shows Afghan farmer Muhammad Saber Shojaei seal packing grapes in mud-and-straw discs known as Kanginas before storing them in a dark room in the Kalakan district of Kabul province. (AFP)
This photograph taken on November 10, 2026 shows Afghan farmer Muhammad Saber Shojaei seal packing grapes in mud-and-straw discs known as Kanginas before storing them in a dark room in the Kalakan district of Kabul province. (AFP)

On the outskirts of Afghanistan's frenetic capital Kabul, Muhammad Saber Shojaei is carrying out a centuries-old task of preserving fistfuls of grapes to be eaten when winter bites.

Crouched in front of dozens of "kanginas", clay-and-straw discs containing grapes, Shojaei recalls his father, who taught him the technique.

"I remember the old days, when we sat together around the sandali (stove), eating kangina grapes and enjoying those happy moments," said the 47-year-old from Kalakan district.

Carefully putting a bunch of grapes in one of the discs, Shojaei added a second disc on top and sealed the kangina with mud before placing it in a dark storage room.

"In this way, kanginas can keep grapes fresh from now until the spring," said the farmer, who makes about 700 each year to sell by the roadside.

No one knows quite how long kanginas have been used in Afghanistan, with estimates starting at "centuries" and the knowledge passed down through the generations.

This photograph taken on November 10, 2026 shows Kanginas, a traditional preserving method made from clay mud and straw used to keep grapes fresh for up to six months, in a storage inside of a house in the Kalakan district of Kabul province. (AFP)

During harvest season, grapes for sale can be seen bundled in big plastic bags, or piled high onto trucks as they're taken to markets further afield.

But such abundance comes with problems in Afghanistan, where cold storage to keep produce fresh is severely limited and the export route to Pakistan has been cut off by cross-border conflict.

Farhad Ezati, a 21-year-old trader, said "farmers can't even cover their costs" this year as grape prices have plummeted by 70 percent due to the border closure causing a supply glut.

Standing in a bright green field while laborers packed grapes into cardboard boxes, Ezati said competition among sellers is incredibly tough.

"Afghan grapes are the best," he said, his face brightening. "They're really high in quality... and have a really good taste."

- 'Keep our culture alive' -

Labor-intensive and fragile, kanginas cannot overcome large-scale storage or trade problems.

But in the depths of winter, Afghans living near the vineyards can buy them along the roadside or in nearby markets, and farming families can crack them open and enjoy fresh grapes.

Gulagha Frotan, a community leader in Kalakan, said people wait until snow or rain to enjoy them.

"We don't wash the grapes because they might lose their natural quality. We only blow away the dust, or shake them gently, and then they're ready to eat," the 61-year-old told AFP.

This photograph taken on November 10, 2026 shows an Afghan farmer carrying harvested fresh Taifi grapes in a vineyard in the Kalakan district of Kabul province. (AFP)

Despite its long history in the Kabul area, the practice is currently only being used in one other province, neighboring Parwan, according to the UN's Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO).

The agency's Ezatullah Noori said that, along with the cool weather, the large population in the area means that farmers don't have to travel far to sell the kanginas.

"There's potential for farmers to sell some of their grapes, rather than to lose them during the peak production season," said Noori, FAO's emergency and resilience team leader in Afghanistan.

He called for scientific research to better understand such unique heritage, as well as an organized effort to help farmers cooperate to sell their kanginas on a larger scale.

"I am afraid that one day this will disappear from our country and nobody will know how to make it," Noori told AFP.

"We should keep our culture alive."