Ghassan Charbel
Editor-in-Chief of Asharq Al-Awsat newspaper
TT

The ‘Three Musketeers’ and the Chinese Rendezvous

This week is unlike any other. You cannot escape its developments. Do not use an exciting football match as an excuse, nor claim to be consumed by the troubles of the Strait of Hormuz, caught among tankers, destroyers, and generals. The approaching date will inevitably overshadow news from Jurf al-Sakhar and the actions of factions that drones have transformed into roving mini-regional powers. The same holds true for the tactics of swift death and the dance of poverty and war in the Horn of Africa.

The spectacle is certainly more gripping than watching Eisenkot try to sweep away the traps set for him by the chief wolf on the Israeli stage. The world will also look away from tech stars cheating on their wives, especially the latest chapter involving Nvidia’s former CEO who was entangled with a Chinese spy.

In the land of the alleged spy, the “Three Musketeers” will gather around a single table. The world has not witnessed such a scene in decades. Those meeting are well into the age of wisdom, unburdened by salacious files like the infidelity scandals that dogged Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, and Jensen Huang. The youngest among them is Xi Jinping, at 73; Vladimir Putin was born a year earlier, and Donald Trump preceded him by seven.

Yet, the absence of personal scandals does not mean an absence of appetites: Trump wants victory in Iran and Cuba and a Nobel Peace Prize; Putin wants a fifth of Ukraine and vengeance for the Soviet Union; and Xi is trying to rein in his eagerness to return Taiwan, so he may surpass his sole rival, Mao Zedong, in the history books.

Three men and three stories. When news of the meeting was announced, analysts were quick to recall the 1945 gathering of the “Big Three” in Yalta during the final chapter of World War II. The name Yalta resonates not only because the summit’s participants discussed the division of spheres of influence and the future of Europe, but also because it lies on the Crimean Peninsula, which the current czar captured in 2014.

Three men sat at Yalta: Franklin Roosevelt arriving from the White House, Joseph Stalin from the Kremlin, and Winston Churchill from 10 Downing Street. Any recollection of the Yalta summit immediately leads to the observation that the leader of a rising China now sits in the seat of the man once regarded as the leader of “Great Britain.” It is no secret that the post-World War II world drained Britain of its greatness, and like its rival France, it took the path of gradual descent into second-tier clubs.

It is no exaggeration to say that today’s Europe cannot ignore the name of the Chinese president, yet can afford to forget the name of the prime minister of Britain, France, or Spain. Those gathering for the trilateral meeting saw no need to reserve a fourth seat for the “Old Continent,” which Putin struck through Ukraine and whom Trump is now stepping in to reward with a piece of Zelenskyy’s country. Nor was there any thought of leaving a seat for India, which has yet to prove it can stand as a reliable alternative to the Chinese empire.

There is no doubt that today’s world is sick. A state of uncertainty hangs over its political climate and economic conditions - something akin to driving through dense fog without brakes, now that international law has lost its ability to warn and deter. The world is sick and needs a panel of doctors to contain its conflicts, reassure its economy, rationalize the frenzied rollout of artificial intelligence, and turn its attention back to environmental calamities.

However, there is no reason to indulge in illusions. The Three Musketeers do not belong at all to the ranks of devout saints who prefer renunciation over acquisition. Their occasionally fine phrases are not enough to conceal their appetites.

In their seventies, politicians turn their eyes toward history and their place in it, even while still holding the reins of fate and the seals of power. Each participant in the trilateral summit stands to gain something from it. The man sitting on Mao’s throne can say that China has become an obligatory gateway for any discussion about the future of the world, and that the era of sidelining or weakening it is over and gone.

He can say that Washington has come to realize that Moscow is no substitute for Beijing, and that the true heir to the Soviet Union is China, not Russia, with one major difference: a massive technological arsenal that Stalin’s heirs lacked. Xi can also say that his country is advancing with a language of responsible diplomacy that resembles neither Russian nuclear saber-rattling nor Trump’s threats to obliterate others.

Putin also stands to gain. The trilateral summit serves as Chinese and American recognition that Russia has not been reduced to a mere regional power, even if it has had to turn to its Chinese “comrades” for support. Russia still holds significant cards, including its vast nuclear arsenal and its ability to influence energy prices. Putin can claim that the war in Ukraine has placed his country in European rather than international isolation, and that he is, in practice, closer to the master of the White House than is the occupant of the Elysee Palace. The balance of power did not allow Putin to bring the “traitorous republics” back into the “Soviet fold,” so he has settled for a modest revival of the dream of expanding Russia, following in the footsteps of Peter the Great and Catherine the Great.

Trump, returning wounded from the midterm elections, also has something to gain. He not only has the ability to speak with China and Russia, but also to take part in a trilateral dance addressing global affairs, as well as nuclear and economic concerns. He can speak of his attachment to diplomacy and the language of the deal, despite intense rivalry with China and its ambiguous stance on the war with Iran.

We are not in the aftermath of a world war for the globe to be treated as a mold for the powerful to carve up among themselves. Even so, the meeting of the “Three Musketeers” in China remains useful for easing tensions and keeping the window for dialogue open, despite the greed of the participants and their nations.