Mishary Dhayidi
Saudi journalist and writer
TT

Who is Stealing from Whom: Artificial Intelligence or its Creators?

In universities, research centers, and even schools, there is strict vigilance against plagiarism and academic theft. The emergence of artificial intelligence has only heightened these concerns. Students, including the laziest among them, can now produce sophisticated research papers with the click of a button. Even professors can do the same. The case of British Cambridge University professor Jason Arday, who reportedly took his own life, is still fresh in memory.

But wait: who is stealing from whom?

In a discussion with some friends about the uses and future of artificial intelligence and its relationship with us as human beings, the conversation turned to AI's sources. Where does AI obtain the information that enables it to provide this answer or that one, this study or that research paper?

Where does this AI creature draw its water from? Where does it find its food? Where does it breathe its oxygen from?
For example, if a student asks AI to write a paper on the history of Riyadh, would not Riyadh Through the Stages of History, by the renowned Arabian Peninsula scholar Hamad Al-Jasser, be among its most important sources?

If someone uses AI to write a novel about the neighborhoods of Cairo in the early twentieth century, would Naguib Mahfouz's celebrated Cairo Trilogy not be a fundamental source?

If an AI user wanted to write about the history of Iraq, would works by historians and intellectuals such as Abbas Al-Azzawi, Abdul Razzaq Al-Hasani, Ali Al-Wardi, and others not serve as primary wells from which this consumer of information and data drinks?

These brief examples bring me to the following news story:

Several months ago, around one hundred British authors demonstrated outside the London headquarters of the American tech giant Meta, accusing the company of "stealing" their works to train its AI models.

Protesters chanted, "Meta, Meta, book thief," while holding signs criticizing the company's founder, Mark Zuckerberg.
The authors expressed particular concern over Meta's alleged use of the online library LibGen, which promotes free and open access to academic knowledge. The platform contains more than 7.5 million books and scholarly articles.

Earlier this year, more than a thousand British artists also condemned a proposal by the Labour government to relax copyright restrictions, making it easier for AI companies to use copyrighted content.

If artificial intelligence were stripped of its free and unrestricted access to these articles, studies, and books, how would it generate results for you?

These books, along with newspapers, magazines, television content, and news agency reports, are the products of significant investment, effort, and expertise. They belong to their creators, whether individuals or institutions. How, then, can this appropriation by artificial intelligence be justified?

I realize it is still early for the establishment of binding laws governing the use of artificial intelligence. Yet these examples and these questions are merely the beginning of what lies ahead.